Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Hi guys, first of all I apologize to all fans who are sick of all the Partridge theories. I understand how this can be annoying to someone who is very sure that he is dead.

However please listen to me. You can't deny that it would be very silly if Red John turned out to be someone who has only appeared from season 4 or 5. How can it be Haffner?? What if the show was cancelled after season 3? Would Bruno Heller just introduce a complete stranger to us as Red John in the last episode?? I don't think so..You have to agree that this is weird.

You must admit that Red John has to be someone from seasons 1, 2, maybe 3. (so: sheriff, Stiles, Partridge or maybe Bertram)

And if this is not the case and RJ is Haffner, then Bruno Heller has changed his original idea. In this case, I'm a 100% sure that originally Red John was supposed to be Partridge. 

I'm not saying that its going to be him in the end, I'm just saying that it will be very disappointing if it's any one of the suspects from season 4 or 5, maybe even 3. (Bertram). Nobody even knew at the start of the show that these actors will be in it. So why does Bruno Heller say that he knew exactly what's going to happen from the beginning of the show? Surely this means Red John is somebody from the early seasons? What do you think?                                    




Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #6320 • By R_Tagliaferro_
Show this theory

Red John has imperceptibly manipulated things in order to make Patrick Jane come up with that specific list of suspects. That'a how Red John knew about the list before he killed Lorelei. But what Red John does not know is that Patrick Jane has seen through it and only pretends to have fallen into the trap. And this is how we can be sure that the list is not the real one.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok, so we know about the satanic and biblical connotations throughout The Mentalist. If you don't here is a brief summary.

As shown when Lisbon responds to the emergency call in 6-01, there are many satanic messages on the walls including  666 and die, along with other satanic drawings. Heller told us there was a big clue in this season, there you have it.

Episode 7 of the series is "The Great Red Dragon", a 7 (yes in episode 7, coincidence?) headed dragon which is a depiction of the devil in the book of revelations. This Dragon was also the subject of 4 paintings by William Blake. Yes, the same "Tyger, Tyger" Blake. The 7 headed-dragon is a reflection of the list of 7. One of the dragon's heads is said to be fatally wounded, "but the fatal wound had healed". This is Brett Partridge. Now I believe Partridge isn't dead due to two things. First is the fact that this wound had been healed. The second is the "Brace of Partridge", another painting by Blake, which depicts two dead Pigeons. However the word "Brace" means two. The word brace could mean a second coming, lending itself to the possibility that Partridge isn't dead.An alternative theory could be Red John was aiming to kill Lisbon and have her as the second pigeon. This theory makes out like Red John is killing off his fear (Pigeons) symbolically, however i cannot understand why his "fears" are Partridge and Lisbon.

Speaking of pigeons, it is now quite widely believed that Red John is Ornithophobic, which is the fear of pigeons. Someone put this together due to the extended shots of pigeons in season 6. Also, McAllister jumped at pigeons in the tower at the end of 6-03 However this is backed up by William Blake's "The Brace of Partridge" depicting dead pigeons. So we also know that he is not afraid of heights, so don't get caught up in that yarn any longer and look out for those pigeons!!

Now, the subject of my real enquiry is the paintings "The Great Red Dragon and the Woman Clothed in Sun" and also "The Great Red Dragon and the Woman Clothed with the Sun". If it is believed that Heller and the writing team are sticking with the same analogy, it comes to reason that a heavily featured part of Blake's dragon paintings, the woman clothed in sun, is featured. So we know who the dragon represents, Red John, but who is the woman clothed in sun? Well the obvious answer is Teresa Lisbon, however I believe it is Grace Van Pelt. Van Pelt's red hair is the reason why. The "sun" has been translated by Heller as Grace's long red hair.

Now, we know that Van Pelt and Rigsby leave the CBI this season. I feel that Van Pelt has been RJ's mole in the CBI, hence being "in sun". now as she leaves she is not in the sun any more. This, i believe, is a metaphor for her transition out of the CBI, and to RJ seeing she has outlived her usefulness. But i don't think it will be RJ that kills her, I think it will be Rigsby. RJ will let Rigsby find out that she is/was the mole. This is all speculation of course.

There is another painting by Blake called  "The Red Dragon and The Beast From the Sea". The beast from the sea is the CBI/Patrick Jane's allies in my opinion. But lets see a little more down the road. Sorry if this looks like a ramble put on a computer, that's because it is. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

haffner is red john he would be a great red john.

kirkland is so dead this episode....

does anybody knows if this would be the last season and how much episodes will have? thanks from Peru!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #6315 • By fhg
Show this theory

She new to the team at beginning of series.  RJ seems to always have insider info.
Had a relationship with RJ mole.  She has shown the ability to kill in without remorse.
Everyone refers to RJ as a male only because of the name John not because he/she is a male.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

A lot of people have said that Kirkland will torture PJ and I will cut his fingers but look closely at his shirt... Patrick Jane seems to wear a "one color" shirt under his suit unlike the man on the last scene, who wear a checked shirt.
We can also see Kirkland's shirt on the preview, and I see some check on his shirt (but i'm not sure...) : rather than PJ tortured by Kirkland, It could be Kirkland who will be tortured by Red John in this episode.


NB: Sorry for the mistakes, i'm not and English Native speaker

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #6313 • By Curious11
Show this theory

Finally a conclusive theory about Kirkland-
He is RJ's right hand and has to proof his loyality to him.
Thats the reason he hunted down Lorelai after her escape and
and why he killed Lennon.
Now he has to keep RJ updated on Patricks List and stole it.
RJ knows already the real list because of his surveillance
techniques. Kirkland becoming aware that his list is a fake has to geht
The real One to proof his abilities to protect and support RJ
So he tries to torture PJ....
I think PJ knows RJ since episode 3 and was working on his Elaborate
Trap to get him fixed.
We will see....
By the Way- Am I the only one totally annoyed by the 1578980. th
recitation of that useless poem?!?!?
Nobody is able to remember Shakespeare and by now i cant get this stupid Poem Out of my head....

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on