Who is Red John?

Theories of krobhag (25)

Theory #18124 • By krobhag
Show this theory

Just want to get a sense of how we are feeling.

This cold case....will it be:

(plausible) a case we are familiar with, care about and is plot-relevant 

or 

(implausible) a stone-cold plot device.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm sorry...but no.  This is just unacceptable.  The proposal...the promo.  No one could possibly be happy about the direction this is going.  I'd call it cliche, but that is offensive to cliches, who have their place.  This is just...wrong.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

http://tvline.com/2014/05/09/the-mentalist-season-6-preview-jane-lisbon-finale/

Doesn't look like anyone posted this yet.  Interview with Heller, Tunney, and Baker published today.  

My favorite line:
Heller: Sometimes I think I’m way too dumb for this audience, to come up with clever solutions like that. 


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For what it’s worth, I thought this was a great episode.

Let’s talk metaphors, shall we?

The grand jury is a metaphor for show.  The prosecutor is accused for being deceitful in order to ensure the defendant gets acquitted.  The jury is innocent but being led astray.  Jane says that it isn't that she is excluding or falsifying evidence but rather that the deceit is in how she tells the story.  She isn’t lying, but allowing the jury to believe something false by telling her story “halfheartedly” and “lacking confidence.”

We accuse Heller and co. of lying and falsifying clues about Red John when he gave us a disappointing reveal.  But, perhaps, his true misdirection is in the “halfhearted” way he has closed the Red John story and thereby lulling us into believing something that is false.  It’s not a con….its a sting.  ;)  (Ok, it is a con, but a good one.)

Speaking of halved hearts, if we are going to get any information about Red John it will be in “Black Hearts”.  Yes, the title is a reference to the black market hearts cut out of those poor women.  But, let’s not forget that in previous seasons the episodes didn’t always have “red” in them.  Sometimes it was just things that are usually red...like blood or roses.  Having obvious linkages between the title and the story in both yesterday’s and next week’s episodes distracts us from this.  

This whole human trafficking arc has me feeling uneasy and suspicious.  First “bow and arrow” and now a system of tattoos?  Both things were introduced awkwardly and both too obviously mirror the clues we got about the Blake Association. In “Brown Eyed Girls”, we briefly saw this Ridley fellow - we are meant to believe that he is the big baddie but I, as I usually am,  am suspicious.  

We will just have to wait and see.  We know that Red John had access to high risk women (from people like Jason Lennon and Miriam Gottlieb) and we don’t understand fully the circumstances under which he killed Lorelei’s sister.  There is potential for a tie-in of some kind with this arc.

Just so long as I don't have to endure Jane telling Lisbon to "get on that plane" in the finale episode, I'll be all right.  Not just because I'll be sad about them parting ways but because I could never accept such a heavy handed reference.  But Casablanca is a truly great movie.  If you've never seen it, you should drop everything and go watch it.  (Also, blanca = bianca = white.)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Question:  We first meet Kirkland back when Lisbon is investigating Volker, right?   We know why "homeland" was investigating Red John (personal vendetta), but did we ever figure out why Kirkland was warning Lisbon off Volker?  


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Pike/Lisbon/Jane love triangle is progressing in the most predictable way imaginable. What do you guys think of the idea of Pike actually being a red herring...i.e. a fake boyfriend?

Jane is the one who suggested that his unit help out the Art squad.  Since when does Jane go out of his way to help anyone.  And Lisbon was incredibly flirtatious with him in that stolen art room.  

What if the whole relationship is a fake for the benefit of the prying eyes within the FBI?  Everyone there thinks there is something between Jane and Lisbon.  Lisbon threatening to leave for DC gives Jane a plausible excuse for going off the deep end and breaking the rules...thus leading to this grand jury indictment.  

What if that was the plan all along?  Ingratiate himself with the FBI - gain their trust. Then force the FBI's hand to get him indicted, thus giving him a public platform to.....do....something.  Not sure what.  

Grasping at straws I know...but it is a fun idea.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There is this ridiculous ad campaign for Longines (a watch company).  Simon Baker is looking at a horse. It is really weird.  But...it DID remind me of something.

Jane now regularly wears a wristwatch.  He never used to before Season 6 right?  I'd say that it is a mentalist 2.0 addition but he wore a watch on "Red John".  Weird, right?

http://tvfilmnews.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/Simon-Baker-as-Patrick-Jane.jpg

Time seems to be a big theme of this season.  


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on