Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Red John: Don't kill me, you don't know I got your list!!! you don't know how I got your list!!! I'm a real psychic!!!

Patrick: I don't give a shit!!!

This scene was hilarious :D

I liked Haffner, but I'm ok with RJ's real identity. He was almost everyone's second choice!!! I'm bothered that they left so many questions unanswered. At least those that were related to RJ himself should've been taken care of.

What I'm hoping to see from now on is RJ's dream haunting Patrick. Like what happened to Grace and O'Laughlin. RJ's dream accompanies Patrick and even helps him solve cases!!! I hate to see him go away like this, but at the same time I hate dragging the storyline too far.

R.I.P RJ, you'll always be my favorite serial killer.

PS: Partridge fans, sorry!!! Your RJ was nothing more than a puppet!!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Okay so it's not about RJ being a god. We all know he is just a man at the end of the day but the thing is he is an evil genius. He also thinks he is god so he would never back down, and always have something up his sleeve. His followers are many but where were they here. I didn't see his evilness or narcissistic behavior till the end. His determination to not get beat? Where was that. His under handed dirtiness where was that?  It's like all of a sudden he became this weakling.
The whole feel to the episode was awful. The day time thing in the park wasn't the best option either and the jokes and humor about it was ridiculous.

The plot was awful. The action wasn't action it was running and jumping. The end was awkward with the blinking. Red John was but a man but HE THOUGHT HE WAS A GOD and where was that??

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So

- Partridge indeed always was just an idiot, there was no story behind it.

- Haffner indeed always was just an idiot, there was no story behind it.

- Stiles indeed always was just a nut job cult leader, there was no story behind it.

- Kirkland indeed always was just a complete nut job, he even killed the only one able to identify Red John in the search for Red John. There was no story behind it.

- I have no idea who Bertram was, but he indeed just turned into a complete nut job and went on a killing spree out of nowhere. I have no idea how to come up with his story without lots of drugs involved.

- The guy writing "he is mar..." was indeed just an idiot who couldn't write just the name of his killer but wanted to make a poem out of it or whatever. There was no story behind it.

- Red John was indeed the leader of a secret organization and wanted Jane to lead the CBI into investigating his secret organization. To make it easier, he marked everyone with three dots - including himself. Well, at least he had no Red John smiley tattoo on his forehead.

Can we get the background story of the pigeon now?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just a wild guess and my last hope...

What if the real episode is longer than 40 minutes?That would explain why the promo's scenes are the same and why the spoilertv's admin said that the episode was the same etc.

I don't know what to believe, I just want something different to happen, or else that would be a shame. really.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Okay, I accepeted this episode. Nice try Bruno. 
But I really don't understand how you guys think it can even remotely be the real one. For Blake's sake, have you suddendly become retards? There were more parody things in these 40 minutes than the number of pigeons we got to see in season 6. Wake up. This was a joke. Stay tuned for actual Patrick Vs Red John episode.


P.S. We can assume this was a joke. The fact is that they ruined the image of the sheriff. I mean, he could have been okay, but after many people saw this it's impossible, at least for me, to look at the sheriff the same way.
This is why I think he won't be Red John in the true episode.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

if this leaked episode is the real thing then i can say with 100% certainty the bruno has no idea what he is doing. its so clear that originally partridge was supposed to be red john. the fact that people saw that made him throw some hack job together at the last minute to "prove" the audience wrong. the sheriff as red john makes zero sense.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It's really weird...

This leaked episode matches with the promo
All scenes in the promo are in that

But it's a shit! A big shit!!

It's not about McAllister being red john.... After Partridge, McAllister was my favorite, and I would be happy if he is it... but not that awful way!!

It doesn't make sense, because the episode has a lot of crap like:

- The funny Bertram's fall
- Patrick chasing with no rush after McAllister
- McAllister with a bullet in his rib runs faster than Patrick
- Explains absolutely NOTHING!
- and the final scene of McAllister blinking for yes or no, really made me laugh out loud

I'm confused, this crap scenes, and others, make me believe that it's a fake, but it maches with the promo...

If this episode is the official one, it will be the worst thing I've ever watch!!

PLEASE BRUNO, DON'T DO THIS TO US!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on