Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Theory #18330 • By StupidPoopkidd
Show this theory

Stoopkid aka Anthony is a fucking cocksucker.

No one like's the bastard on here, yet he always tries to say "we dont care" "we this".
Motherfucker no one LIKES you, ever since you spam the website, and even Reddit told you to fuck off HAHAHHA.
Anthony Iezzi AKA STOOPKID812 AKA HUSKAVELI aka natas33
347 E Hector St
Conshohocken, PA 19428-1916
6103049475

This faggot is a sad 33 year old gaylord
"I am almost positive that Rj is a woman after this season" LMAO






Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Oscar Cordero deserved the end he got.

When Jane arrives to the Chapel he does a search on him... finds his gun... takes it from him... then Jane responds with a pun "'worth the shot" but he thinks the whole time "Thank God he didn't find the... pigeon."

No wonder the man under Cordero's protection meet their makers. He was the worst frisker ever.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hey, guys
This is just a question, I wanted to ask.
Which Red John did you like better?

Green :Timothy Carter
Red :Sheriff Thomas McAllister


For me, it's Carter








Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i would have to think that the biggest diversion of all was rosalind harker's description of RJ.  before 6x8 when this site was going nuts, everyone was eliminating suspects based on physical description, mainly by rosalind and sophie.  well since RH was RJ's girlfriend, and we were shown that he visited her after Jane did, and possibly hipnotized her,  we should completely ignore her description.  not only ignore it, we should maybe even look for the opposite in some ways.  hell, PJ didn't believe her, why should we.  if PJ considered reede smith and bret stiles, there is no reason we shouldn't.  Yes, sophie said he was "middle aged", but that is a pretty vague term. 

and i think we can all agree, if stiles was involved somehow, then he wasn't alone or had help.  maybe a son, or a protege he was guiding in his footsteps.  and stiles never denied having links to RJ.  links that were never explained.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Lets say Red John is alive for fun sake.
If what i say is true and Rj used Jane to take down the Ba
then this really proves that Rj loves the shit out of Jane .
Rj does not want to kill Jane at all.
He thinks of him as an old comrade as Lorelei said.
So WHO IS HE? Is he a he?
Red John wants to turn Jane and it kinda worked.
Jane was kinda crazy in season 6 and has a lot more confidence to do anything.
He killed Macalister in cold blood and you could see the pain on Janes face when he did it.
Rj from the season 2 finale " o and Kristina has grown quite fond of you even with all your differences"
Does that sound like Macalister ?!? Particularly fond haha
It kinda sounds like Freye talking in that scene but prob not her.

I cant wait for season 7 as you can see.
I actually love the new characters and show but i love it bc i am almost positive they will revisit the Rj story line along with Visualize.
By now we all know the official story about Janes house is a lie.
It does not add up at all.
Even Smiths story about Rj makes no sense.
Rj used an fbi guy for clearance to kill a secretary who already had the clearance codes!

O on a side note, the Reddit page for this show blowssss
Bunch of close minded losers.
I love when people argue with me and just explain word for word what happened on the show or is written on wiki as there argument. Like dude, i watched the show myself a lot what i am saying is that the show is not telling us everything! Fucking reddit

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i believe that there are 3 people who know the absolute truth.  They are RJ, PJ, and........Crystal.  Halfway thru "White Lines", jane and the hottie are on their date.  She asks about his ring.  he says it is a long story and they better order drinks.  several minutes later, after an absolutely useless scene between fishcer and lisbon that was only their to show that there was a significant lapse in time, jane finishes telling her his story.  she then understands why he still wears his ring.

Now, if he told her that after several years of searching, he finally got his revenge and with it some long overdue closure, then her reaction would have been something like, "wow, so i guess now that it is all over you should consider taking it off and getting back out there".

instead, her reaction was to be understanding that he still wears it.  that would make sense if he had just told her that he just took down the BA, and another RJ accomplice, but he will continue to wear the ring until the day he knows for sure that RJ is dead.

i know for sure that the first thing i am looking at in S7ep1 is janes left hand.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Jane said, that he excludes all the possible suspects, that he met only once. Why the hell are McAllister and Smith on the list?
And if he met them again offscreen, it doesen't count. 
I can't acceppt Red John being someone, who should not even bee on this list. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on