Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Hi everyone,

This is just for fun: ;)

Just had a wild and wacky thought spark inside my brain. 
Probably my mind's way of breaking up some of the tension for us for a moment.
Because after a while all the reading, thinking, writing, debating and theorizing can be  a lot of fun but also exhausting.

Here's what came to me:

A visual where Red John is revealed in the last scene of the last episode of series is where Patrick Jane turns to the camera, faces us, the viewer and says, It was YOU!!!!! YOU are Red John!!!!!

We see what we've been longing for:
A flood of flashbacks on the screen and somehow we each see our own face revealed as RJ's mask is taken off!!!! How could this be???

And because we are all so tired, exhausted and burnt out from our waiting and hoping and nail biting, and analyzing, each of us actually jumps up off our couch and yells aloud

Could this be?? Was it really me?? Am I Red John???? Damn!!!! It was ME all along!!!!!!!!!!!! Have I been hypnotized to think i am just a viewer? Man talk about a shocking reveal!
This really IS a surprise twist ending!!!!!

And because our disappointment with episode 8 ran so deep... we would actually rather be RJ than have it be that lamea$$ ending of the sheriff being rj.
Wow. We REALLY did not like that ending did we? 

Bruno Heller. Evil genius? Madman? Hypnotist of the masses? Catalyst for world-wide nervous breakdowns? Or con-man extraordinaire?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi hating mofos. Guess what guys i get people daily telling me they love what i write and want to talk about it .
But people like u have no theorys of your own. You just hate hate hate .
Go head , explain what your great outstanding theory is ?
O i c you think macalister is red john . Ok. So why do u come to this website then? Maybe a little bit of doubt?
Look make fun of me all you want but in the end you just bullys sitting behind a computer making fun of a fan of the show you Supposively love .
Why dont u wait till the end of the season to see if im right ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

- Patrick Jane on Stoopkid.

You enter the website and the very first thing you see is a dripping red theory by Stoopkid. Then you feel the dread, and you know what's happened. And then and only then do you see the braindead victims.; it's always in that order.

If you don't get horny reading your own theories, then I'm Britney Spears.

I'm sorry. He irks me. He's irksome.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Brett partridge is red john because he is creepy and his first line was "red john enters here "

This is a great theory and should get 10000 plausible clicks right?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

You read my case file ? Haha
You have nothing against me but you periodically check my profile stats? I didnt even know there were such things.
You cant say my theorys are better or worse because they are the same
You have no idea whats gonna happen so why act all high and mighty like you and all the "true mentalist fans" had great theorys. What partridge is red john? Great theory so smart .
Listen buddy, theres gonna be a lot of surprises coming soon and they of coarse will be red john related.
Im not here for green buttons im here to spark debate but nobody wants to talk about anything except for a few smart people who see the se clues as i do.
Yea there are MANY people who believe red john is alive so my question is , who the heck are you to make fun of my theorys?
Question, is rigsny being written off the show?
Ok now ask yourself how, and get back to me when it happens . K ? Cool
And let me know how my stats are please since you check it hoping nobody agrees with me haha

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

There is a big mismatch here . If someone posted the right theory it would get 90% Red, discouraging others from reading it and burying it. The average intelligence of the whole site dropped after the reveal. It becomes unbearable to see every other theory whining about Heller. They're pretty much the most popular theories too. Pre-RJ reveal, I clicked on Stoopkid's profile. His theories used to be 90% red. Now they're around 40-70% Red.

I have nothing against Stoopkid, but his theories haven't got any better. The site audience has changed. A lot of the dedicated site members stayed, but there weren't many of them.


I'm under no delusions, this place has become a ranting ground, where real theories cannot thrive.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Jane knows something about Kim Fischer that even she doesn't know. At first, I thought the theory about Kim Fischer being Jane's daughter as ridiculous, but the more I see her with Jane, the more I see it.

Jane says, and I quote, "I understand you Kim. I understand you very well. Better than you do yourself." Green Thumb.

In My Blue Heaven, Jane says his wife died but he doesn't say his child died. It looks very innocent. Then we find out Fischer looks very similar to the little girl in episode 8. There is something very off about the episode. Is it Fischer's dream? There are screaming women. There is Brett Partridge in front of a slide. If Brett Partridge is Red John, it is possible Jane's daughter was never murdered. She could have been kidnapped. But she would have been hypnotised to forget her former life and Partridge. This is why her subconscious can't access the face of the man in front of the slide.

Green Thumb episode was about a kidnapping and dual identities.

If you watch in My Blue Heaven, when Jane wakes up after being beaten up, he looks spooked when he sees her from the back. It's very possible she resembles his wife. She makes great tea. There's role reversal when Kim orders Jane around in Green Thumb. There's a scene where Jane is embarrassing her during the meeting. There's definitely something strange about their dynamic.

Crazy theory right?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on