Honestly, there are evidences growing everywhere that makes me throw teories, however this last fact, when in the begining of season 5 finale, when Brett said HI, after his coleague told him that would like to know/meet red john, god damn....
Honestly, there are evidences growing everywhere that makes me throw teories, however this last fact, when in the begining of season 5 finale, when Brett said HI, after his coleague told him that would like to know/meet red john, god damn....
Hello everyone , there is a very easy way to know who Red jhon is , but they just want to add more drama and suspense to the show , i m going to tell you how to identify Red JHon.
If you re watch The Mentalit episode 13 from season 5,than you should know that the priest know exactly the kid who draw that smiley face on the wall , so why Jane did not show the pictures of the seven suspects to that priest , he will definitely recognise him and he had no interest to lie or hide truths to Jane , that way Jane will be one step away , .
Red John is a showman and would have put on an act or facade when he first met Patrick and 'supposedly' shook his hand.......It's all about the performance for Red John...remember Tommy Volker's idiot performance in season 1....The same is with Ellis Mars....He pretended to be a psychic just like Patrick and made it look like he was being manipulated by Patrick for the entire episode, Now that is a performance................It would be a bit boring and predictable to cast Brett Partridge , Stiles or Kirkland as Red John, They have the potential to be Red John but most of the viewers want shock and awe in the series final episodes in the revealing of Red John's identity........After years of anticipation, wouldn't it be a letdown if Red John is an obvious choice like Stiles or Bertram.....If Red John is Kirkland, I would blame the writers of laziness and taking the easy way out........My favorites 2 candidates to put shock and awe to the viewers are Ellis Mars and Walter Mashburn.....yes...that Walter Mashburn.....plus there is also the clue 'He is Mar' which could be indicative of these 2
The most obvious choice for Red john is Brett Partridge....but that would not be a shock to many viewers and some may consider this a letdown after years of anticipation............We must remember that Red John is a showman and when he had first revealed himself to Patrick and shook his hand, he would have put on an act or a facade to hide his real self........If the writers want to give the viewers shock and awe on Red John's identity, then they should put Ellis Mars or Walter Mashburn as Red John.............Some may say that they cannot be Red John but if you just look back at their episodes, there are slight and subtle hints that they have the potential to be Red John......It will be boring and predictable to choose a person like Gale Bertram, Kirkland or Stiles as Red John....It will be somewhat unexpected if Mars or Marshburn is Red John....There is also the clue 'He is Ma', which could be indicative of these 2
I also agree with the last theory written, Kirkland & Stiles are not RJ, I also think Kirkland is after revenge on RJ like PJ is (& if by some ridiculous storyline Lorelei is still alive then I believe Kirkland maybe connected to Lorelei or her sister somehow.) I don't think PJ even knows she is still alive at this point to be fair thou.
Ok i have to say this......This whole Lisbon being rj accomplice is just rubbish, she loves him & she is the only thing in PJ life that he cares about, we all know he will spend the whole of the next series trying to keep her safe from RJ i'm sure to the point of madness. He didn't make the cd himself because he believes lisbon is working for RJ???? No No No . The CD came straight for the nut job who stole Eileens baby, it came from RJ himself, PJ doesn't even have a smart phone or use a computer and now suddenly he is steven spielberg & he is making & editing his own Videos with RJ girl to try fool the 1 & only person he cares for????? RJ made the CD, when/how are a differ matter?!
I don't think the list is fake as I think IF Bruno heller lied at this point it would upset all of the fans and that's not what his aim is. I believe most or at least some of the suspects are linked to RJ somehow or another. Some we all ready know about kind of such as Stiles.
If i had to guess... HAFFNER... SHERIFF MCALLISTER... PARTRIDGE... are the main 3 who could be RJ in my eyes.
(but partridge will really really have to act his heart out to convince me on any sort of level that he is just like Jane & really a charming, charamistic psycho killer who can manipulate most people, be a womanizer & has god knows how many followers in the palm of his hand.. Yes partridge def could be a killer this i don't doubt, but is he RJ???. He has been there from the start of the show but at the same time that seems a little too obvious in my book for this show.)
hmmmmmmm... so many doubts... but i'm sticking with them 3 for now.
