Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

The leaked episode is a fake, just another ruse

Do you think after 6 years, they would allow the critical episode to be leaked so so easily? and then not even bother taking the link down after it had been spread all over social media. The Mentalist is all about tricks, deception, games. Heller has just given Mentalist fans a insight how it feels to be duped by Patrick Jane. So don't worry your little heads, there will be a spectacular end to the Red John saga come Sunday!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Guys, I really love this site. For months, I have been writing theories here, and I can honestly say that if this website had not existed, I would not enjoy Mentalist this much. I learned many details here, and I also hope I have been able to teach some details myself.

Whoever is the owner, I want to thank him. No advertisement whatever, he has probably been paying from his pocket all the server costs. The server is struggling with the traffic for the past 2-3 weeks but that is really OK.

I suspected many people since I have been following this site. When I was an amateur I used to suspect Ellis Mars and Linus Wagner.
I had a Kirkland theory about facial surgery
http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/1849
Then I learned more and more and 6 months ago I switched to Bertram
http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/3183
And 2 months ago I made that theory much stronger
http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/4424 

My theories have twice been most popular of month, so I have had my share of attention. I am really glad for those votes, made me feel good. Those times there weren't survey theories ( green X red ) so not very high upvotes.

I have spent hundreds of hours watching The Mentalist, looking for clues. It was really nice. I loved the community and interaction here.

Just wanted to say thank you.

Also, yesterday night was crazy (15 hours ago) We were all trying to watch the video and the comments after that were memorable. So i setup a website to remember today, our emotions. It explains the past 15 hours with picures of comments. It is not about the leak's being real or not, it is about us.

www.red-john.info



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

SPOILERS AHEAD (but not about who RJ is)







The "rough episode".  The problem is not the color, the sound, and not even who RJ turns out to be, the problem is the
acting and the writing and all together,  it was just terrible...not
even PJ was that good, and RJ!! Wasn't he a good actor? He was terrible
also, winning all over the place in such an unconvincing way... 
The
lack of answers is also very annoying, there were ways of telling us
things, it didn't have to be RJ, so the excuse "PJ wouldn't give him
applause time" doesn't even fit. 

Oh..well, I'm going to get over it...(but right now I'm mad as hell).
What's the fun of finding more clues now?
And I really doubt they will answer any questions on the next episodes..



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok so after watching that leak i have gone trough many emotions, anger,sadness,frustration and now im in denial or hopeful depends how you look at  it. 

So im hopeful that the leak was a fake and that in fact by giving us all a very accessible way to view the almighty red john episode Heller has disappointed us all on purpose, knowing all hardcore fans would access it. Cause lets face it that was awful but wouldnt it be genius to provide us with this awful episode so when we actual saw the real one we will all be so relieved and happy that it wasnt what we all just saw. 

I know at this point i would even be happy if red john turned out to be partridge rather than xander berkleys shocking portrayal  of him. It was more dirty old red man john, Than Red JOhn the "GOD" 

somewhere deep down im still praying its CBI RON :) its not happening though. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hey I also believe the leaked episode is a fake and to hopefully prove it I found this http://www.tvfanatic.com/2013/11/the-mentalist-preview-who-is-red-john/

Enjoy been great guessing and writing. Theories with you all

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

First i'm not saying it's not fake. 

But , i mean even if he meant to make it the worst episode and the worst reveal in the history of TV he still wouldn't make it as bad as he did ! Unbelievable it was like watching episode of Friends or Seinfeld !! 

That scene when the great RED JOHN the genius lying and calling 911 hahahahahahahahaha !!!! are you for real? *** was that ? is that is the guy we scared of?? seriously?? ooh boy 

Or that scene when he was asking for mercy and saying :" Patrick you're good man you're not like me, don't kill me " hahahahahahahahaha.. or that scene when he was running with a bullet in his stomach , is he superman or what? THIS IS MUST BE A JOKE , THERE IS NOT ANY OTHER explanation.

Anyway i found this interesting ( don't got me wrong i still don't think it's a fake episode but... ) 


This picture from the promo .. http://picturf.com/i/6Sf

and almost the same picture but from the episode we saw http://www.pic-upload.de/view-21409241/redj.png.html

In the first pic you can see clearly there's no Bertram on the ground.. and in the episode we saw there is Bertram lying on the ground.. so i mean let's hope what we've saw today was nothing but a comedy or a joke otherwise i feel sorry for spending 6 years on this rubbish.. LOST all over again 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

C'mon. Such a cruel joke.

Imagine the Red John.
A step ahead of Jane, killed his victims with such finesse, a showman, the closest someone can get to a psychic. Someone everyone in law enforcement is scared of, someone every influential guy knows. Better manipulator than Jane, evil, and has no remorse. More importantly, sends shivers down the spine of viewers in every episode. And his ''Hello, Patrick" send shivers down Jane's spine !!

Look what we got.
A balding, oldie who bends his neck to talk in Red John's voice, got screwed by bread crumbs and a fucking pigeon. His backup is a 5 foot woman with a 2 inch knife. He runs like a girl, sees a woman and starts begging her not to shout like a sissy, runs some more, then calls 9-1-1, and finally falls down in a fucking garden and starts crying like a girl. In his last moments, he is telling Jane, "he knows the list cause he is a psychic". What the fuck, man !  

The viewers deserve a better Red John. Like Batman had his Joker. Even Jane deserved a better Red John. Not this sissy. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on