Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

People hate me on this site cuz i think outside the box . This is my last van pelt is suspicious post. Cant wait for tonight !!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

SPOILER( i know you guys don't care anymore about spoilers but if you still wanna enjoy tonight's episode don't read it)  Thursdays leaked episode is real just not 40 minutes we missed out more than  20 minutes of explanations that didn't make the rough cut. Mcallister actually a good red john and its a good ending with the explanations. you are frustrated not because of him. its not complete and thats why. Patrick doesn't care about how red john got the list off course he doesn't care he just kill him. also the chasing scenes are not like that they are gonna change a lot with editing. we have red john POV flashback and patricks long con about how he found out that red johns identity. There are huge sacrifices by bot PJ and RJ. PJ actually sacrifices his moral stand and gets really darker before its all sunny again. lisbon has a great role in RJ plans and Cho has a great role in PJ's. The idiot who leaked the episode fucked us not bruno. I'm really satisfied by the real one. We see RJ as a mastermind first the brought down to his knees by PJ and it was ecstatic this way even 911 call. pigeon scene actually not like that there are pigeons! like the batman begin scene he's not afraid of one pigeon. there is a special effect there so its not in the rough cut. and what else hmm. and to all partridge fans you gonna like the episode too because he is not just a ghoul true disciple of RJ and a really smart one. he has a crucial role in fooling PJ for all this year. but I can't say anything for Haffner and Stiles. just weirdos I think. I'm the only happy mentalist fan I think :) give bruo heller some credit will ya

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I have just seen a theory suspecting Brenda and van pelt to be in a red john fueled lesbian relationship. I thought it was a hoax theory At first, but Shettrick is Latin for lesbian. Google it, it just seems to uncanny. And I have seen the chemistry between van pelt and Brenda in some of the early episodes.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just because the 'he is mar' clue bugs me, I make my last theory on this site.

There is no bar on the 'H' and to me it looks like 'II is many'. If you've been stabbed, bleeding out you don't have the energy to write a sentence. A name would suffice. Why else would you scrawl on a wall in blood?! Obviously to alert people. But if another man came to the scene, maybe that is what he was trying to tell them. I don't see multiple red johns, but maybe a master/apprentice variation.

I'm 99.9% certain all the fans will see a new episode ending tonight. Thank you all for the theories. It's been fun!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

When will some of you guys stop sucking up to Bruno Heller...saying the leaked episode is fake lol. That's beyond delusion. The episode was full of horse shit. Even some of the previous episodes were awful. This one did stand out because of the impact on the story. Everyone and their mothers' desire was watching Red John's mystery unfold in a smooth manner: Answering all their questions and connecting the dots between the clues. NOTHING WAS ANSWERED. MORE QUESTIONS WERE RAISED INSTEAD. The clues were COMPLETELY FORGOTTEN. No shock value whatsoever. It just reeks of bad writing.

Bruno has been milking this story for years. The number of the viewers dropped over the years but the majority of them kept on watching because they were CAPTIVATED BY THE RED JOHN MYSTERY. We were all ignoring the bad writing on certain episodes because we JUST
WANTED TO DISCOVER THE IDENTITY OF THAT SON OF A BITCH TROLLING
EVERYBODY WITH HIS SMILEY FACE.

We were just deluding ourselves over the years. Bruno is below average. To further prove my point: the reveal left a huge monumental crapstorm and Mr. I Can't Write For Shit chose not to address any questions/details on the 6x09 episode, but instead decided to make a 2 years jump in the future.

I'm not buying his bullshit anymore. He can GO FUCK HIMSELF.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on