Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Theory #16153 • By Nope
Show this theory

Bruno Heller said that Xander Berkeley found out he was going to be Red John at "the last moment and he was thrilled" ... 

First question at the top of the page ... 

http://insidetv.ew.com/2013/11/24/the-mentalist-red-john-interview/2/ 

"It's totally fair ... games over I won" - If that was the Sheriff's actual voice then he knew he was Red John the very first time that voice aired on the Mentalist years ago. How can you be on film doing Red John's voice and not know you are going to play Red John until "the last moment"! This means plain and simple .... that was not Xander Berkeley's voice or Bruno lied about when Xander found out and I see absolutely no reason to lie about that. If it was not his voice then Bruno Heller is not telling us one of a two things ...

1. Red John is not Sheriff McAllister
2. They had someone else do Red John's voice the whole time and Xander was lip sinking (If that is the case it's pretty poor planning but at least tell me who the actor is that does the voice out of curiousity ...

It just doesn't make sense. If Xander really did the voice then he knew for years and if he didn't do the voice then wtf who did? I really don't think this adds up ... Have there been any interviews with Bruno Heller about the Red John voice?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hey "negged" you're an idiot .
1 My theory's are dumb but your theories about red john being patrick jane are cool?
2. Who gives a shit about likes and dislikes ?! And i bet i have gotten more than u haha
3. This is not school. F grammar grandma ... I write most of my post as i am driving and never proofread it once ...why u ask? Because i am not a f'n weirdo like u!!
Thanks.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

First, we all knew it wasnt Bertram.

Sherrif was my second guess, the best characther for the job, a friendly hunter. He wasnt my first because EVERYONE GOT SURPRISED WITH HIM IN THE LIST. NO ONE HAD REASON TO SUSPECT HIM BEFORE THIS SEASON. Was this a puzzle? No, because we couldnt find out, just guess. He should learn with "inception". The movie its self was An inception. This wasnt a puzzle.

I expected the Rj showing him self at the last moment, when we find out it's not the other. The only thing is i hoped to be Stiles the fake RJ and Haffner the real RJ revealing him self.

I think it's because he called Lisbon and told so. At least he Thinks it's over. But, if noone knows who Rj is, what about cordero? . I hope RJ is alive, but probably will appear someone else connected to him.

This blog was for nothing, almost useless,, the RJ wasnt chose before. They just decided the less likely one to be the RJ.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The biggest disappointment for me is not that it was McAllister, but the fact that he was running away, begging and being terrified of dying. That's my biggest problem. It doesn't make any sense to me that they wanted to close the Red John storyline like this.
Have they never seen a good thriller with a psycho serial killer in it? Like Kevin Spacey's character in Seven, or Anthony Hopkins in Hannibal?? Would they beg and cry? No, because they are sick, mentally insane psychopaths..Even Kirkland was more of a psycho, just accepted that he was going to be killed..
Why did they make such a huge mistake and made Red John a regular person?? I don't understand and I never will..Very sad for us fans who never in a million years thought that it will end in such a cheap, unimaginative way..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Red John should be like Hannibal . For those of you who have watched Hannibal, when Will Graham and Hannibal come face to face and Will Graham discovers he is the murderer, that's how it's done. So tense, so dark and done so well. Hannibal is an utter evil genius as Red John should be.

I'm still going to watch and hope that we get a good season finale to The Mentlaist.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

You think you guys got it bad? I unfortunately made a few bets on the Red John saga. . .

$1000 on Partridge as Red John
$1000 on Michael Kirkland being Rosalynd's Lover
$500 on Roy Tagliaferro being Ray Haffner's original name
$500 on all 7 suspects being alive at the start of episode 8.

However I did win a $1 bet that RJ was not gay. 

So I'm down $2999 . . ..


I don't blame Heller... I blame myself.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16147 • By RedJaina
Show this theory

Who's the bigger pussy?

GREEN:  Ezra "A" Fitz (Pretty Little Liars)

RED: Tom "Red John" McAllister

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on