Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

http://www.fanpop.com/clubs/the-mentalist/images/35576736/title/mentalist-season-6-first-look-rigsbys-van-pelts-wedding-photo?card



Well, it looks like they are getting married

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I noticed one very interesting thing from the list of 7.I dont know if its really important but its worth to mention it.From the 7 suspects of the list there is only one of them whom his appearance on the show isnt connected at all to the Red John case.And this man is Sherrif Thomas McCallister.In his appearance in s01e02 we have zero mention to Red John and it seems one episode with another killing that PJ and the team will solve in a smart way.Think of it.
1)Brett Partridge:All his appearances except one were in episodes referring to Red John.
2)Bret Stiles:Helps PJ to get Lorelei out of prison and also in another episode talks to PJ about RJ and how RJ takes all the things from PJ's life.
3)Gale Bertram:He is also connected to the Red John case in s03e24 where we thought at the beggining that he was RJ's accomplice before we find out that O'Laughlin is RJ's accomplice.
4)Reede Smith:His only appearance is in s05e01 where he and Mancini at the beggining have an argument with Lisbon and her team about the Red John case.Also take a look at his face when Rigsby says "We were this close on catching Red John...etc".
5)Bob Kirkland:Well what can i say about BK.He killed Jason Lennon.He is the chief in finding Lorellei when she escaped from prison,he break into the room of PJ.All his appearances are connected to the Red John case.
6)Raymond Haffner:S04e01.He and his team replace Lisbon's team cause of their suspection in killing Timothy Carter(fake RJ).And of course s05e13.The episode that we learn that RJ started to kill in the late 80's and was a member os Visualise as Haffner too.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I am impressed by the many compelling ideas supporting each suspect as RJ.  That notwithstanding, I really hope some of the suspects turn out to be good guys -- or at least normal human beings (good intentions, serious flaws but also some positive characteristics).

In particular, just how many psychopathic serial killers -- and devoted followers of a psychopathic serial killer -- can there be in law enforcement in one area?!  RJ is striking because psychopathic serial killers are rare.  It is quite a stretch to assume that even criminals would be willing to accompany RJ down such a heinous path, much less be willing to die for RJ.

Also, while the conspiracy theories are fun, it strikes me as weak if the plot depends on widespread evil, with the lone exception of Lisbon's virtuous, heroic team.  Ordinary failings often are quite enough to explain dishonorable or questionable behavior.  For instance, Bertram was perfectly willing to write Jane off after he killed Timothy Carter.  This is perfectly in keeping with an excessively ambitious bureaucrat/politician whose commitment to his subordinates ends when they cease to further his career.  (BTW, try as I might, I can't reconcile the plaque for bravery in Bertram's office with a RJ personality, regardless of the other clues suggesting Bertram might be RJ.  Bravery -- especially the aspect of risking self for another -- seems incompatible with the absolute self-referential nature of RJ.  RJ appears to place zero value on any person or belief system except his own.)  Kirkland's murder of Jason Lennon isn't far from the ruthless values and actions sometimes required of spies.  If Lennon were a covert agent "turned" by RJ (as Kirkland said, Lennon allowed himself to become the "plaything of monsters"), Kirkland might have killed Lennon to protect some larger investigation.  Anyhow, it's too precious for all virtue to reside in Lisbon's team with evil widespread among other law-enforcement teams and agencies.

Just a thought.  Thanks for reading this.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Some guy just linked this and I just want to ask, does this mean that the list is fake? And by that I mean (brett stiles, gail bertram, ray haffner,reede smith, bob kirkland, mcallister and brett partdrige). Or is this about some other fake list?

http://www.spoilertv.com/2013/10/the-mentalist-episode-604-red-listed.html

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Listen closely to red john's voice when he answers Lisbon's cell phone and imagine Wayne Rigsby is talking. It's him. Also from a story telling standpoint, it's got to be someone on Lisbon's team for it to be A) shocking and B) good storytelling. Don't look outside of our main characters. And with the announcement that the actors playing Rigsby and Van Pelt leaving the show half way through the season and that Red John will be revealed before 2013 is over. Rigsby is Red John and he will kill Van Pelt before 2013 is over.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Some shithead just posted this and I was dumb enough to click on it because I didn't think it was that big of a spoiler. But I guess the secret will be out in just a matter of time so I might just post it myself.
Do not click on this link unless you want your next 16 days to be like hell.

http://www.spoilertv.com/2013/10/the-mentalist-episode-604-red-listed.html

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #5019 • By AtygerTale
Show this theory

Look at Bertram and Look at McCallister in their pictures from the suspect list.

Does anyone else think they look very similar? Maybe im reading tooooo far but has there ever been a scene where both of them are together?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on