Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

It all makes sense now.
I know why Red John is McAllister.
Because He was home alone :p

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I found Red John's biggest enemy: http://i.imgur.com/ca7uRaW.gif

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I know it's got nothing to do with Red John or The Mentalist..

But RIP Paul Walker! :((

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Whats up with these Partridge fans? The guy fuc*ing died,they showed his damn body and last week Red John was revealed and still they keep insisting he is the 'great' Red John. You can't take no for an answer? There is one dude on here who made a bet on his virginity hahaha.....................

Probably after a couple of episodes they will say Partridge is "green george" a new serial killer. Does partridge really look that appealing that Lorelai would jump his bones? And people would willingly kill themselves for him? None of that matters anyways but seriously you should drop it and stop pissing us all off.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

getting sick of reposts from stoopkid and redrigsby
stop fishin for greens.. no matter how hard you try, the negs will always prevail


oh, and bruno is speaking truth - red john is done... momentarily 

i'd bet my virginity that this isn't the last we hear of red john.
it would be silly not to go back to it in the last ever episode(s)
the mentalist is red john and red john is the mentalist. it must end with him
put yourselves in bruno's shoes......... it only makes sense to end on red john.
that could mean more closure on mcallister or perhaps a jaw-dropping revelation and return of a killed character (does it really matter?) as long as red john is the final stamp

or, having said that, perhaps end on something mind-blowing (preposterous) like a last scene of jane killing again showing him painting the red smiley revealing it was him all along 
after all, like someone pointed out, there has always been hints that jane could be rj. 
nothing can disprove that as well.. apart from the bleeding obvious concept of time-space continuum
but anything can be explained on tv
 



one more thing, if you're going to try and make a cohesive and seemingly intelligent theory by the use of big words... can you at least get the grammar correct?
it irks me because you're trying to sound smart but contradicting yourself at the same time with mistakes like:
"would of"
using "however" incorrectly (punctuation)
using semicolons incorrectly

if you weren't trying to sound so smart maybe i'd appreciate your theory
until then, enjoy my negs










_________________________________________

in Plotnick we trust

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Owain Yeoman went to the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art, and yet acts like Clark Kent??? Tis not natural.
Question: Why does his dad hate him so much? Most parents are proud of their kids when the kids don't fall into a life of crime, even if the parents are supposed career criminals (TV stereotyping to establish my conclusions).
Question: Why the goatee in the flashback episode? What happened to it? Any rational minded person, if that exists, would clearly understand a goatee as a signature mark of a person trying to hide something, hence, serial killer! Is that so much of a leap?
Question: Why the baby out of wedlock drama? Seems needless to establish a weird relationship for Rigsby and have it lead nowhere, right? I mean the woman is a bit weird too, right?
Question: How does the sheriff, who is supposed to be Red John, A.K.A the most evil of all criminals in the history of cop shows, lose at Rock-paper-scissors to Jane like some stupid little child?
Question: Why does Rigsby express anger by jumping from high places to catch criminals? RJ is supposed to be afraid of heights, so what better way to show reckless abandonment when one is angry?
Question: Isn't it true that all serial killers strive to look like Ted Bundy/clean cut? jk
Fact: Owain Yeoman is a Brit and thus perfect for a Sherlock Holmes type program. The dude picked a red head for a new partner!
IT CANT BE THE SHERIFF because we need a sense of serious foreboding and creepiness about Red John for it to be Red John. We need to see Red John in action from a more intimate point of view so as to see the truly dark nature of him before he is caught. There needs to be a creep factor that is off the scale, yo!!! The sheriff is a great actor but just not Red John! Rigsby, with a little more exploration into his divergence from his dad, a dad that happens to be another well known actor, could establish a serious level of darkness, pity, terror, etc..
Show Rigsby hiding in that barn!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16111 • By redrigsby
Show this theory

Robert Kirkland. In Behind The Red Curtain, the 18th episode of the 5th season, Lennon was killed by Robert Kirkland who injected him with a syringe containing air that caused air embolus that made his heart give out.


Sheriff is RJ

Michael Kirkland as the new red jhon

remember 1x01  the smile no is the real RJ

Bob Kirkland kill Lennon was complicit in RJ  ?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11jDYrfH-l0

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on