Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Theory #14928 • By Hoogenband
Show this theory

OMG, Partridge?! I'm still in shock. Who else is rewatching episode 1-7??? Heller, first, nice trick, and second, I'm sorry I ever doubted you!

I didn't really understand the part about Haffner faking Partridge's death.

Someone explain how GPS works? OK, I get that Lisbon is bugged, so Haffner knew when it was safe to move to West Huron (because Haffner saw when she leaves the office). Next he superficially wounds Partridge. Partridge lures her to his door and then the rest is history. But who had Haffner's phone?
It was also a good clue from Heller to put Haffner in the dream. It makes sense why Haffner went to check up on her. And I was half right about Red John! Haffner did so many of the Red John killings, I'm guessing Partridge was too weak to kill men!!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #14926 • By b0rdenn
Show this theory

So now, after being really depressed for a few hours, I tried to watch the episode again and I have to say that I actually like the idea of RJ showed like a wuss, I Iike the 911 call, showing how hopeless and pathetic he is, and then PJ made him regret killing his family and seeing the fear in his eyes when he is seconds away from the death. I wanted so many things to be explained, but if you think about this from PJ's POV, he finally has the killer of his family, he doesn't care about any of that, any of the tricks RJ pulled, he just wants it all to end

I think there will not be another episode, cuz the idea of the writers was how PJ kills RJ and the story moves on, therefore the feel of rushing and very little things explained, but that makes all the clues given in the past episodes pointless. I still have my hopes up  tho

And to finish, imo from PJ's pov this actually makes sense but from another gven what the whole show is about it really doesn't, big disappointment

Oh, and also I think the disappointment comes from the really big hopes for an epic ending to the Red John chapter, and the fact that he is a normal person like everyone else after all and not a God that doesn't make any mistakes...showed how he dies miserable, lonely man, begging for mercy, fearing death like every human being does. I do feel tho, that the episode is really badly written, I guess I kinda like some of the concepts, but the overall writing and directing sucks big time imo

Let me know what you guys think! Hope to see ya round :P
Here the song from the promo btw, I really liked it
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5kZY1cLQbrY

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If the Leaked Episode is REAL, then:

1.  CBS flat-out didn't care about spoiling the reveal in their promo material.
2.  It's simply a coincidence that this episode wound up getting leaked.
3  Bruno has suddenly forgotten how to write.
4.  The show's budget suddenly got cut in half.
5.  Every specific clue from episodes past winds up being pointless.
6.  Mentalist's PR team never heard of this site, nor has Bruno.
7.  The Mentalist fan/tv critic who positively reviewed RED JOHN, truly believed that this episode showed Jane at his witty best and gives the fans the CLEVER Holmes/Moriarty showdown they've been waiting for, along with answers to MANY questions we've had for years.

8.  Heller thinks so little of the fans, so as to expect them to keep watching after seeing this weak wrap-up, which of course makes him stupid as well as inconsiderate.

If the leaked episode is FAKE, then:

1.  Bruno wanted it to be seen, to throw off fans, and surprise everyone.
2.  CBS meant for pics of McAllister to be seen, with Bruno's full blessings.
3.  Bruno will put the pieces together, that he has painstakingly laid out.
4.  Jane will best RJ with manipulation, proving he's still ahead of all of us.
5.  The cheap look of the episode was because it wasn't the REAL episode.
6.  This site was instrumental in Bruno's decision-making, as to how and when to end RJ.
7.  Bruno would like the show to continue successfully, with old fans as well as new.

Wishful thinking aside, it seems more logical to think that this leaked episode was calculated.  And it was handled in such a way, so as not to be SO obvious that it deceives no one.  It was available just long enough for people to see it and share it, but then got "quickly" taken down, as if it were an accident.  Then it shows up on Itunes, again to make it "legit."

If Jane and his clever manipulation skills are merely an extension of Bruno's creativity and cleverness, then wouldn't it be very "Jane" of him to get everyone angry at him, only to prove that it was all a ruse, merely masking his true intentions, known only to him?

Don't get me wrong.  It's entirely possible that all of the casual viewers' complaints about being sick of Red John finally got to Bruno, and he just said, "The hell with it.  Let's just kill him and get on with the show, before our ratings drop any lower."  It is all about money, at the end of the day, after all.

But I think even the CASUAL viewers would feel stiffed by this nonsense, and the ratings would plummet anyway.  Bruno has to know that.  So, for the show to even have a bright future, he has to deliver a payoff that would make people want to continue to tune in to see what's next for Jane.

Since almost all of us feel like this episode is a giant "F**K YOU", I don't think Heller would seriously put this out there as his "Hail Mary."  He would only do that if he doesn't care anymore and plans to cancel the show, and on a sour note, at that.

So, to my way of thinking, too much is at stake here, for Heller to do this, unless he's finished and angry.  His latest interviews don't seem to suggest that at all.  So, for now, I'm still going to assume this is all a ruse.  Seems more reasonable to me.  I sure hope to God I'm right....

And yes, I hope it's Partridge.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i have no idea how come Macallister's voice tone suddenly change "its
totally fair the games over and i won " doesnt match with his original
voice tone

disaster and totally nonsense episode i have seen so far :/

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

THIS CAN'T BE REAL

- CBS include a clear image of Red John in their promo for the 'Red John' episode.

- The most important episode in the show's history gets leaked on a partner website of CBS and is allowed to stay up for almost 24 hours.

- People post links to the episode and screen caps on the Mentalist's own Facebook page and they aren't removed.

- Now the episode is available to buy on the French iTunes before it has even aired in the United States.

A SICK, SICK JOKE.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I know there is a lot of debate if the episode is real or fake and I think its a little of both I think it is misdirection we have analyzed every little thing in every episode but nobody has said anything about Bertram wearing partridges fishing hat from desert rose when he is on the phone with Jane and says I don't have to use a different voice do I and after Patrick kills red john McAllister he takes his cell phone these are all clues for us but think what you will I will watch tonight and see the end true or not.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Oh my god
FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCK
wtf cbs ? wtf bruno heller ?
here i am angry again even that i saw the leaked episode two days ago
motherfucking timothy carter would be / still is a better red john then mcallister 
fuck the whole universe
i dont think that we will see another episode tonight , mcallister is red john 
he calls 911 , jane kill him and he got away with it by runing out of california .
so whats next bruno ? whats nect for the mentalist ?
just fuck you my friend .. i mean my god damn enemy
i wish i knew him personally so i could fuck him in the ass then kill him
if a was a writer in the show and i saw the leaked episode i swear god that i would kill heller then burn the cbs company building then kill myself .
R.I.P REAL Red John
http://images2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20110524100654/thementalist/images/2/2f/Red_John_in_person.png

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on