Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

For those whove been more attentive than me, there was a spoiler here earlier about a stuntman confirming he was McAllisters stunt man and that McAllister is RJ. Did others see this? Has it been confirmed or debunked? I hope its not a true spoiler. I'd be fine with McAllister, but I don't want to know know it before the episode. Say it aint so. I want to be tricked!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

RJ is the couch carrier. how did he know to stop and hand PJ the coins? why did he hand PJ coins in one of the important parts of the show? why would the writers waste time putting this small scene in if it did not have meaning. we are going to find out this guy has been in several shows thru the years in the background that very few of us noticed. the list of 7 is just fluff so they will have a storyline to continue with once RJ is revealed. they want a next season. this guy was from texas and knew to hand the change to PJ from the couch? he was there only a few seconds and stops and hands it to PJ with all the other people there. im not sure how all the dots connect but if will be fun watching. thanks!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Anyone else starting to think that many of the abusive comments the BP theorists have been getting (e.g. "BP is dead, get over it idiots") is coming from one general direction for one particular reason? Makes ya say, hmmm...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Partridge is dead . They deff checked his body but the mark on his arm is weird . Did he do it and was planning on leaving tiger tiger ? Did tt kill him and scratch off evidence or did rj scratch it off and why?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Guys,

The reviewer lady in spoiler tv, who already watched the 6 x08 episode almost explicity said that Red John is Sheriff McAllister. She confirmed that it is one of the 7 suspects on the list and she said "Don't overythink. The promo tells you a lot".  I love reading your theories, but at the end of the day , the sheriff puts the bomb under his hat, kills some of the suspects and appears again after Patrick announced a "fake" Red John deliberately. As simple as that.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There’s one unanswered theme that’s been repeated in more
than a couple of episodes. That’s Robert Kirkland and his question to people, “Do
you recognize me?”

He also has a twin that got involved with Red John, and he
purposefully changed his features so Red John won’t recognize him while he
pursues him to seek vengeance.

Who could his twin be? I think it was Brett Partridge, whom
Robert Kirkland never met.


Skipping a bit, there’s Brett Partridge’s  supposed dead body that has a chunk of his
left shoulder sliced off. It’s odd that you would slice off a chunk of a dead
person’s shoulder.  To what end? To hide
that the person was a Blake Associate? Why? To protect Brett Partridge’s legacy?
Not likely. To protect the Blake Association? Maybe, but if you already know
about the Blake Association and their tattoos, what good is cutting off the
tattoo? That body was a Blake Associate, but was it really Brett Partridge, and
if it was, he was a Blake Associate, and why would someone want to conceal that
he was?

I think Brett Partridge faked his own death, and replaced
his body with that of a Blake Associate, and he sliced off the Blake Associate’s
shoulder to conceal that it was. If it wasn’t for Brett Partridge’s supposed
dying words, they wouldn’t have known about “Tyger, Tyger” in the first place. It
was Brett’s plan for Jane to surface the Blake Association to get them off his
back.



Of the seven final suspects, Brett Partridge has the least
amount of positional power. You got Bret Stiles, the leader of a cult. Gale
Bertram is the Director of CBI. Bob Kirkland and Reede Smith are both FBI
agents. Ray Haffner was once a former supervising agent at CBI. Sheriff McAllister is the sheriff of Napa
County.  Brett Partridge is just a
forensic investigator. Seems out of place to be a final suspect, doesn’t it?

Now think about this. Brett Partridge knows a lot about Red
John (or thinks he does), but he’s been wrong in every crime scene involving
him (or his copycats). How does someone that seemingly studies Red John get it
wrong every time? Because it’s a game he likes to play with Jane. In turn, Jane keeps making fun of Brett Partridge, but gets no rise out of him (which is his intention). That's some pretty good self control. Now why would Jane keep calling Partridge a ghoul? Because he knows he is one, he just doesn't have anything to prove it.

At any rate, Brett Partridge is Red John, there's just no solid evidence of it, yet.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Rolling with my knife
Enjoying this weird life
Dead are his daughter and wife

Joy is what I seek
Onward, Patrick!
History has been written by me
No one mentions it, but my voice is the key

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on