Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Not a real theory, just my opinion about the whole McAllister affair after he was announced dead in the recent episode, even though he stood on the 'safe' side of the house in 6x06.

This fact resulted in a whole lot of theories that he is alive and he is Red John. I just can't understand that. Here's why:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9tR57B9jWE

In the scene, we can see and hear the shot @2:23. After the shot, we still see the house for like 1 second before the scene changes. That means the explosion did not happen at the same moment as the shot.

The explosion happened at least 8 seconds later. Because in 3:10 there is Lisbon running towards Jane's house and we don't hear any shot. In 3:18 there house explodes. During those 8 seconds (probably more), ANYTHING could happen in the room. There could be a fight, someone could have tried to escape, and all positions could switch within very short time. So there's nothing special about the fact that McAllister is dead. You can tell that Stilles or Haffner are alive and the probability is the same.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

In this post I will explain several key events that have happened in episode 7 The Great Red Dragon (if you have not seen the episode yet stop reading and go watch it). These events will also hint at what I believe will happen in episode 8 Red John. 

In the last episode several important facts have occured.
After the bombing of Jane's house 3 of the 5 remaining RJ suspects end up dead. When we learn that the tyger tyger tattoo has been removed from Patridge's arm Lisbon asks "What does it mean?" Jane answers "What do you think it means?" and walks away. The removal of the tyger tyger tattoo obviously means that the Tyger Tyger group is present in the morgue, and this also means that the dna results of the 3 RJ suspects that died in Jane's house are very likely false. Jane obviously realizes at this point that RJ is 1 of the 3 "deceased" suspects. He then begins setting his trap, he announced publicly that RJ is Bertram, fully aware of the fact that this is a lie. I mean Jane has always said that when he finally gets RJ he will kill him, so why would he announce to the public that Bertram is RJ and that he is "armed and dangerous"? Answers because he wants Bertram to get killed, he wants Bertram to die, making everyone believe that RJ is dead. As we know RJ is a showman, he wants people (especially Jane) to appreciate his work, RJ has a phobia of being unrecognized. So RJ needs to confront Jane in the next episode because he HAS to, he knows that it is a stupid thing to do and should walk away but he CAN'T. Hence why Jane sais in the end, "I'm not quitting, I'm letting go". There is nothing more that he can do and he knows it, RJ needs to make the next move. So he goes into the church and waits for the inevitable arrival of his nemesis, RJ. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #12980 • By voicecomp
Show this theory

I am totally against the idea that RJ is BP but I've found another resemblance. 

You must all know the famous words heard in the church on 6x08 promo saying "The game is over and I won". If we assume that it was Red John saying that and if we compare that voice with BP at 2:59 (* We have a schedule to keep amigo) from the link below, I can say that it's a hit.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVmQFzq8Jeo

Still, I believe that it is definitely idiotic if the guy who saved patrick from the copycat killer kids is BP and that Jane didn't recognize his voice. But still, you never know what happens, right?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Anyone notice the pigeon on the rock between/behind PJ & Lisbon in the sneak peek (& promo)?

Another clue!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #12978 • By smile
Show this theory

1) Red John or Red John's accomplice put blood on Lisbon's mouth only after the phone conversation was over.

2) Looks like she could have been alone and able to speak freely for the end of the Season 4 finale where Red John is on the phone, too.

3) She is religious, and would likely think of herself in religious terms: hence the Tyger Tyger poem, the symmetry of good and evil (Lamb and Tyger) inside herself, inside Jane, and between the two.

4) You can spell her name with letters found in the Final 7 list, which might give the showrunners a sneaky way out of their public promises.

5) Jane goes to a church after the FBI kick him out of the Red John investigation with Bertrum on the run, and in the last scene, the camera lingers on a painting of a female religious figure (the Virgin Mary, I suppose? --> mother --> Mother Theresa) surrounded by adoring followers. Aside from Jane's face---looking rather broken, arguably---, that's the last shot of the episode.

This would give an interesting dynamic to Lisbon's disapointed look when Jane appears to give up at the end of the last episode, as well as to the initial meeting of Lorelei and Lisbon at the end of season 4.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

with regards to the promo.

The church scene will happen at the start of the episode as it is a continuation of previous one. Someone will come into the church and will be whoever PJ is talking too. The i win the game dialogue that goes with it is dubbed and will come later in the episode.

The same happened in previous preview, whilst outside Bertram's house he is one of them. They edited this missed bertrams name out etc and linked it with Rigsby's don't trust any cops one.

I am certain I know who is it, and it will be a huge surprise to many on here.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After episode 8 will this site get shut down or are people here going make theories why Red John is not Red John but someone else? xD

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on