Who is Red John?
EN - FR

Theories of RED_LUTZ (50)

I apologize for my insensitive Moriarty comment.  I in no way would ever want another human being to hurt themselves ever.  I felt like I was being bullied and picked on and I lashed out without thinking  .    I just wanted to share my theories with other Mentalist fans who enjoy the show as much as I do and was hurt by some people's comments     I hate bullies and I didn't mean to do the exact same thing     I apologize to anyone I offended with all my heart                                      peace and love  peace and love

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely



If it's not BA, RJ or a RJ follower    do you really give a fuck?     some random asshole with some bullshit made up motive        would that make you happy?         expect a whole bunch of red herrings that don't add up to shit          who on the FBI team is gonna double cross ?        I bet everyone on the show will now be a suspect   but don't bother guessing based on "clues"   cause Heller will just pull a name out of a hat                                                                                     don't want to be a troll so I'll just say                                                                                                                                

   *I loved the way Red John's identity was revealed --thrilling and perfectly executed--very satisfying I love that it was McAllister        *and this New Beginning is a breath of fresh air -- I love all the new characters and the new murders have kept me on the edge of my seat  guessing till the very end --- I love this brand new Jane      thank God RJ is dead           I bet this new CBI serial killer story is gonna be better than RJ saga ever was          Bruno Heller is a genius                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          


      and for the love of fuck stop posting Sherlock spoilers       




 if you wanna compare The Mentalist to another show it should be LOST        they didn't answer any questions and the last season ruined the entire series                                   if season 6 ends without even a RJ mention it will go down as the biggest ball drop in TV's history                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   they just should have ended the RJ story on a high note with Timothy Carter  then seasons 4 & 5 could have been the BA as the main villain and season 6 could have been the CBI serial killer     the show ends with some dignity and enough episodes to make syndication                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 if you are just gonna cut up my theories in the comments section at least post your own theory as a response     





IF YOU BELIEVE RED JOHN IS DEAD THAT'S FINE BUT WHO DO YOU THINK IS KILLING CBI AGENTS ?    LET'S HEAR WHAT YOU HAVE TO SAY YOU UNORIGINAL FUCK    






    if you come on this site and don't post any theories and all you do is cut up other people's posts  than you should just pull a Moriarty. . .  . . . . . .. . .and by that I mean put a gun in your mouth and pull the trigger                     

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This "new" serial killer is one of three things   1- The B.A.  2- A Red John Follower/copycat  3- or Red John                             1-I don't think it was the B.A.- they are just blackmailed cops and Abbott says the FBI took down the rest of B.A.                  2- it could be a RJ desciple looking for revenge   but why kill ex CBI agents two years after CBI was disbanded and not just kill Jane first     3-  I pry to God it's RJ and he isn't using the smiley face cause he still wants Jane and the world to think McAllister was RJ and is dead                                 but Red John said he was going to start killing often and Haffner warned Lisbon    and he also threatened Jane          off the top of my head I don't remember seeing one RJ smiley face this season          what if RJ hasn't actually killed anyone this entire series and the real Red John is now killing everyone on the CBI list       every RJ murder is either a copycat killing or by a RJ follower like Timothy Carter or McAllister                                  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

     I'm now 100% that McAllister was not Red John           are you convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt that McAllister was Red John?    I'm not ....not even close          McAllister didn't act like Red John he acted like someone who was being forced through BA to impersonate Red John and kill Jane .......instead his fear of birds gets him shot and he starts crying, runs away  and collapses          claims to be a psychic???? ...........fuckin calls 9-1-1???   LMFAO                     look back to Timothy Carter   when he was "playing" Red John he told Jane he was going to retire and he was giving Jane advice about moving on and forgetting  but instead Jane shot him dead in public      Red John wanted to give him some peace of mind and help him move on     by the end of season 4 Red John wants Jane to join him       and when RJ planted a fake Red John on the list of 7 knowing that Jane would probably get the best of him and think that he got his revenge and move on with his life and find peace and finally be happy   and Jane did ......for two years         why did he really come back?   he knew Abbott was going to fuck him over   he wanted to work for the FBI      I think within the two year time jump Red John reveals himself to Jane now that Jane has his guard down and is relaxed      taunts him and just leaves  while Jane vows to hunt him down   The Real Red John just laughs at him      gone             then after a few more new beginning murder of the week episodes   there will be a flashback episode that shows what happened at Jane's house before the explosion and what really went on during those two years      the rest of the season is Patrick Jane and the FBI vs the Real Red John        the average viewers and the Jisbons get to see a RJ-less Mentalist for a handful of episodes      and the creative team behind the show get to do something new       but let's face it Red John is The Mentalist  and without him there is no show       I can feel the set up      there is no way they can keep up this new beginning story till the end of the season without Red John coming back      RJ sent in McAllister as another Timothy Carter to give Jane some peace of mind       I think the Rigsby's have something to do with this and when Red John returns Jane will have the FBI behind him and not the corrupt CBI that RJ owns      

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If Timothy Carter was a fake Red John than why can't McAllister be a fake Red John?                                             get over it???  it's only been 3 episodes and the season isn't even half over you funkin dumb cunt                                       I bet you watched episode 11 with all your cats and was captivated by the Jane romancing the blonde story and was so shocked she was the murderer you dropped your knitting needles           you have the balls to come on a web site called WHO IS RED JOHN? and call the people who are posting theories about who Red John might be pathetic     go fuck yourself       better yet stop hoping for the Jisbon storyline nobody wants and go suck a bowl of dicks              







                                                                                                     
 
 















LOL 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Nothing gets 'em wet on a first date like telling her you killed a man with your bare hands                                 first Jane sleeps with a RJ disciple then tries to pick up an undercover FBI agent and lastly goes on a date with a drug lord murderer   way to move on from your murdered carnie wife                                Cho was romancing a hooker          Lisbon had a one night stand with a Billionaire suspected of murder      and Van Pelt was dating a RJ disciple                                                              Has anyone listen to the Podcast TV Talk :The Mentalist   what a couple of fuckin morons   they just love this new beginning and everything is a shocker                                        Stoopkid and I could probably put on a better show       just sayin            

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #17024 • By RED_LUTZ
Show this theory

I think Red John is more than one person(Stiles/Haffner or Partridge/Kirkland)  or a group of people(a sub-cult within Visulize)        mark my words one of the FBI team is a RJ disciple      I don't believe RJ would have the BA tattoo  that would be idiotic              I've always suspected Van Pelt of being a RJ disciple and Visulize member             

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on