Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

atleast we now know that patrick is indeed AshKetchum from Alabastia who did catch a wild pigeon and learned him tackle. that should explain all the loose ends like he is mar, or how he did get that list of 7 and why the fuck red john was so afraid of patrick that he almost shit his pants in this episode.those tears must have tasted so good

CANT FIGHT A POKEMASTER

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hello fellow Mentalists, I've been following this site for months now, and honestly, it sometimes made my day.
but today i have the impression that this is the End and people are trying to find any kind of explanation regarding this "leak".
honestly, i dont care if its real or not!

on
the other hand, our expectations on Heller and his team were extremely
high and almost impossible to achieve. Maybe we have to finally realize
that, as usual, more the people want and need an epic end / reveal in a
show, more it gets ruined by the people writing it. they are confronted
with so many theories and controversial stuff, so at the end it cam out
as most of us witnessed today.

it has been very fun all these
months and theories but we have to realize that this has come to an end
today. even though my guts tells me that this was just the final act
before the big reveal, my brain tells me that was it.

after lost,
Dexter and now mentalist, i will maybe start watching meaningless
series and TV shows after-all to avoid any kind of emotional hole you
are dropping after such a huge disappointment.

Xander Berkeley
has a certain kind of charme of course, but showing up out of nothing
after 5 years and voila " bla bla i am red john"....ridiculous and
pathetic.

I certainly hope that Bruno is sitting home now and laughs about us, knowing that the final chapter insn't what it seems to be.



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hello fellow Mentalists, I've been following this site for months now, and honestly, it sometimes made my day.
but today i have the impression that this is the End and people are trying to find any kind of explanation regarding this "leak".
honestly, i dont care if its real or not!

on the other hand, our expectations on Heller and his team were extremely high and almost impossible to achieve. Maybe we have to finally realize that, as usual, more the people want and need an epic end / reveal in a show, more it gets ruined by the people writing it. they are confronted with so many theories and controversial stuff, so at the end it cam out as most of us witnessed today.

it has been very fun all these months and theories but we have to realize that this has come to an end today. even though my guts tells me that this was just the final act before the big reveal, my brain tells me that was it.

after lost, Dexter and now mentalist, i will maybe start watching meaningless series and TV shows after-all to avoid any kind of emotional hole you are dropping after such a huge disappointment.

Xander Berkeley has a certain kind of charme of course, but showing up out of nothing after 5 years and voila " bla bla i am red john"....ridiculous and pathetic.

I certainly hope that Bruno is sitting home now and laughs about us, knowing that the final chapter insn't what it seems to be.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Dunno but
do you really think that vanpelt kicking her head against a car window like a
child is not all but a big hoax

The mentalist
putting bread crumbles on RJs hand, having a pigeon hidden in his jacket and rj
jumping back like a 5 year old sissy – that’s the big revelation – uiuiui

 



RJ lying defenceless
on the ground and PJ mounting him like – dunno.

RJ:wanna know
how I knew your suspect list in advance
PJ: nope I don’t
care
Me: LOL 



The finale
scene of  6x07, PJ entering the church,
did look a bit different than the one in 6x08. But again –
maybe it s just the cutting.

Someone said
it reminded him of a SNL episode, he s right – hopefully it s just PR (if cbs
can afford such a pr hoax –  bravo, now that’s
where the money goes ,)

If not, you
crazy Hollywood people – what kind of mentalism was that (let s hope the
writers did have a great laugh about it, black humour I suppose.

true fans however
are bursting out in tears right now)

PLEASE DON
T HURT YOURSELVES (especially you partridge people out there)!

 



Peace




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For those of you who have seen the "RJ" episode:  "He is StayPuff Marshmallow Man"

For those of you who haven't I found it on the comments to a post that asked how everybody knew what happened in Ep 08, keep scrolling down.  It's pretty deep -- but maybe it only works in the US and might be pulled soon?  FYI -- I appears to have been hacked, not leaked -- if there's a difference. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

*No Spoilers*
Guys somehow managed to watch the leaked episode

I just hope this episode ain't the same they gonna air this Sunday,But its highly unlikely because all the scenes in the promo were in this episode

I can guarantee you 75% of the people in this forum made more logical and better sense than Bruno did

Red John begging for mercy and calling 911 were ROTFL moments
They made Red John like Sheldon / Chandler

Even a normal person wont be kissing the killers ass this much

Also None of the previous clues/Questions were answered.

I think the writer randomly picked a person who acted in this series and asked him to be Red John
Totally disappointed

Infact the worst episode till now

Will rate it 0.5/5 (For Patrick's acting)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Big Spoiler alert for all you skeptics that don't believe there is a video

pic 1 is RJ/McAllister pointing a gun at PJ while Bertram lies dead on the floor

BZraSGuCMAAbrte.jpg:large


Pic 2 is of PJ throwing a pigeon at RJ after he'd given him bread crumbs, giving him time to pic his gun up from under the seat were he placed it in episode 7. 

BZrabqNCIAARVdC.jpg:large

Ladies and gents, I rest my case.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on