Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Out of curiosity, where are you folks getting the idea that Jane is going to be encountering any legality issues regarding Red John?

Because that is frivolous.

There will be no charges against Jane, for killing Red John (and yes, Macallister was Red John)

It's so obvious the show is setting up for a series finale. Not a season finale, but a series finale.

The remaining cast is going to go there own ways.

I know everyone wants Red John back, but it will not happen.

In just a little over 5 weeks, the only episodes you will be watching from there on, will be reruns.

Sadly, the show botched the Red John chapter, but he has already been revealed, killed and is no longer part of the show.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Thank God the Haibach thing was so short.
There is not a single big storyline going on now. This means that the only story line left is going to be Red John related with Jane in court.
This also means that they are going to spend time on it and not just brush by it.

Things will be explained. Janes future depends on it.
For Jane to go to trail now means he pissed off the Fbi right?
That was Abbots deal with him.
Lisbon is leaving with Pike which makes me think more Jane blows up the Fbi relationship.
He never liked or trusted them. He only joined the fbi to check it out and like its a fishbowl.
Every tv show i have ever seen in its entirety tied up all or most lose ends.
The plot holes will be filled and ifs gonna be awesome.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Bugged CBI member 100% sure.

http://s27.postimg.org/9d5sbyxcz/Van_Pelt.jpg

Virgil Minelli appears in 6x22 (Blue Birds) :D

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The season isn't over yet...........and there's still the season finale.          every season finale of The Mentalist has always been the best and most thrilling ep of the season         what's the season 6 finale gonna be?          Stiles/Haffner return?   McAllister as RJ explanation?     real Red John returns?           it has to be Red John related to have any impact at all          there's no time left in the season to build any tention or drama with another killer/storyline              ther's a reason Jane came back to work with the FBI      Jane hasn't moved on at all                  and is Agent Kim Fisher the worst character in Mentalist history ?      she's all over the place?  and she has a crush on Lisbon        her eyes bug out when she sees Lisbon in that dress, she's asking Cho Jisbon questions  is she thinkin bout Lisbon when she's waving around her wand?           she's fuckin straight up nuts           just the way Red John likes em          and Whylie could be RJ's computer hacker?  he's creepy enough  and do you believe McAllister could pull off all RJ's computer hacking                          there's nothing new at all about this New Beginning                                 they can still save the season and the series with a killer season finale                   maybe there's more to Red John than just McAllister       like a group or a mastermind                        i think the most shocking would be that Jane is really behind Red John and that he is fuckin crazy                                                                                                                                 did anyone ever imagine in a million years that Red John would be deathly afraid of birds, phone 9-1-1 , and claim to be a real psychic???                                       they never put any closure on Stiles or Visulize and the fact that they are never mentioned is proof that they are not done

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Dear Bruno Heller, Simon Baker [and the various writers they found in a cave somewhere....],



STOP reminding us of clues that were never solved!! [and that you have no intention OF ever solving]

You are putting bullshit in our faces when we're already standing in pigeon shit.






 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ever since the beginning of the "new" Mentalist, we have been getting Red Herrings. 

1) I'm going to paint the whole town Red - Patrick Jane

2) The name of the motel Grace was staying at.

3) The way Ardiles was killed seemed like Red John's doing, but what was interesting was the finger cutting that Haibach wanted to do just like Red John ordered.

4) And most recently, the psychic who told him to look "near a body of water". That is too much to be a coincidence............ but what should we make of these Red Herrings?

5) Also he is MAR............... (Marcus pike).

Coincidence or not? You be the judge.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hmm, I'm kind of confused with the last episode.
From the second I
heard the talking clock and the alarm and the countdown thing, I knew
they would trick the time to make the suspects reveal themselves, despite that, it's still a good trick.
I guessed it was the new wife from her reaction when Patrick accused the husband sat on the couch.
Am I the only one ? well there were only 2 suspects so I'm not proud ^^

What made this a good episode :
- Habbot and Jane, argue about psychic power (reminds me 4x03.
- The "Teresa" thing, and Lisbon still calling him "Jane".
- Everyone got his place in this episode.


Finally
I liked the episode, even if they drag it on so long with the state of
Jane's mind, with background development between the new characters (
according to the writing speed, we should wait an entire season to
achieve this).
From episode 8-9, we were supposed to meet the "new
Jane", I feel we still didn't see it. As we know, they wrapped up badly
the red john saga in 8 episode, while there is only 5 episode left until
season finale : I wonder how could they wrap this new stuff in this
short amount of time, and bring us a Real RedJohn ending/reborn at the same time.
In conclusion : we are screwed.





Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on