Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

This is about Bret Stiles, but I'm actually not accusing him, I'm exonerating him. And what I'm about to say may sound farcical, but I'm serious. This is my first time submitting a theory here, and I hope this does not go against me as a theorist for not being substantial. But... 

Bret Styles cannot be Red John, because the visualize symbol is a variation on the CBS logo -- Network that airs The Mentalist. I'm quite serious about this. Although I don't want to stretch my theory too thin and speculate about the significance of the similar designs, I think the similarity is intentional, not coincidental. 

Before I submit another theory or theories accusing other people, I want to say that Bret Stiles is the most fitting suspect for several reasons that have already been mentioned by others in this forum, and the fact that he is the most fitting subject DOES NOT make him a red herring. But I still don't think it is him. 

I do, however, think visualize has some involvement or influence in the turns of events concerning RJ, because, for instance, Stiles has too much knowledge about things Red John, he's too powerful, and there are too many connections like the murders committed in the basement of that house years before RJ's murders became public. For that matter, Haffner, a member of Visualize is dirty, for certain -- but not necessarily RJ or one of his disciples. 

The list of 7 could very well involve people who are all in this together somehow, including RJ whom I believe is an individual, not a team. We know that Bertram and Kirkland have had private conversations regarding Jane and Red John; we also know of the trio in Bertram's office in episode 6.2. I think there is another trio that will be revealed very shortly: Stiles, Haffner, and Partridge. We will learn about the connections in the fourth episode this season. Note, that this consideration on groupings involves all 7 in one way or another, although the trio I suggest has yet to be materialized.

Some of the people on this list are blood relatives, or else one of them has a brother who has been affected by the RJ killings. I say this because there is a sibling issue with RJ's MO. On more than one occasion we know of a girl or woman whom he killed or had killed whose sister was spared. The basis for my suggesting there is an important  fraternal relationship in the Red John ring is based on this motif and on another relevant motif "Tyger Tyger." 

There are also two Brets -- but not really. One is a Bret the other is Brett. Brett Partridge is one of the Tygers; Brett Styles is not -- IMO. But if we wanted to get involved in anagrams and alliteration and what not, there's lots to play with with the T's in these names. Then again, these sound games are insubstantial -- maybe... maybe not. Show titles often indicate significant, clueful plays on words, and most of RJ's alias's are plays on the pseudonym "Red John." so it's not out of the question for Heller and other writers to use these devices. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It's gotta be Bertram. He quotes William Blake in season 3. Also, in the season finale of season 3 when he and Jane are waiting to "meet" Hightower he is not nervous (as Jane points out) and he seems quite content, like he knows exactly what is going on. Also, his position would explain how he always knows so much about what Jane is up to. Not to mention that he says in the latest episode "when you catch RJ, I'll be there". It's like he is taunting Jane. There is still the question of who else is involved and I don't have any answers regarding the conversation between the three suspects in Bertrams office.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just a note, when watching the ending scene of S6 Ep. 1 - After Partridge is dead, we see the face being detailed onto Lisbon's face right?

Anybody notice how the eyes of the face are vertical down her eyes? - This isnt the usual style. 

Personally, no idea if this is done by a fake, the reason i put Brett as the suspect is just to create this note. But, what I will say is this - If the face drawn onto Lisbon was drawn intentionally different to usual, why. If not - Was it an RJ fan or accomplice making a mistake?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think that most of your opinions are wrong. The list has to be wrong otherwise Jane would not smile when he saw that somebody broke into his room. ( kirklands guys )
we all know that scene with a toothpick when jane smiles when he sees that its broken. So that could only mean that he planned this to happen which means that he planted false list to fool red john. I doubt he would reveal his real suspects to red john so i think he kept it for himself and he has some kind of trick that he is going to pull later on in the series. So if the list is fake and no one from that list is red john that means that kirkland is only red johns helper. And if other guys from the list arent red john i would suspect mashburn because he is the smartest guy in the show aside the guys on the list.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Regarding the bird phobia RJ may have which stopped him from killing Lisbon, I would be pretty disappointed if that were the case. With the mental capabilities exhibited by RJ I personally would be shocked if he has a major phobia of a nature that would impede his ability to carry out whatever his plans may be (including killing Teresa). Here we have this ultimate badass with superior mental abilities and he is incapable of overcoming a phobia that would affect everything he does? (birds are everywhere).

I know they hinted at the possibility but I believe not killing Teresa was part of the plan and the birds are just a red herring.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Isnt this a bit weird?

http://www.spoilertv.co.uk/images/cache/the-mentalist/Season%206/Promotional%20Episode%20Photos/Episode%206.04%20-%20Red%20Listed/The%20Mentalist%20-%20Episode%206.04%20-%20Red%20Listed%20-%20Promotional%20Photos%20%284%29_FULL.jpg

And has he ever been seen in a tie other than a red one?
Watch the episodes he has appeared in and you will see every time he goes to say Lorelai's name , he stutters.

I think bruno heller has tried to throw us off him , and i think lorelai is still alive , but time will tell !

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Season 02, Ep. 13
In thw panting that Mashburn gave Liselle as a gift there is  tyger in the center of the image. If anyone knows which is the name of the painting, please tell me! Thanks 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on