Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

I think Red John is Kristina Frye. She is one of the few people that have the same skills as Patrick and appears to manipulate people with ease. She is also one of the only people that Patrick has had problems reading.

All the evidence points to Red John being a man.. the witness statements, the rape... But if we think about RJ's track record he has always used accomplices and at least one of his accomplices convinced the CBI team that he was RJ himself, therefore I don't think RJ has to be a man. I think RJ has to be someone who can manipulate men to pretend to be RJ. The rape was also not committed by RJ but by the man Lorelei killed in the last episode.

Women are more hated as criminals, it is somehow more shocking and dramatic (which is what the producers are looking for) for RJ to be a woman, especially when all evidence appears to suggest he is a man.

Kristina'a storyline was unbelievable. She was sure that RJ would not hurt her when she spoke of him on TV. This is not a conclusion a normal person would make from looking at the evidence. She then 'vanished' whilst under the guard of Van Pelt (who has also gone a little crazy since spending time with Kristina in my opinion). There was no apparent disturbance she just vanished which incriminates one of them or both of them to me. She is also the only person (to my recollection) who has survived a RJ kidnapping aside from PJ. Her appearance after her abduction was equally strange and unbelieveable. It is also incomprehensible that PJ would have just given up on her after the few minutes of trying to make her talk. She is the only survivor of RJ and she was very close with PJ, you would think he may at least visit her in a later episode.

RJ is a master manipulator with the same skills as PJ. Kristina shares her brilliance with Patrick in manipulation.

The letter RJ left to PJ when he killed his family taunts him about not being 'a real psychic'. Kristina is adamant that she is 'a real psychic.' Obviously real psychics do not exist so Kristina is not to be trusted.

Kristina and PJ shared a connection that explains their fascination with each other on another level - neither like to be outsmarted and both like game-playing.

Kristina appears to be about the same age as RJ may be and we didn't find out about her background.

RJ would not have spared Kristina's life. Also Kristina has sat happily out of view for a few seasons now so that we all forget her.


 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #1796 • By Murphy
Show this theory

Hey,
I just watched episode 24 from season 4 and had a funny thought.What if the client Oscar is RJ. (The one who interupted Patrick and Lorelei at the bar and whose bodyguard beat Patrick up)I somehow got the impression that Lorelei had met him before and:-he has money (bodyguard)-he is a male -age and discribed look of RJ fit-RJ kills mostly females. Maybe because auf a trauma similar to the one Oscar told PJ (about his mum not being dead but abandon him)-he touched Patrick on the shoulder and Patrick will certainly have shaken hands with him the first time they met because he was a client.

If he is RJ, then he did it to get Patrick behind bars so Lorelei could buy Patrick out and find an easyaccess to him....The whole scenerio was planned. So were thethe cops that arrived just at the right time...The story about his mother might be true or might be invented to become Patricks clientbut if the story is true he has a personal grudge against Patrick.Then (if he is RJ) Patrick might have betrayed him before he killed Patricks wife and daughter. But he did not intend to seek revenge on Patrick from the beginning.He started killing femals because his mothers betrayl was bigger and he knew that Patrick is someone not to mess with. But then Patrick went to that TV show and he decided to teach him a lesson. And in season 4 he pretended again to seek his help with the intention  to show Patrick what happends if you mess with people and to get him arrestet and Lorelei could pass on his message...It would have also given him a kick to see if Patrick remembers him.

What do you think?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Regarding "he is mar"

I think that Jared was trying to write "He is married", and that while he did not know Rjs identity he knew he was married. Which gets me thinking about Rosalind and how she could fit in if in fact RJ is married. Also it could be like how Jane told that woman in the bar he was married even though his wife was dead. It is possible RJ has a dead wife as well, maybe someone Rosalind reminds him of. 

I think that in order to find RJ, Jane and the team will uncover something, somehow about his wife that can give them a lead. Maybe this mystery woman could be someone RJ met on the visualize farm, or that she died when he was working on the farm. 




I think that Lorelei will have let some sort of clue for Jane because she knew very well that she could die I think her way of saying thank you to Jane for finding the truth about Miranda will have been to leave a clue behind. 
Also I used to think Kirkland was RJ but i think that he is just a small pawn in RJs operation and his scenes are only to add suspicion, I don't believe he is a major player in this. 


Let me know what you think, agree or disagree?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #1786 • By redeveryone
Show this theory

I think it should be mentioned the presence of red hair in the show.  When all of Rigsby's internet dating pursuits show up at the office, they all have red hair.  seems fishy to me... I'd be disappointed if it was him but it definitely possible that there's a link.. 


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #1784 • By CHO1131
Show this theory

This isn't about Red John, but, has anyone noticed Cho has gotten chubbier? What's with that?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think it is Bret because he has the power, the money and the men. he is quit dangerous and a dominating man.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on