1. Haibach tried to cut off Jane's finger because Bob Kirkland did it to him

2. Red John instructed Lorelei to cut of Jane's finger prior to this

Could it be that particular RJ on that particular day was Michael Kirkland?  Not hard to figure out where the Kirkland twins might have picked up this bad habit up considering their upbringing

3.  Mikey K.  could easily have been a youth at the barn who got straightened out [alcoholism] through Visualize and RJ

--- only problem is that while we know RJ's smiley face is on the Visualize barn -- Heller didn't bother to give us the connection between McAllister and Visualize, but then I guess that's not SURPRISING considering there are more holes in the Red John story than in a extra large sized colander 

Please Heller, take us somewhere we've been before and EXPLAIN why the F you took us there in the first place!!