Caveat: since this is a TV show, assembling an accurate profile on Red John is ridiculously difficult, if at all possible. The information with which the audience has been provided could easily describe several killers. However, for the sake of simplicity, let us assume that Red John's MO is still evolving.
Available data overview:
1) Technical
worker traits: electrician, carpenter, mechanic, plumber
- Strong
hands
- “Neither
muscular nor soft,” thus uses stun gun to subdue victims, also binding them with tight,
black plastic ligatures
- Uses
linoleum cutter – very specific tool, likely something from personal environment,
chosen due to availability and/or desirability
- Alias
“Roy Tagliaferro,” which translates to “cut iron” and could relate to an industry with which Red John is familiar
- Uses
rubber gloves to paint signature smiley face
- Carries
kill-kit with him, because the items used for murder have not been mentioned to have been present at the crime scene at the time of murder or afterwards; however, Red John seems to easily hide in plain sight, which would indicate he wears a uniform or disguise that justifies the items in his possession – it is not unusual for a repairman to carry duct tape or wire, etc.
- Attacks
low-risk targets – nearly all women, late at night, in their homes
2) Fiercely
intelligent, highly educated
- Alias
“Dr. Joe N. H.”
- Cites
William Blake’s “The Tyger,” which portrays the tiger as the embodiment of a
creator’s power, an animal of terrifying beauty, strength, and complexity
- “Showman
and artist”
- “Has
a strong sense of theatre” – signature smiley face more of an emotional release than the victim, wants the face to inspire dread and fear, ensures it is seen first
- Exhibits
psychopathic tendencies – uses a mixture of charm, manipulation, intimidation,
and violence to control others, in order to satisfy own selfish needs
- Narcissistic,
hates being belittled in public
3) Extremely
well-connected
- Has contacts
in the FBI
- Can
infiltrate CBI network, which indicates Red John is either a very capable hacker or has access to one
- Has
dedicated followers, “disciples”
- Bruno
Heller compares to Moriarty
4) Constantly
changing MO
- Reoccurring
frenzied stabbing and cutting of torso
- Rape
- Heat
suffocation
- Painting
toenails in blood
- Poisoning
- Shooting
- Kidnapping
With this data in mind, my money is on Ray Haffner.
Although all seven remaining candidates do not truly fit the profile, I would reject Partridge, because Red John is extremely sensitive to mockery and Jane has repeatedly ridiculed Brett in front of others. Stiles and McAllister seem likely, but their age would have been noted by Rosalind Harker. Kirkland appears too desperate to obtain Jane's research and does not fit the timeline of Lorelei's video. Smith could become Red John if the writers wish him to; there is virtually no background information concerning his character.
Bertram lusts for power and domination, and quotes William Blake in 3x16, but since Red John has been likened to Jane on numerous occasions, Haffner seems like the more reasonable choice.
Ultimately, all of the remaining suspects appear to be sloppy choices without proper justification. Their interactions with Jane have to be clearly explained or their alternate Red John will seem forced. Unless Jane is actually still in the mental hospital, trapped in a hallucination or some such.
No one on the list is red john. Bertram and haffner both work for RJ. Kirkland is trying to kill RJ bc of a wrong he committed against a woman is kirkland's life. Kirkland is being played by bertram. Smith, partridge, stiles, and the sheriff are all excluded for several reasons including their jobs, appearance, etc. My theory is jane gave his list to lorelei knowing that red john would pry information from her and kill her. Lorelei agreed to help jane bc she now knows rj killed her sister and that if she cant kill rj, patrick will. Jane has a fee more names cleverly left off the list and will use the info he and rj both have to understand how rj gets his information. He does not yet fully trust lisbon. Van pelt's father is in some way connected and so is van pelt. I believe we will find out that rj played football for van pelts dad and that he then went to play at alabama. I believe some huge keys are the locket she keeps. The food court scene that no one knows about. The question do you recognize me that kirkland asks.