Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Ok, I'm half way in my 6/9 view.

I think we should change the series title, then I'll be fine with it. I could even watch it.

The sentiMentalist

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm watchin 6/9 right now. I had to make a break, after the first 10 min. I could make my own special comment as Americ, just not with the video alone but with words alone. What the hell...? But I'll end with ***** *****  ****** ****** ******

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16237 • By whiteeagle
Show this theory

PJ is now more stronger than before, he will probably have access to FBI files, and he surely would want to know who were RJ friends in FBI.
i think that is the main reason he accepted this job offer, and he will discover uggly things happening, not only in California this time, but nationwide.
Remember what haffner said to lisbon once; PJ had upset a lot of powerful people not just RJ. Meaning RJ is one of many.

as for " He is mar" could it be He is Marshall? talking about Mcallister, too many people ignore the difference.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I never thought I would say this, because I was always against the idea, in fact I hated it.
I still think it would be weird, but because the Red John fans' dreams didn't come true, I hope at least the Jisbon fans' dreams will come true before the show is finished.

It was kind of nice to see Lisbon missing PJ in this last episode. I dislike the new woman so much that I wouldn't mind anymore if PJ and Lisbon get together in the end. I love Lisbon much more than I did before, after all the disappointments and new cast, I've really warmed to her now.:)




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

If the mentalist does get picked up for a seventh season (I doubt it) but if it does the season 7 premier should start off with a Red John murder and they end the series right.  Is it ok to kill anyone in cold blood as long as you think(with no real hard evidence) they killed your family?  I hope it is another Timothy Carter twist and the real Red John is just messing with Jane turning him into a serial killer like himself     the show leaves it open for a Partridge fake death or the Kirkland twin as Red John storyline or Stiles/Haffner excape after concussion blast before lethal detonation or the most shocking someone not on the list like Mashburn or Manelli       Hopefully The Mentalist gets picked up for another season Heller comes to his senses and listens to the outrage of the critics and fans of the show and goes back to the Red John saga and gives us the satisfying conclusion we deserve because the whole timing and execution of the reveal and the death of Red John just doesn't make any fuckin sense      my mind had been blown at how badly they fucked up this show   if it was done right I would have recomended it to everyone I know but instead I don't even want to admit to anyone that I ever followed such a lame piece of unsatisfying shit  and that is coming from someone who owns every season and has watched every episode at least 3 times over and every Red John episode so much I have them memorized  putting together every little clue Heller left us trying to solve the Red John puzzle         It's like Heller died before the sixth season started and a bunch of writers who hate The Mentalist took over and said "let's end the Red John storyline without any explanation and turn the show into White Collar"   you know what would be fun and different? let's skip ahead 2 years and have an entire episode about Jane on vacation dancing in a dress        Simon Baker gets a directing credit on this episode .......FUCK YOU!!!!! YOU PRETENTIOUS CUNT  Has anyone ever tried to catch a pigeon and kept it motionless in their pocket      and why go through all the trouble to keep your identity secret just to reveal yourself any way   if McAllister would have took his time to explain everything to Jane Abbott would have shown up with the entire FBI and busted Red John    none of this makes sense     McAllister's actions are that of a man who was orderd to play Red John and kill Jane not that of a serial killer and criminal mastermind     and even if CBS was gonna cancel the Mentalist after this season  why end the Red John story in the first third of the season ? to have Jane move on for half a season ???    who gives a fuck?  Episode 9 My Blue Heaven minus the FBI nonsense should have been the last episode of the series or bonus features on the DVD box set           what's left?  a happy Jane solves murders with the FBI while frustrating Abbott with his unorthodox antics?      the murder of the week episodes were entertaining enough but only tolerated till you finally got a little taste of Red John     Without Red John I don't know if I  could tolerate this show                    they could have also done Jane strikes oil and moves to Beverly Hills  or Jane goes on a three hour bout tour and gets stranded on an island that would make the fuckin retard average viewer happy    they type who just watch random CSI episodes on a neverending loop with the volume on high to drown out the sound of their kids     fuck you assholes who say you are happy the Red John story is over  let's see Jane move on ..........let's not let's have the series end with Jane all alone and miserable after not getting any satisfaction from the revenge of his family's murder    Jane relizes he is Red John and puts a gun in his mouth and pulls the trigger   if they would have done all this at the end of the first season with Partridge as Red John it would have been better than a five year cock tease that ends with blue balls      fuckin cunts               

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I miss Red John... I want him back. Even some flash backs of him killing/making the tricks would do. Or a web series about it! Anyways the new episode looked really mediocre in my opinion.

What do you think?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on