Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Since the beginning I always believed that BP was RJ, and I'm sure you're all familiar with all of the clues that lead to him.

What we all need to realize, is that The Mentalist is NEVER obvious. When I found that BP was on PJ's list, I started doubting myself. Why would Bruno Heller PLACE the answer in our hands? Why would he take away every element of surprise? Though, when BP was 'killed', my faith in my theory was restored. How else would you surprise the audience? Make the 'dead' guy the killer all along. We won't see him for the rest of the series, and at the last episode we will find that he's RJ.

Let's say I'm wrong. If I do happen to be wrong, (which doesn't happen often), I can assure you that it will NOT be one of the other 6 on the list. There would be no element of surprise, no shock, nothing. If it's not Brett Partidge, it will have to be one of the main characters. That is Lisbon. Rigsby, Van Pelt, or Cho. I think it would be really shocking and thrilling if it was one of the main characters, and it would make for good television. If anyone is Red John out of all of the prinicipal characters, I think it would be Cho.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I DON'T THINK it's PARTRIDGE.  I think he's dead.  But this website won't let me pick the one I really accuse.  
Anyway, could Jane's FAKE list of 7 suspects hold symbolism for the 7 deadly sins?  I think that points to these characters all having a weakness that will lead to their undoing, and the proving that they're not RJ. 

 
1.  Sheriff McAllister:  SLOTH.  He's a REAL DONUT SHOP COP.  About 20 steps behind everyone, including himself.

2.  Ray Haffner:  GREED.  Money talks but RH is seriously motivated by money as his main interest and goal.

3.  Gale Bertram:  GLUTTONY.  At first, I thought him GREED -- because of GB's poker habit but I realize he has more the desire to win than to just have money.  Another definition is "the ability to withstand," as in glutton for punishment, which GB certainly is, and also an excessive "love of power," or at least for GB, a love of looking good.

4.  Reede Smith:  I thought Gluttony because of his obvious physical appearance but his true point of his nature is: WRATH.  The guy has serious anger management issues.

5.  Brett Partridge: LUST: or blood lust [ghoul!!]

6.  Bob Kirkland: ENVY: he truly seems in direct competition with Jane and the CBI, but why?  We don't know yet.

7.  Brett Stiles: PRIDE:  the biggest ego of all -- I think he could have a connection to RJ, but isn't actually him.  [Perhaps a father or father figure maybe]

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

yO DAWG LIKE MANZ SHOULD NOE BY NOW WHO DA RED JOHN GUY IZ DOE. LIKE YO OBVI ITS THE GUY WHO LOOKS LIKE THAT, WHO DOES THAT THING, THAT YOU KNOW, PROVES THAT THING WHICH MEANS HES KINDA RED JOHN BUT HEY IDK.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hey guys... I have been thinking about who red john is for awhile now and i must say that i cannot tell for sure whi rj is but i came up with a theory and a possibility... First lets remove some suspects

Bret partrige - i think the dead wasnt fake, although he would make a great red john...
Sherif- he is just not the guy, he isnt the right age, height and the fact that he hasnt been shownin many episodes...
Reede smith - despite the fact that his name is an analog of the red is me Jane met him after the conversation about the handshake so that made me think, why would jane even put him on the list.. that makes me think that the list could be fake...
Gale bertram - i think he cant be rj, he acts wird when he says in 6s1e i hear you are getting closer, maby he is connected to him, but he isnt rj.

Now lets get to sirious facts and my theory..

Bob kirkland - i think that he is rj's brother.. i think that he is rj's right hand he asks the guy if he recodnises him simply because bob and the guy have seen before but bob have made a little transformation idk like he let his hair grew or smtning like that, he also thinks that jane doesnt know about stealing he information and i think jane planted the list. Ok lets move on

Brett styles - i think he is rj's father he knows very much about him, but he is on neither side, he just wants a good show either jane cathes red john or not.

So we are down to ray haffner - if the list is right i think he is the only one who could be red john. He is right age and right height.. in my oppinion people who are on the list will start dyingone by one and when cbi will think they finaly have red john even the last suspec on the list will die.. i think jane has another list, that has 1 more name on it and that one is red john, and that name exists just in janes head, he didnt tell it to noone because he knows that they would do something about that person if he told him.

Soo sure there are some questions abiut the happy memory and why would rj even kill his family...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #5079 • By Kozzab
Show this theory

I reckon it's Jayne. I think Jayne has a mental disorder and is actually Red John. It would explain the fact that Red John is apparently 10 steps ahead of them all the time, and it would explain why Red John seems to know what Jayne is thinking about before Jayne does.
Jayne is a very talented Hypnotherapist, he could hypnotise people that know his as Red John into thinking he isn't Red John.

Seriously I think Jayne IS Red John!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #5075 • By Cakes
Show this theory

I think McAllister is Red John and Reede Smith is his friend in the FBI.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

guys, if u think list is legit, there is one thing. they say guys on fake list are in danger. RJ killed patridge and he was on the list we know. So that means list of seven is fake

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on