Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

The real two faced genius, mastermind of this series and even a killer himself is JANE! I dont know how they will put it togather, but that would be the only explanation for our unanswered questions by now.

I will write all the evidence ill find about that. I dont care what Heller said. Of course he said yes, Jane is not RJ..it would be STUPID for him to even give hints of PJ being RJ in the interviews. If he would do such thing the show would be ruined( yes, people who think that the show is for now ruined i agree) The ooonly way to make it right is by making Jane RJ or something like that. Please no more dead  Brett and Brett and Haffner. 


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Mentalist
I think that Red john was never roy tagliafaro. He just drew the face to throw jane off coarse. This gets confusing but it has to do with the tanner family . This name comes up a lot . They owned the visualize farm. The brother of tanner comes into play in the dumar episode. Tanner was building the farm, this is why he smells of pine . He was with Rosalind during this time . Then red john bought the farm as dumar says .
When rosaline said he left without saying why or returning is because his daughter was murdered. I forget what episode it was but he had to be with his family when this happened. Red john was messing with jane by putting the smiley face there .
Think about it . Why would he be bangin Rosalind and then draw a face . If he was with her he would wanna hide it. BUT he wasnt with her and drew his mark to show jane that he was there.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For 5 seasons and 7 episodes I was kinda obsessed with the show.I tried to figure out who Red John is, to put clues together visiting sites like this etc.
Then I saw ep.8.

*Anyway, I just wanted to share a dream I had last night.I saw that a lot of people posted different theories over the storyline about the Red John reveal and death.Then the others voted them.After that. a lot of "The Mentalist" fans started a site named
www.MoneyForRedJohn.com
where people could donate money in order to make our own episode with our own script and the Mentalist team.(of course).That would be awesome.(And impossible too, ok I know right? :) ).I believe that came to my mind after this thing I've heard about a millionaire who was willing to give 60 million dollars in order to make one last episode of "Breaking Bad"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!???

P.S.:Please continue posting theories about RJ's return, you are giving me
hope! <3

And something last, I totally agree with the guy who posted the theory:
 Jane said that "Reede Smith is not RJ cause of his breakdown and RJ wouldn't do that even if he was acting"
So why the hell after he kills the Sheriff he doesn't come up with the same conclusion?+The fact that McAllister gives the whole "hypnotized guy" vibe.
Two posibilities here:
1st:Another plot hole.(We must admit there are a lot)
2nd:Another brilliant masterplan by Jane to catch RJ?Hope so.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well there is certainly loads of questions to be answered, but I just noticed one more: Why the hell did Bob Kirkland kill Jason Lennon in 5x18? Does not make any sense at all? Jason Lennon knew who Red John was. Kirkland was after Red John. He was prepared to torture people for that information. Confusing.. Anybody have any theories regarding that? The only thing I can think of is the whole Michael Kirkland thing...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Don't you think it's weird that Bret Stiles and Ray Hafner were not mentioned even once after "Red John's" death? I mean Haffner did not do anything wrong and was killed because he liked lisbon? Maybe Haffner is Red John and he used Stiles's help to outsmart Patrick (which is a reasonable theory) since he is a memeber of visualize. He can seduce/brainwash women or use women in Visualize to do his bidding...............with help from his mentor Stiles. Still too many questions unanswered like he is Mar...............what does that mean!!!

Give us answers Bruno. Now!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16614 • By freaks
Show this theory

How dumb can you be people?? Others would like to comment on the show's development but they are not interested in discussing dead Red John and you scare them away?? So pretty soon it will be only you deluded freaks here, the laughing stock of everyone?
Haha, OK, just carry on with your dumb theories, other fans who are interested in the show without dead Red John will go somewhere else. You sad losers! :)))

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #16613 • By Shrink
Show this theory

Change this website's name to something else. The Red John saga is over whether you want to admit it or not, if not than you need to get help from a psychologist.
Maybe it could be something like: Patrick Jane's adventures at the FBI. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on