Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Just my opinion and this helps me sleep at night.... ;)

The entire show ever since the time of the explosion @ Jane's house has all been a hallucination of Patrick's. (or Lisbon's. she did get knocked back pretty hard too.)

(Hopefully) The last couple episodes of this season will be Jane waking up and the writers showing us what really happened inside his house after the explosion and how Red John is still alive and yet to be found.

Hopefully Haffner and Stiles will still be alive and making mischief. That was such a compelling storyline that I miss a lot!! It was really starting to heat up!
Reed Diamond plays that role exceptionally well ....he's much too interesting to kill off. 
 
All I want for Christmas (since world peace seems out of reach at the moment)
is for Red John to be Ray Haffner! (or someone more exciting that the sheriff).
Come on Santa!! I've been good this year!!!!!  ;-P


P.S. Did anyone else notice this:
When Haffner and Lisbon were at the CBI after he makes her a job offer and she walks in on him looking at the board of people.
And as they are talking she says he can't be surprised she won't be taking his job offer.
And THEN...as he's standing in front of the board of people he says to her (paraphrased),

"Lisbon you're missing out on something really big here." -This could mean the job offer OR it could also be his subtle way of telling her she's missing out on the fact that he's Red John or she's missing out on a very big clue.
He's standing right in front of the board at the same time he says this. I just find it very hard to believe he's not involved or actually RJ. If he's not, it was a true waste of a very intriguing storyline and Reed's acting talent. But something tells me....he is RJ. But more importantly, I just want Reed back on the show! :)

Thanks for listening everyone! I look forward to reading more of your theories and have enjoyed many of the ones I've seen on here.  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16534 • By bluesilverball
Show this theory

When Patrick Jane was in the church and Fighting or shooting at Red John a woman run up and attack Jane with knife (?) Red John I think the women was Red John went the FBI Showed up she was walking away. maybe or not

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After study a little the encrypted "list", I think that is not a list, is more like a message... or just one name... 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Im just happy to come here and read what fans have to other angles for Red John.
The imaginative power to how his exit should have been.
It's therapy to me because his conclusion was indeed a let down.

Thank You Guys.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Did macalister say right before he dies "i have a psychic" ? It sure sounded like he did . Maybe we will get to meet him or her .
Also i notice that whenever jane is watching the infamous tiger chasing the deer scene on tv. (I think it happened a few times) the lion is always a female !
I always thought red john was a woman.

Side note: kim fisher was NOT hired by the fbi to spy on patrick .
Abbot was planning on "turning over every rock to find him"
It seemed like he had no idea kim was in mexico too.
Who hired her ?
Why is she so weird ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16522 • By Jjcfinalhope
Show this theory

The full RJ plot is way too complex to communicate through writing. So I'll shorten it to the most surprising spoilers. This is going to be hard to believe, but there's masses of unwritten information backing this all up.

Episode 8 is Kim Fischer's dream, hence why the chemistry between CBI members is wrong and why there's so many random shifts. The little girl you see closing the door on McAllister is a young Kim. The dream is after Kim has read a case file on Patrick Jane. The case is full of misguided information because Jane tricked everybody including Lisbon to catch Red John. Only 4 living men know of how Jane actually lured out Red John. Gale Bertram, Robert Kirkland, Thomas McAllister and Bret Stiles (And one living woman-Lorelei Martins). Hence nothing you saw in episode 8 actually happened.

In episode 9, Kim Fischer makes her first appearances and talks about dream worlds. You want to know why Jane is so close to her, why he was so surprised when he wakes up and sees her, why she makes great tea and is no threat to Lisbon? She is Jane's daughter. When Jane woke up (after being beat up) and saw her, there is an uncanny resemblance to his wife. In episode 10, Jane talks to her by her first name, and he pokes fun at her in the briefing like an embarrassing father. "I knew you saw me. I knew it," after she ignored him the first time.

Brett Partridge, Red John, is seen as the very last person in her dream. He didn't kill her. He kidnapped her and she was hypnotised to forget him. This is why she can only see him from the back. Her subconscious vaguely remembers him, but the hypnotism prevents his face becoming clear. However you do hear Brett Partridge's voice for 1 line in the dream episode.

And the hardest spoiler to take; Jane and Partridge were twins. Their father was Bret Stiles and their mother was Elise Vogelsong. Stiles, who Jane used as leverage , to eventually disarm and kill Partridge can be seen drinking his troubled memories of torture, away in My Blue Heaven. There is a scene where Jane introduces Kim to Roger, which is Stiles and all 3 generations are next to each other.

Elise Vogelsong was a murder mystery fanatic. Partridge inherits love of murder and death. Jane inherits a love of mystery and detective work. They both drank tea as Stiles has British roots. Both are excellent whistlers. And in season 5 episode 15, you see Jane finishing Partridge's sentence about "Bleak House, by Charles Dickens." Also, in William Blake's full poems the Lamb and the Tyger are born of the same creator. Jane is Lamb, Partridge is the Tyger and Stiles is the creator. And Patrick Jane translates into Pink Jane, which is the inspiration of the mirror name Red John.

I understand its hard to swallow, and hey I'm not forcing you too...





... But we all want to see an epic finale right , like maybe the real Red John ending? Don't be so quick to extinguish another's hope if you refuse to let your own candle burn.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For

Red-John-Is-Alive:

I take your advice, and I'm very sorprised changing every character for one number in order of appereance.... there 24 different characters:



Ѳ 1


ɸ   2



F   3


♠   4


♦   5


▲  6


˨˩    7


ᵜ    8


■   9


○   10


╧   11


Χ   12


˨    13


Δ   14


⌂   15


ʘ   16


⊄   17


Θ   18


↑    19


Ф    20


├    21



♥    22


◄   23


Ξ    24

So, now we can beggin to analize the list with numbers, and find something that make sense....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on