Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

hey folks..nice to write back..now, yea I was a tad disappointed on the RJ reveal..OK more than a tad ..:) ..but hey, thats life..we would never know why Heller did what he did and would have to trust his judgement as any other theory makes him suck and I cant believe the creator who gave us 4 marvelous seasons could play with our TV-sentiments..lol..but life looks forward
                        so after thinking more theories about how RJ could still be alive, I decided not to. coz it did not feel healthy..it bordered on obsessiveness..i am not saying it is surely a bad thing as it anyway is a very enjoyable exercise but sill, we need to stop at some point right..
                         I also dont think any ideas like the "dream" and stuff are gonna be very appealing..come-on, the appeal of the show lies in the fact that RJ PJ  and all lived real lives..it is a tough job ahead for heller to chart out PJ's life-story sans RJ and that is a thing to watch..and if RJ does make a comeback somehow, well I will think abt it then.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #18143 • By Stoopkid
Show this theory

Here is a route heller could take....i hope..

Make Jason Cooper red john. He is creepy, feminine, and we know nothing about him.
Maybe go the Farragutt route. Cooper was farragutt but faked his death to evade the fbi with the help of Styles.
The fbi was always Visualizes biggest threat as they were trying to arrest Styles for Farragutts death 30 years after the fact for some odd reason. I know this show likes pointless cluess but they brought up Farragutt for no reason so far.
So contrary to what people think Farragutt and Styles are close. Styles was trying to evade the fbi and what better way to than to fake his death? 2pac did it.
Not only that but Styles could ressurect like Jesus for his church just like he wanted.

I have been wondering what the deal with Fischer is . At first i was like ok she sucks but then i realized how irrelevant she really is. Too irrelevant serving no purpose whatsoever. She seems like Visualie to me with her robot personality. She is a visualize mole in the fbi. She hardly talks and takes orders very well. She is obsessed with Jane.
The key moment with her was when she saw Jane took off his wedding ring for their date together. That was the "moment" she spoke of when opening up to Jane.
She was hired by Visualize to watch Jane in mexico too.
Remember she found jane and we all assumed the fbi hired her. BUT Abbott had no idea where Jane was on the island. Wouldnt Fischer call and say he is staying in room blah blah? YES!
At first i thought she was gonna be Janes new love especially when she made him great tea. But no they have not even spoken in 5 episodes.
Maybe forget the whole cooper thing but they should deff play up this Farragutt story line.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

We got zombiefied Frye, blowned up Styles and company, few dead people "randomly" killed as Partridge, Lorelei etc, we got Lisbon, who is left unharmed for no reason by RJ unlike the unfortunate psy wich head was chopped off (no big deal, really) and last, your familly gets killed by some psychopath, but never mind who, what, how and why because this show is about mentalism as Heller says....just great.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So, imagine this people....as this show is going to hell anyway, the best and stunning ending would be as Theresa and Jane get togather, than Theresa in season 7 discover that Jane is the real RJ, or Pike discovers it and shoots Jane. Than this whole RJ ending would be explained as we deserve it. If you combine all the facts about RJ, all you have to think about is this.....who is the covincing RJ...Mcallister or PJ? Who of them is more similar to RJ...? Season 6 is a con mans work i tell you.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Is it only me ? or what we have here is truly a sad case of schizophrenic individual that spams this site in utterly poor way?

I believe he comes in many forms . . . if you watch  behaviour of few things : ( such as ) 

It always comes with VARIABLE intro ( i really loved this episode/ vs / this episode was stupid  ... and transmoprhs few sentences later into, but the RJ stuff is over.

Also the times of the comments and time difference between those posts seems to indicate so.

We also had the IMDB faker coming back and back like a punching clown.

Plus the outbursting guys who will hack this site and destroy us all.

Speculative clues : i wonder if the guy whos got a crush on Stoopkid and goes after BringmoreW and All those others figures ( usually agressive ) ... 

are purely fictional .. as I suppose we've got a single person here who pretends to be em all . . 

I might be very wrong with this.. but in the end, the thing is .... I'm tired of those imature piles of horse***** ... and I wonder what on earth could make em go away . .. . they are all those things Jane said RJ in the very first episode.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

AFTER 6 SEASONS…AND 138 EPISODES…IT'S ALL BEEN BUILDING UP…TO THIS......."don't go, don't break up the team"............. What the fuck is this fuckin bullshit? Don't break up the team? What team? The Rigsbys are already gone...hey Jane remember when you killed McAllister in cold blood with your bare hands and the took off to South America for two whole fuckin years? Did you care about the team then? You had 6 whole fuckin seasons to make your move and you are gonna wait till Lisbon accepts a proposal and a job offer and is on the plane to say something......... I just hope this promo is as misleading as the Jane on trial for RJ's murder promo------------the first 3 seasons of The Mentalist were great and Timothy Carter is Red John in my mind... That's how I'll remember this show .........not the fuckin farce it turned into

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Only if this page is closed down I'll stop bitching at Heller's con. Well, end of the season and of course no more Red John cause there's no hope about it unless Heller has a "manic" state of mind and steal some ideas from this page. The case will be a filler, no doubts about it, so I present  2 stupid scenarios for ya watchers :

1) PJ and TL are found naked on the couch after a nice waiting for 10 years fuck nite, both are fired from the F.B.I for misconduct and take the airstream or an old car (as seeing on a pic prom) with some "Grease" song as background to hit the road. 

2) Well, some cheesy crap ... like he proposing at Alexandria's church with RJ's spirit floating around with dozens of pigeons blessing the union.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on