Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

So I just saw the episode here in Nicaragua. Its definitely a different episode. SPOILER:
Summer and Cho both turn into pigeons and fly to Dubai, also Bret Stiles is the secret father of every character on the list of 7. I can confirm this because I am in canada and I also saw the episode. And me to, I am in Kenya and saw it on Amazon Prime Kenya, and we are all posting from the same account. I hope this clears everything up. Any questions?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

 I bet my money on Mashburn, Partridge ou Minelli.

I want to final explosive and not like the leak episode.
I hope
Kiss guys
see you tomorrow for the answer.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Another thing that bothers me is that Bruno Heller wrote pretty much all the finales on the show and some of the best episodes on the show, Red Moon, Code Red etc So what happened here?For me the struggle became apparent in Season 5 finale "Red John's Rules", the episode was not season finale standard, the list also made no sense to me as I couldn't understand how some names made the list, it felt like they just ignored all the details they had gathered about Red John throughout the years e.g Reede Smith was never a viable suspect. When season 6 kicked off, I began to accept the list and even enjoyed the episodes as I thought the list would be justified but now I realize there was no thought to it just like this Red John episode.Strawberries & Cream was a delicious episode, even the plan on The Crimson Hat was a good plan compared to how the Real Red John was revealed this season.I believe the writers wrote themselves into a corner by NOT letting Timothy Carter stay as Red John

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I’ve posted theories here since around the
2000th theory, and we’re reaching the 15000th,

I’ve read too many and missed a few, I even
went back and read some of the first.
The first one was about Partridge. I was
not a fan of partridge, but at one moment I was convinced, in fact I was
convinced also by Mashburn, Haffner, Frye, Stiles and others. I was never
convinced by McAllister, Bertram and Smith, and I think i was not the only one.

I refused to believe that there was a leak
until I saw it 24hrs ago, I’m not so disappointed completely to be honest to a
point of saying F…k everybody, I just couldn’t find it logical to end this way,
I mean I don’t have anything against McAllister Being RJ or calling 911 or
begging for his life, who wouldn’t when knowing he’s going to die, the guy is
smart and not a terrorist. What I didn’t like or what I had expected is that PJ
reveals RJ and not RJ reveals himself, if PJ had trapped RJ like he always does
and maybe in a more complicated trick, it was ok, but not as easy as that.


Even after McAllister was dead I kept on waiting
for something more to happen, When PJ called Lisbon I thought that finally we
are going to see the real face of RJ answering that last call from Patrick but
no, unknown caller in an evidence pack.

But hey, if we replace McAlister by any
other suspect it would also fit, I mean Bret stiles or Haffner could’ve done
the same thing, Stiles is old but he can count on Cordero to kill. Brett
Partridge and Kirkland also, seriously imagine someone else in place of
McAlister, nothing would change.

Witch lead me to think that maybe there was
a multiple shots with several actors since McAlister came into action, and
specially that on the promo we don’t see the body of Bertram.

Until tonight’s episode, I’m really not
expecting any changes, I’m just hoping for the good sake of the show and its
credibility.


To finish, if it was really a leak, i think because heller dosen't trust himself capable of satisfying us, so first he will disappoint us knowing that we will be happy with any other outcome.



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Pigeon, pigeon wants to fight!
In the pocket on the right.
What retarded hand or eye
Couldn't pat down Jane and find a live bird on his person???

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Oh yeah.  I'm a Brit and I work with livefromdubai who refused to post a SPOILER earlier. Let's just say that I was with him for the last twenty minutes of the episode, then backtracked to the comments on this site related to the spoiler episode. It differs. Like I said, you can't see shows like the Mentalist out in the real world here. They're considered immoral. But at the hotels here that host a lot of us Brits and Americans they usually show American TV. Think it's satellite fed. Anyway, here's to hoping my Brits and Americans alike enjoy the ending. I would guess that Australian and Japanese viewers saw it first and I'm real surprised they haven't spoiled it already. But then again, it looks like there are about 24 theories posted every hour on this site, too many to keep up with!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on