Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister Reede Smith
Reede Smith Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

I think max winter is red John.

Lorali stated that PJ and RJ are alike

Max winter is way too alike to PJ, he sits, acts, talks like PJ and he even wears a wedding ring but he's wife is dead like PJ
When we see red John with rosalind Parker we see how RJ sits, holding his cup of tea, like PJ and like Max Winter when PJ and he met for the first time.
Mac winter also gives PJ the gun that kills Timothy carter like he was planning to get Timothy carter killed so he wouldn't tell anyone about who red John is.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Jane is smarter than the seven on the list . and in redjohn rules when rj kill the happy memory of jane nobody on the list is smart enough to that .and in redmoon s3  e9 todd johnoson  was helping in the case and he was the serial killer and he refused to talk to anyone else and he want to talk to jane because he told lisbon that they have connection and i think the connection is that both are serial killers helping in their cases just to distract the cops . and jane maybe have Schizophrenia so he could have two personlties one is rj and the other is someone whose want to catch rj and kill him .

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I huv reasons to say RJ and PJ is one person although Bruno Heller always 
 says isn't he ?1-I think Jane after death of his wife and daughter developed some sort of mental disease what we called shizophrenia. Huv two separate personalities kind one and violent one2-he hallucinated about his dead daughter its auditory hallucinations its positive symptomplus visual hallucinations 3-  the episode when agent darsi said to him an important question if ur an enemy of red john why he didnt kill you4-when agent darsi re opend old case panzer murder no body knows that except Wainwright so how red John know and send someone to follow her

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just found this site and I'm glad to see that Brett is everyone else's top suspect. He's the only recurring Character I have seen who truly matches the build and voice of Red John. Btw I didn't see the final four episodes of season 5 yet but I read on here that he narrows the list to 7 suspects. I've suspected Brett for a long time because Red John is a small, slender white guy with a nerdy voice just like Brett. Let's not also forget that he appeared in the very first episode which would make it fit perfectly. And as Jane said in the first episode "He urks me... He's urksome."

I do like this show but I will admit the writing is pretty annoying. They don't seem to like to give viewers hardly anything substantial about Red John so I wouldn't be surprised AT ALL if his list of 7 turned out to be nothing and that Lorelei was just lying all along.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

After Bertram finally beats Judge Manchester at poker, he says to Lisbon "I gutted him", which is how RJ kills his victims. Could be nothing, but could be a playful clue from the writers.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Facts from Bruno Heller:

1. Patrick Jane is not Red John

2. "We can trust that list" (list of suspects from Season 5 finale)


Facts we know from Lorelei

1. PJ shook his hand

2. He is a man (As he had a sexual relationship with Lorelei)


Facts from Rosalind:

1. Red John is about 6 feet tall ( which means that Gale Bertram is discluded)

2. Red John has straight short hair (not the case for Sherif Thomas Mcallisar)


Discluding the other suspects:

1. Bret Stiles: a litte smaller than the average and Too old for a sexual relation with Lorelei and Rosalind

2. Ray Haffner: Would be too obvious as he is only appearing for being a suspect

3. Bob Kirkland: WAAAAAAAAAY too obvious. And when he killled at the Hospital there was no Smiley.

4. Reede Smith: Too fat which Rosalind would have mentioned.


Do you remember season 1 Episode 1? Brett Partridge seems to be Close to an orgasm when describing how " red John " killed the victims. On top of that in the season 2 finale, Jane Comes back into the room and Kind of Shocks Partridge a Little bit which Red John does to Jane for revenge after the Tigre Poem.
The voice is very Close to Partridge as we can hear at the end of seasons 2 and 4. On top of that the voice sounds nothing like an older man ( Mcallisar, Haffner, Stiles, Bertram). You could argue that the voice is tricked through the mask and the mobile phone, but the Little Girl in season 4 tells Jane that RJ has a weird voice. Therefore it fits.

In conclusion: 4 suspects can be discluded 100% 2 others are unlikely. Brett Partrige would perfectly fit the role of Red John mainly due to his behaviour in Season 1, Episode 1.
I think that at the end Jane wont but Lisbon will shoot Red John rightfully.







Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on