Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Sorry for my English, I'm from Venezuela.
This is not an accusation, but did someone remember the last episode of season 3?
There was 4 suspect on Laroche list and they make us think that one of them is the RJ accomplish, then the dispensable killer goes to the last floor with the intension of goin one floor down and kill Hightower. But there is a funny fact here, what is the dispensable killer was not going to go down just one floor down? What is all four suspect even including Laroche are connected with Red John and they all gave him the address so he could think send the dispensable killer to all floor looking for Hightower since he know all addresses or just sent the killer to Bertram floor so he could distract them for O'laughlin to kill Hightower and then sent Timothy carter to the mall where Jane met with Bertram since Bertram is also an accomplish of RJ he told him they will meet in that mall

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I guess Brett Patridge is Red John.
- Many people are saying that Red John must have appeared since Season 1 and that he has to be one of the "three main characters". Brett appears at the first episode.
- Also, many people say that Brett always appears to "mask" Red John cases.
- His voice is very similar to Red John's voice at 2x23. 
- PJ always says that Brett is a ghoul. I'm sure PJ hates Brett. Then they aren't friends. Lorelei said that PJ and RJ aren't friends.
- Brett, in fact, is really smart (he just pretend he isn't). They say that equal people hate each other and the opposite attract. PJ hates Brett because he is just like him. Lorelei also said that PJ and RJ are very similar. 
- At 5x15, Brett talks about the "human torch". Possibly, it's the same trick that RJ used at 3x09.
- And at last, RJ is a thin and agile person (see 2x23) then he can't be someone like Minelli that is a little overweight and old (no offense to the actor).

The question is if Brett has a connection with Visualize, it would be the last evidence. Well, people say that PJ and Brett shook hands "offscreen", but I'm not sure of that. If they didn't, Brett can't be RJ. Sorry about my english, it's not my native language =(

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2063 • By S92
Show this theory

I think Robert Kirkland is Lorelai father .. See his reaction in e5×08 when Lisbon look at a picture and ask Lorelai mother "is this your father ? "  she said " no , its my husband.He works in Munich " She could lying and Kirkland warn her to not tell anybody that he is her husband !!
So , he kill Lennon because he kill his daughter !

Sorry for my English :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i think RJ is him, bret stiles because of some reasons
1st. they have ever met before and shoke hand each other
2nd. they have same caracter on manipulating and lying.
3rd. stiles knows RJ so well, he knows what RJ plan (season 1)
4th. stiles has  very large connection (exmple he can help PJ to release lorelei and so many). RJ must have large connection
5th. RJ must have a relation with visualize as we known (from season 5)
6th. RJ dont want to kill PJ by some reason (such as RJ feels that they could be come friend), we know that stile also dont want to kill jane because of the same reasons...

it's my theory, but we still dont know...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #2062 • By joe_kickass
Show this theory

I'll preface this by saying I DON'T actually believe this will turn out to be the csae, but let me propose a scenario.
RJ killed Jane's family as outlines in the story, what happened then? What if at some point Jane discovered the identity of RJ and managed to exact his revenge. Now, without a family or a cause, he has regressed psychologically to a point before dealing with RJ. Everything since that point has been Jane's doing. He has been behind the larger "conspiracy" and the assistance of several acolytes allows for the presence of holes in logic presented by Jane's being the culprit.
Again, I don't think this will wind up being the case but it is technically feasible and would be an interesting twist while still allowing for Jane to play both the role of RJ as well as the damaged victim not entirely in control of his actions due to those of the "original" Red John.
Just a thought

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

We all know that Jane's goal is to find and kill RJ, that is a foregone conclusion. I pose this question though, what is RJ's purpose? If it was simply to kill random people or mess with Jane then there would be no reason for him to be associated with so many people when even one loose end could result in his identity being revealed and him being captured. I have a few theories on his purpose, because keep in mind he was killing people before Jane even mentioned his name on T.V. and his wife and daughter were murdered by him. 

1. He's like the Joker from Batman and just wants to see the world burn.

2. RJ is leading some sort of revolution. Its been hinted he was a member of visualize, and I believe he was Brett Stiles protege until the student surpassed the teacher and became dangerous to even Stiles himself. This leading to RJ needing a good number of followers to take down visualize and him having the techniques to do just that.

3. RJ ultimately wants power. He will do anything and everything to have control of as many different organizations as he can regardless of who he has to kill. Remember how he killed Bosco's team so Jane could be back on the case and the CBI just obliged and said OK. I didn't know that police organizations gave into criminal demands so easily.

4. In no way do I think Jane is involved in RJ's purpose or grand plan I just think that Jane got caught up in the middle of it with his comments and is one of the few people who intrigue RJ in terms of brilliance and so RJ toys with him. Don't kid yourself by saying Jane is smarter than RJ because time and time again he has been outsmarted and maneuvered. It's a game of cat and mouse RJ has enjoyed playing.

His purpose could be completely unrelated to any of what I just said and I could be completely wrong, however I feel as though it will be much easier to figure out who RJ is once his purpose or goals have been established. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Why isn't Robert Kirkland on this list? Lennon knows Red John yet claims to not recognize Robert Kirkland as Red John. The writers are clearly trying to throw people off of Robert Kirkland when the "ah ha" moment to come later is that Robert Kirkland has altered his appearances and is happy to confirm that he is unrecognizable to his followers. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on