Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Some people think that when Heller said "You can trust the list" that it meant RJ is on the list.

I think it meant you can trust the people on the list. None of them are RJ.

I still think that Jane is in the process of setting RJ up.

I believe that several of the people on the list suspect that Jane is RJ-hence the meeting in Bertram's office where
Reede tells Bertram it's his job to know what Jane is up to.

I believe that Partridge is indeed alive and that he is a wannabe RJ trying to insert himself in the action.That woman on the bench feeding the pigeons sure looked like Partridge.

Jane repeatedly relies on creating a diversion in order to solve his crimes. 

The identity of Red John is revealed in episode 7, yet I think it won't be the real Red John.

Partiridge is a copy cat. Tyger,Tyger.

Copy that?


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

as we all know the first crime that red john did was in 1998
thats 20 years ago
witch means that red john is very old
no .. there is 2 red john's .. yep
the first is bret stiles .. i dont know why but i just have this filling that he is
the second is the " now " red john and i think he is bret 's son 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Brett partridge wasn't red john .. he was his assistant
in s6xe1 when lesbon find out brett's body in the locker .. he said " tyger tyger "
and as i remember that poem is exclusive to red john and his " society "
so brett did something wrong maybe and red john killed him

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

IMPORTANT!! Chapter 2x2 Look observe the name of the psychiatrist who works for the CBI serving Lisbon after the incident in the old cottage that kills jane official!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Probably red john is not mr.roth who was sophie miller's passion
but i still think red john is brett partridge or ray haffner
they are the only suspects that i feel they can kill and do what red john does 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm not accusing anyone of being red john. I'm just going to eliminate suspects that simply can't be him.



First the list most likely totally bogus, but still let's study the suspects anyway: 

Haffner, Bertram and McAllister have all been outsmarted by Patrick, so I doubt any of them can be RJ.

Plus Bertram and O'laughlin each had been given a different room number in Strawberries and Cream. Wouldn't RJ have suspected something and not sent his killer? Same goes for Osvaldo Ardiles, Brenda Shettrick, Hightower and LaRoche.

Kirkland. Think about it, when Lorelei told Patrick that he and RJ shook hands he hadn't even met Kirkland. Also when Kirkland killed Jason Lennon, Lennon didn't recognize him. He would have if he was RJ and even if he didn't recognize him I just don't see a reason to kill him. 

Partridge is dead.

Smith would've been 12 in 1988 so I don't see how he could've killed and tortured two people and Stiles was 45 and too old to have been the 'kid' seen painting the face.

Also I doubt anyone from the list is related to one another especially not the two Brets. And if someone simply has red hair it does not incriminate him. 

Red John is not Jane and its not a group of people that would be impossible I'm not even going to go into this. 




It can't be Cho, Rigsby, Van Pelt, or Lisbon because in Crimson Hat they were all together during Patrick's conversation with RJ and surrounded by the FBI it would've been impossible for them to communicate with Patrick without anyone noticing. Same goes for Darcy.

I'm starting to feel that Cbi Ron is a red herring. Too much attention is being drawn to him.
I think the way the show works is the murderer is most often the person no one would suspect because they were never treated as a suspect. They were always just there. And the show has been shoving him in our faces lately. There's no concrete proof as why it can't be him. It would certainly be interesting. 



Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on