Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Apologies for bad english in advance

Heller could have said-'He is mar' is a blind clue left by Red J himself. The 7 suspects might have been revealed by Jane to someone during a psychotic break. Lorelei maybe- all the time he spent with her? Would be interesting if Jane actually had a psychotic break at the end of 4- when he thought he was faking it.  Blake A was needed maybe cos it does seem logical that Red J would need people to collect all the info he required. But mcallister could have been shown as some sort of a puppet master- rather than an actual member

Showdown in red J ep should have been structured differently. maybe red J captured Jane and made him listen to all his plans?

Red J should not have been in an official position (sheriff or bertram's role). Official work involves a lot of paperwork- and somehow I do not see Red J doing any such work. Showman- paralleling Jane (Stiles) suits him better

The lead characters should have continued in their platonic way forever.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

"The Mentalist" explained in 43 seconds :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUiaVUOcsL0

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

The Mentalist Season 7! I cant believe it was renewed. Do you think Red John will have some closure. Will we see how he kills ect. or will it just be about love. Here is what I think

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFt9IRFIAsI

What about you guys what do you want to see from Season 7? :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I haven't ever posted on here, but I have been thinking about the season finale and I thought of a theory. What if Jane and Lisbon are putting on a show? They have done it before. Why else would Lisbon's freak out moment be so cheesy? Also, she was pushing Jane to say what he felt, but then she freaks out on him when he tries to do it in his own way? The whole love thing between them was cheesy so i'm wondering if Jane and Lisbon are just putting on a show for someone. Cho has been with them the whole time and he doesn't see the whole love thing but Abbott does. Cho knew about Grace and Rigsby when they were sneaking around. Maybe they're playing the FBI, I mean, who knows what Jane and Lisbon were talking about when they were writing letters.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Wha goes up must come down...

Jane is at an all time high. He killed his nemesis and got the girl of his DREAMS haha this could all be a dream.
This reminds me of Dexter. Dex always got what he wanted (mostly) and used people like toys just like Jane does. Pretty much everything Lisbon yelled at him for when he got caught lying in the finale.
Season 7 will be Jane slowly down-spiraling. Maybe he has a mental breakdown bc he is RJ or maybe it just all catches up to him. Dexters finale was the first time we saw Dexter as a bad guy or in the wrong. I think this will happen to Jane in season 7 and things will hopefully get dark again.

We all know the actor who plays Haffner said him n Styles will be back and although he kids, i believe him.
I see season 7 as the encore season where all the familiar faces will come back. Maybe Frye and Mashburn possibly or even Lorelie if she is still alive like the picture showed us.

Question: when Lorelie went to go kill Rj and got caught it seemed she was back into thinking he did not kill her sister again right? She seemed cool with him and happy with her fate. So who killed her sister? The BA of coarse.
I still think Lorelie gave Jane the list of 7 and that Jane never had a list but we will have to wait n see.

I think there were two Red Johns and nobody can tell me otherwise. The clues call for two completely different styles and reasons for murder.
When i saw the season finale i thought it was all over BUT thinking about season 7, i have an intuition "things will heat up". Haha

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Although we all love the Red John story arc , the plot was going on for too long and we were being piled with tons of clues which were leading us to nowhere near guessing who Red John was. Before season 6 began, i was happy Red John was going to finally be revealed in the 6th year.............. and along with the reveal i pondered how Heller was going to piece all those clues in episode 8 alone. The Red John arc should have ended sooner before things got out of hand and with Heller repeatedly throwing random clues we were ultimately given no explanation.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Something very strange happened this season.
A different person got control of this show.
It seems that they were trying to get rid off the Red John arc asap.

Then they set up that artificial "jisbon" thing.
I'm not anti-jisbon, but I see that like a secondary thing, not the "grand finale".

I think hey did it to keep high ratings, they gave sh*t to he porks.

This season not only there were massive plot holes, but many mistakes.

Patrick saying that love to Lisbon while still using his wedding ring was sad.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on