Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Fuck the Mentalist.
Was my favorite crime mystery show up until Season 6 with all this bull about the Tyger Tyger elite, pigeons, considerable plot holes that weren't resolved, and with the McCallister reveal as Red John it pointed very much in the direction that this show was a knock off of the Profiler.

If you want to watch an impressive crime mystery show then watch Sherlock.


It gets a 91 on metacritic.com. and a 9.2 on IMDB.
Cumerbatch and Freemans performance as Sherlock and Watson leave Jane and Lisbon trembling in their boots.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I can't believe what some people are saying about Red John begging for mercy.
Most serialkillers are cowardly bastards, same goes for Red John, where you expecting some kind of a evil superhero?
I think the episode show his true colors well.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I need help
I am in denial.
Why am I having so much trouble accepting this?
I do not accept it.
I cannot accept it.

Am I going to meet with disappointment for the next 13 Sundays?

I admit that "My Blue Heaven" was well done. I am not satisfied. But it was well done.

However, I could not help but continue to look for clues that lead to Red John (or rather, lead to something that will lead to Red John.)

The cinematography was interesting, Did anyone notice the 'haziness' that was present in every scene with Jane, even when he was back in the U.S.? Patrick and Kim mentioned 'Dream Worlds' while strolling on the shore.

I knew something was up with Kim. The scene after Patrick was beat up, as well as the following morning, were reminiscent of Jane's first meeting with Lorelei. I think it was intentional.

What was up with Cho's inaudible snicker as Jane was walking away? Was it "he's fu**ed, the poor bastard", or "gosh! It's so nice to see Jane after all this time".

I think Patrick is still lying comatose in a hospital bed, following the explosion at his house. If that were the case, everything since is figment, including Abbott. I love his character. Even though he is a douchebag, he is a great character. You hate him so much that you love him.

Are they going to close this website down, given that it is now superfluous?

I didn't see CBI Ron in this episode.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think there are 2 main types of fans.

1. Those who loved the serial killer storyline and although enjoyed the murder solving in each episode, their main interest was the background story. The suspense, the excitement that the person who killed PJ's family could be someone we know and like, when will he kill again, etc..

2. Those who never  cared that much about the RJ storyline and are just happy with the every day murder cases.

I think most people who come to this website are in group 1. 

I really don't know what to feel now that Bruno Heller f**ked us over. Are we supposed to settle and be forced into group 2? After 5 and a half years suddenly should we just accept that all there is in the future is lukewarm vanilla, no big mystery? 
It's a shock to the system..It's really like a brand new show now. I'm still hanging in there because of PJ, Lisbon and Cho but I don't know for how long..

PS; I'm not sure I want to see that bitch new woman on a weekly basis..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This show is about Red John, that's what sets it apart from the generic procedural cop shows out there. So Red John needs to either come back or they just need to end it because who wants to watch a soap opera?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Dear Mr.
Heller,




you are are
a man well known for surprises and The Mentalist season 6 is a good example for
that. You managed it, that after 5 and a half years this popular series will be
destroyed by the death of Red John and the disgusting and sadistic behaviour of
Patrick Jane within a few minutes. Nothing
is left of the wonderful time. No one did
something like this before. Congratulations.

I am very angry.

 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'd like to talk about episode 8 and 9.I tried not to but after i saw episode 9 i just can't.

Episode 8:

What the fucking fuck was this shit? This villager is Red John? The fearsome serial killer that killed many and lives of many are controlled by him gets pwned by a fucking pigeon after he killed Partridge in a house full of pigeons?.Logic.
Then he begs for mercy? A psycho killer / organisation leader begs for mercy? Even a small drug dealer wouldn't.I was waiting all these years for an episode that shows Red John for 20 minutes and 15 of these minutes its RJ running/crying begging for mercy?
Bullshit. But ok i got over it.So i was waiting episode 9 to cover up the mess.Explain things about visualize , RJ that we never learnt and stuff.

And what do we see at episode 9? A HAPPY GUY IN VACATION WITH A BITCH.What???

To bruno heller: Just stop writing.Finish this show no need to convert this nice show into a fucking soap opera.

Thanks an ex watcher.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on