I'm just going to share some thoughts with you, and i warn you straight forward - this post might change the way you look at the whole Red John issue.
Let's start at the very beginning.
In season one we were already given a lot of information about Red John. Bruno Heller is, no doubt, a genius in storywriting and planned everything the way it's going to make sense to us rewatching all the past seasons after Red John is revealed. But nobody seems ever to care about the fact that even Bruno couldn't know how many seasons that would be granted to 'The Metalist' - so he must have kept to possibility to reveal his identity at the any of any season. In simple terms - with every new season there have been more red herrings and misleads. I believe it's not necessary to analize all seasons but the first and the second. We are now down to seven names, and can exclude a whole punch looking at the physical data given. So with the few names left, lay down on your comfortable bed or sofa and rewatch the first two seasons. I believe that there's enough information.
All based on the assumption that the seven names are correct, but I believe Bruno wouldn't lie about that, would he?