Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

No wait.....Bruno.....Are you serious????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Let's create a petition so Bruno Heller will understand that we need more closure to the Red John-story! His background, meaning of "he is mar" and so on. 

If we're lucky and get enough vote this might reach him and they make a specific episode where we follow Red John from the beginning of his "journey" into madness.

Best regards,

Patrick Jane

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Waiting Game- In 12 hours, we will know whether the episode was real or not.

There are 2 groups of fans:

Those who have accepted that leaked episode is real because it aired.

Those who think they have spotted Bruno Heller's meanest trick to date.


EPISODE 9 will air in 6 days. We will know by TONIGHT if it is a trick.

IF it is a trick, Heller's HAD his fun, he HAS to promote the real 'Red John' episode tonight on CBS. He's leaked, peeked and sneaked a horrendous/funny episode onto air. Baker called it a 'huge risk.' If the hardcore Mentalistas among us are right, we will be vindicated for hoping tonight, and we will be speculating again in 24 hours on the true identity of Red John!

In Conclusion: We will find out within 12 hours whether the episode is real. AND NO SOONER.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

(English isnt my primary language) 5 episodes left and you guys think its done? Red john is  Thomas McAllister realy?? NO ! Ok forget all you THINK you know about Red John. And put the fact upfront. Red John is cute, charismatic and young. Dont forget Lorelei and Roselin are 2 beauty, both of them fall in love with Red John. You realy think they would fall for that old man?? REALY?? NO, not at all. 5 episodes left, in the last 2 episodes only the REAL Red John will be revaled. And i can only see one guy; Wayne Rigsby. Red John have to be someone who was in the show from day 1. Someone who shake PJ hand, not friend with him, but close enough to always be one step ahead of PJ.  Someone cute enough to get Lorelei fall in love madly with him. Someone who you ll never see it comming (unless your smart like me). Wayne Risgby will be the perfect Red John. Season 6 episode 7, when CBI learn where is the fat cop is, you see Wayne Rigsby pickup the phone and call someone. And when he arrive at the place. The red john acolyte shake rigsby hand and know rigsby... strange isnt it?Think about it ... Wayne Rigsby is RED JOHN. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I went into the last episode with an open mind knowing the reveal wouldn`t be what I wanted but there was so much wrong with that episode.  Holy fuckin ball drop.  There was no mention of Jane`s past and no connection to Visulize. There was no Mentalist suprise they could have stuck anyone in the Red John role but they chose the hillbilly sheriff who was only in one episode before the 6th season and they didn`t explain anything. What a cop out   The whole season was fucked. they should have revealed Red John`s identity in the season 6 finale and added a plot twist like one of Jane`s team is working for Red John and the 7th and last season would be the hunt for Red John and the whole series ends with Red John`s death.and them explaining all the mysteries from the series tying up all the loose ends and satisfying all the fans. Just having someone from the list of 7 wasn`t going to be a shocking at all and then have it be one of the bomb blast victims was lame. The whole Blake Association thing came too late and the FBI was a waste of time. Stiles Kirkland or Partridge would have been a more believeable Red John.  I thought the actor did a great job playing Red John but we already saw this with Timothy Carter.  Jane throws a pigeon at Red John  Red John tries to call 911 acts like a bitch  what the fuck happened  this is how they were gonna fix sagging ratings  they just killed the show    they could have had anyone be Red John they could have explained everything episode 8 should have been a Red John origin story showing us everything we wanted to know     just like Timothy Carter it`s still open that McCallister is not Red John     there`s no fuckin way this is how the Red John saga ends  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Planned originally to say nothing.
Had to say something: I'm extremely disappointed to the ending of the great tale of Red John hunt.
Just plain disappointed. If Waldo is something who is shown in 2nd episode and then random...
Too much Waldo for my taste. The story doesn't fit together at all.
End of season 3 would have been masterpiece having Bertram as RJ.
I don't know how you writers of season 6 are going to sleep your nights, though I see long painfully sleepless nights in horizon...

Ex-fan

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Can someone in US post on youtube the newest Red John promo??? I CAN'T WAIT! Heller you sly dog.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on