Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Personally, I don't think it is anyone on the list. The clue I think in episode one at the end wasn't what anyone did but rather the location/setting of what took place.  Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p43ysF_NFI8 Patrick and Minelli talk about a murder victim who was in an "abandoned house" (just like where Partridge was killed) Red John could have been trying to jog Patrick's brain about that particular conversation in season 6. The voices of Minelli and Bosco sound like they could be Red John with a tad bit of inflection on their part. Comparing body type and hair to the Red John Promo vid for the next episode I'd say it's more like Minelli. Also, Minelli was there from the beginning.  The pigeons....well, could mean "message" as in messenger pigeon.  This was the message Minelli was trying to send to Patrick.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok, if I HAD to chose one of the two left, I would say it's Reede Smith.

We saw a side to him we hadn't really seen before. He handed himself in. Now some might say "so he can't be red john", he could. RJ is a very smart person, right now he is panicking more than he has probably ever had to before. He is manipulating, he could probably manipulate PJ if he really wanted to.

PJ was making a point of saying he could tell when people were lying by being face to face with them, this is true, but RJ is not your average person, he know exactly how to use the skills he has, he is being backed in to a corner and what better way to hide yourself than being right in front of them.

I think they want us to now think it's Bertram, which is why I don't think it is. The last episode really turned things around for me because I did originally think it was Bertram for reasons I have explained before.

Now, if it's not one of the two, then it could really be any of them. Partridge is dead, people need to realise that, he's said himself in interviews, he is most certainly dead. People are hanging on to him being RJ and he was a good candidate but let it go people!

I would say either the Sherriff or Kirkland.

So to sum it up, it could be any of them really lol.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Here's me going out on a whacky limb. Rewatching the end of ep 7, the "wait, Don't" voice sound like Malcom McDowell to me.

Anyone else think that? Maybe Hafner pulls a secondary gun and McDowell is telling him not to shoot?

I'm not saying who might be RJ, but that's a possible scenario for the house.

I also think there will have to be a flashback scene in ep 8 to explain what happened at the house..why was the shot gun originally placed just-so. Who shot the shot? Who's body parts were there? What did Jane really plan or find out there or before that scene? Did Jane coordinate with and trust one of those 5?

Could be interesting if he actually ended up ruling out Hafner and Stiles and trusted them in the end.... Or maybe he trusted one and not the other, or he trusted McAllister...Def needs a flashback......

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #12747 • By oment
Show this theory

Maybe that was the clue for Michael at the end of s06e01:

http://imgur.com/iX4pWUf

Kirkland was in Los Angeles.
Michael is one of the seven archangels in Hebrew tradition.
In Hebrew, Michael means "who is like God?".

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think at this point, I’m not trying to figure out who RJ
is but, rather, what Patrick’s whole ruse is. It seems to me that everything I've
seen in the last 2 episodes from arranging the meeting of the remaining
suspects to the detailed report Cho gave Lisbon at the hospital to the FBI
clearing out the CBI have all been part of Patrick’s plan.

I re-watched the latest episode, paying closer attention to
the opening scene in PJ’s house. Something about the sly smiles and looks to
the side McAllister gives makes me think he was working with someone else,
someone who was outside the house.  



I’m not even so sure any of the suspects really died in the
explosion, just because the scene looked so staged. (I mean, c’mon a bare, cleanly severed foot just lying there? What happened to the sock and shoe? That’s one
discriminating bomb!) Like it was set up in a way for witnesses to have their focus
thrown off by random body parts so no one would wonder why half the people were
unscathed and the other half crispy.



From years of watching Dexter, I learned that you can NEVER
rely on promos! They are always edited to look like something major and
exciting is afoot, when in reality it’s just an innocuous image unrelated to
what you think is happening. So, having said that, yes, I believe it’s McAllister
we see jumping through the window in next week's promo; no, I don’t think that means he is RJ.  From the still he appears to have been shot.
And if you believe the promo, he met Patrick at the church, was shot by
Patrick, was chased by Patrick through the cemetery then crashes through the
glass door, in that order. But did it really go down that way?



Prior to the explosion at Patrick’s house, we hear “No! Wait”
before a gunshot that, to me, sounded more like a handgun than a shotgun. What
if someone in that room had a backup weapon, like many law enforcement officials
do? The “no wait” was a genuine exclamation because it was not part of Patrick’s
plan. (He often miscalculates whether people are armed or not). So the shot… maybe
McAllister pointing his gun at Patrick but shooting in the air as a signal for
his partner to detonate the bomb?   




I think the theme of Resurrection is key. RJ is going to be someone
“coming back from the dead.” So, who’s living the zombie life?... McAllister? It would seem as much, given the
promo for next week. Stiles? Perhaps…in
flashbacks or as his reincarnated self. Partridge? I certainly hope not!

Unfortunately, I think it’s going to be
Kirkland… Michael Kirkland.  It was the tea cup breaking that brought me
to him. The somewhat defeated look on Patrick's face isn't because he broke his
favorite cup, but because the bumped arm jogged his memory to when he first met
Michael who was pretending to be Bob. (05x07) Kirkland bumped into Patrick who
was holding his teacup. He said, “Sorry Mr. Jane” and Patrick asked him, “Do I
know you?” You can see the look on Michael’s face, realizing he had slipped up
in assuming Bob already knew Patrick.  




BH said RJ is “someone on the list” --- technically, Michael’s
picture is on the list --- and that we would be disappointed with who it is---the
evil twin cliche IS disappointing if you aren't watching a soap opera. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #12741 • By evangs
Show this theory

In the next episode RJ is heard saying "I won". In that sense, who seems to have PJ beaten? Reede Smith, whom when PJ looked in the eyes; he could not identify as RJ.
Bertram wants Reede dead because RJ is not the leader of tyger tyger but only a nuisance at this time.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For sake of argument, I accept that RJ could still be any of the 7 suspects except for Reed or Bertram. Id rule Partridge out too, but to many people go crazy for him and might hurt them selves if it isn't him, so I wont. Please add more to this list as I am sure to have missed a few of the crazier theories/ideas...Also no offense if these are your theories. It is only my take after all...

What I will say, is here are some of the theories or comment I think are the most far fetched:

1. Partridge, twice confirmed dead is still alive. Maybe he is, but if so, it should be considered as a really weak/dull plot twist.

2. Fear of pigeons. Reall, are we going to find out that a huge glaring clue was that one of the characters fear of PIGEONS was a major plot point?

3. Ep 7 announces Bertram as ep 7 and titilates us to keep guessing in ep 8 who really is RJ and then it still ends up being no twist--Bertram. That would be pretty week.

4. RJ is not one serial killer but a title that three or more people share. That would be lame.

5. #4 plus one of those Red Johns being the son of Brett Stiles (He's old so defacto he must be RJ's father.

6. The man in the church in the promo is Mashburn because its the exact same hair...oh boy, nice try, that could be anyone.

7. Van Pelt is Red John

8. Craig Loughlin is the most hung of all characters...Well this one might be true. he is hot and does look like he swings a big stick...

9. Summer is not a dirty ho... please she has had more dingdongs in her than a urinal at the Cheesecake Factory.

10. So and so has the exact voice of RJ...yeah thats the thing thats going to connect us to the culprit...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on