Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Theory #2048 • By fan Mentalist
Show this theory

I think it is stiles because it is always very strange with patrick it is cold and nasty. He is my number one suspect

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think that Lorelei didnt know the real RJ, she thought that Kirkland was RJ because he is RJ's right hand and Kirkland her everytime, probably talkin like he were RJ. It's also posible that he did something similar with Jason. I dont think that the writers will give that obvious clues(the handshake thing and that scene at the hospital)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

We all don't know, who actually RJ is but I'm 100% sure that it IS NOT Jane.
Maybe with some special effects they can give Simon Baker(Jane) another role as Jane's twin and he can play a second role at the final chapter. Why a twin(because RedJonh is as clever as Jane)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2045 • By pootle
Show this theory

Still a few things I can't explain, but here's my theory. Patrick is Red John, but he doesn't know he is. Gradually over the next few series, Lisbon will start to work this out. The entire thing ending with Patrick himself coming to realise that he is indeed the man he has hunted all along. Patrick will have no choice but to kill himself in order to kill Red John. Lisbon will want to stop him, to save Patrick. Lisbon will fail, Partrick will commit suicide. Split personality basically. Like Jekyl and Hyde.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Here are a few theories on Robert Kirkland. I don't think that he is RJ, and I think that him getting a facelift is absurd. I hope that the writers wouldn't do that to us the viewers. But I do think that he is corrupt in some way. 

1. He is an accomplice of RJ. Probably very high up, but rarely seen because of his deep cover in Homeland Security. He may be RJs right hand man, even. He was seen by Jason Lennon once many years ago, and RK asked Jason if he could recognize him. Not because he has a "new face", but because he could have blown his cover and wants to be sure that no one else knows who he is. If Lennon had known who he was, RK would have had to kill the people he had told about RKs true identity. He kills him anyway because he is ordered to do so by RJ, so that Lennon can't tell Jane who Red John is.

or

2. Robert Kirkland is/was involved in the operation going on at the shelter and bought one of the women that were being sold. That would also explain him wanting to know if Lennon could ID him and thus know if he had told anyone about RKs corruption. RK then killed him so that he wouldn't tell PJ or anyone else about his involvement in the operation at the shelter.

or 

3. Both. RK is Red John's right hand man, but was never seen by Lennon until he bought one of the women from the shelter. Not knowing that Lennon worked for RJ at the time, he didn't use a disguise. So RK had to make sure that Lennon didn't recognize him so that he didn't tell anyone (especially RJ) about his involvement with the shelter. This would both cost him is job (and cover) in Homeland Security and probably his life from RJ for making mistakes.

Those are my theories on RKs involvement. Hope you like it!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2042 • By Vallyco
Show this theory

I subscribe to almost the theories in which Patrick Jane is accused of being Red John, and I would like to bring a new one, a new clou. Let's take a look at the sign of RJ, at the smiley face that is drawn after any crime he makes. The similarity between that smiley face and the real face of Patrick Jane is obviously. Just look at the scene on youtube, about the voice of Patrick being the same with RJ's. The scene in the car, when Patrick jane looks that face which I'm talking about.  I reffer to his eye, the right eye which is let down. Where come from this similarity and why?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I apologize for my English but I'm French.

And if Red John was a woman?Erica Flynn (Morena Baccarin) has all the features: brown hair,  age, she is a sociopath. Moreover, we see manipulative, getting everything she wanted, especially among men. For example, we see an episode that CBI Ron offered him tea with a knowing smile.

Finally, if lorelei was not afraid to measure red as red can be john john is not monstrous but physically fine.

Patrick  succumbed to her charme. last words exchanged between pj and erica are "we'll meet again soon."

A theory that surprised everyone but with a big problem. She has appeared very late in the series and starred in Homeland

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on