Who is Red John?

Theories of MissStiles (23)

Stop posting about me you idiot Stoopkid!

You have already ruined this site for everyone over the last few months! And I do like The Mentalist and always will but that doesn't mean that everyone has to agree with your idiotic theories.

I'm never coming back here because of you so you achieved the power you always wanted. Congratulations.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I want to say sorry to Stoopkid, he really is a nice guy deep down.:) There is no reason we all can't live in peace..He is a bit obsessed with The Mentalist but so were we in the past.:) 
So I apologize to Stoopkid and I hope you don't mind if I sometimes talk about Sherlock.:)) And about Kevin Corrigan, my dear friend.:D

Love and peace, let's all love eachother and accept eachother as we are..:) xx

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I love Benedict Cumberbatch!! I never thought I will have a different favourite TV detective other than Patrick Jane, but unfortunately I do now..:(

PS; I'm glad people here are starting to realize that you can talk about other things besides Stoopkid's weird theories..:)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #17031 • By MissStiles
Show this theory

One last attempt to convince all the stubborn people who STILL think McAllister wasn't Red John. This feels like talking to kindergarten children..

McAllister was absolutely terrified of dying. All he had to do was tell Patrick Jane the truth (that he wasn't RJ) and he could have lived (which McAllister wanted more than anything).
Jane is not stupid, he would have believed him if he started telling the truth. McAllister could have saved himself. He didn't, because he is Red John. He knew Patrick knows it, he knew there is no point of denying it.

If anyone doesn't understand that, then you have the mental age of a child.

I don't care if I get 30 dislikes, just use your logic and common sense people! Peace.:)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

OMG, this was the worst episode I've ever seen!! So boring, uninteresting, total disappointment..Even the Red John episode was better, LOL. At least that one had Rigsby, Van Pelt and the old team..I'm devastated about what this show is becoming!! Horrible, boring, average! Very upsetting.
Even Jane wasn't enough to keep me interested..Come on guys, I can't believe anyone liked this mess...
Bring back the 'old' people, Partridge, Stiles, Haffner, Kirkland etc..Otherwise this show is dead.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Do we know if Red John was only a member of Visualize when he was young in the 80s or if he was in the cult even as a 'grown up'? 
I don't know why but I always thought Red John had some kind of respect for Bret Stiles especially if he was still in Visualize and that he would never kill his 'guru'. But McAllister didn't even care about killing him for a second. Maybe I'm too sentimental because in my mind even if RJ is a psycho, he wouldn't kill the person who helped him so much in the past that easily.:D 

So either: Red John is not McAllister and/or Bret Stiles is alive, or: he was McAllister, Bret Stiles is dead and this is just one of the million things that we didn't get an explanation for..I hope it's the first option. I want Bret Stiles to be alive so much!:)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

What's happened to Erica Flynn?? She was hot on The Mentalist but on Homeland she is really frumpy with horrible hair and her whole face has changed..Not very attractive! Strange..:D

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on