Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

http://youtu.be/BLM26iBgvmY

oh HELLER is just messing with us as I said in my theory #13688. He just wants to satisfy the junkies on this site and the only way is to lower the expectations by red-herring this fake thing.

Dont you see it? "The game's over and I won" said by the sherriff..

1-  He suddenly speaks in a different voice. 50% hoax iddentified. Ook u wud say, he just wanted to create that impression of the phone RJ effect to Patrick and all and so the sherriff is made to move is shoulder and all. but its a lame effort really coz.....

2- In the promos shown officially, when RJ utters that line, the official footage has is lower body shown. U mean to say that there will be a scene in the official promo and wont be in the main.

then Heller is not just dumb, he is also unprofessional and in his own world. But no, they compromised RJ's facial expressions while uttering such a important line coz they cant show it in promos but that line is important and needs to be uttered and RJ can only show his back in that promo-scene. so if the sanctity of promo-scenecs law is to hold, this episode has to be a fake.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Remember PJ was fooled into thinking he shot RJ once before. They have been too smart for to long . I have faith there is more.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Mentalist 6x8 - Red John - Sheriff Thomas McAllister is Red John

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsnqP1PummY 

2:15 minute

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Patrick Jane  vs Sheriff Thomas McAllister (Red John) - Death scene -

http://youtu.be/KAqBO4Hx16I

13:12 minute

#GoodByeRedJohn

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After watching the leaked episode, I've come to understand that it focused on Patrick's perspective. He didn't care to know how Red John secured the names of the suspects. He got his revenge, and that is what the episode was about. I don't know any tv show where all the answers are given in a nice neat package. It does not work that way. There is a lot of bitching and groaning, but I actually liked it.

So I suppose I'm a sucker. But I wasn't let down. Remember that some of these things can be answered later.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Though I think this is the legit video (apart from it being unedited)... I don't understand how there are no news reports on the Internet about it. Or how CBS or Heller haven't done anything about it or said anything about it.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

To all of you Partridge Fans,

The truth about the "leaked" episode is that Partridge aka Red John had his red headed sister, Grace Van Pelt, use her massive computer skills to upload a bogus episode, and hide it in the source code for the CBS press release video site, just to mess with the minds of the non-believers.  Obviously his plan has worked!  Haven't read a post yet from someone who has seen the leaked episode who hasn't been somewhat disappointed.  Additionally, Red John had help from Bruno Heller in creating the leaked episode.  The Mentalist fans aren't the only ones tired of their show being preempted by sports.  Heller et al have given us five plus great years of The Mentalist and how aggravating it must be for all those involved from writing, directing, producing and acting in one of the best television shows ever aired to be treated like "The Red Headed Step-child" by CBS.  Ever since the night CBS decided not to air the scheduled episode to the entire viewing areas and instead caused havoc for the fans,  suspect that felt like the final straw, too, to those involed from A to Z in creating The Mentalist.  If Sunday's "Red John" episode does turn out to be the same as the "leaked" episode then you will know that even Red John knew he was being underappreciated by CBS and did not make his proper appearance and proper goodbyes.  However, once The Mentalist is picked up by a new network that will revere it and give it the prime time viewing slot it deserves, then he will reappear and we will see Brett Partridge reemerge as Red John and before Patrick Jane has his way with him, we will all get the attention and answers to the great theories and questions that the loyal fans of The Mentalist have posted on this great site!

One last note on the behalf of all fans of all the suspects, "Thank You" to site owner / operator / admin Jeremy for creating a fun site that obviously took a great deal of your time and energy to create and you did so with minimum advertising!  As a web designer myself, I greatly appreciate the lost revenues you could have made with advertising overkill and basically you made this a not for profit site.  If you would like to put a PayPal donation link on your feedback page, would like to make a small donation to you and am in hopes many of the fans of this site would, too!  Kudos and again many thanks to Jeremy!

PS Any of you who are contrary enough to disagree that Webmaster Jeremy doesn't deserve A Green Plausible sign of Thanks, go ahead and press Red and take a flying jump into a "Red" lake where Red John is waiting for you! :)
 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I don't buy it, I just don't...

-Red John was vanquished by a pigeon? Really?

-Only one single line with the actual Red John voice? I wanted a whole damn monologue of RJ's voice, not some weak little town Sheriff using that funny high pitched voice of his once.

-Red John appeared once in 5 seasons....

-Timothy Carter was a better Red John, it is a fact, not an opinion.



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on