Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

From wiki:
"Reed" is commonly believed to be a nickname-derived surname referring to a person's complexion or hair being ruddy or red.

Etymology and history
Although the name is derived from a common occupation, many later Smiths had no connection to that occupation, but adopted or were given the surname precisely because of its commonness. For example:It is common for people in English-speaking countries to adopt the surname Smith in order to maintain a secret identity, when they wish to avoid being found. Smith is an extremely common name among English Gypsies; see also John Smith

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #6688 • By DontBadmouthBruno
Show this theory

Be warned, this is as much a spoiler as it is a theory. 

Bruno Heller is not a moron. Here is why Patrick didn't take the recording of the list's voices to Rosalynd Harker. When he was showing the video of Lorelei reading the list to Lisbon, he got a case from Bertram on the SAME DAY. On the SAME DAY, Patrick finds out who Redjohn is. Conjecture? No. Am I going to type an explanation either? No. 

I've seen this theory link posted like 200 times. Sorry to pee anyone off but here is the full spoiler.

http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/6373

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

For a long time people have placed enormous significance in the Blake poem The Tyger recited by Red John to Jane. We all (including myself) have looked for a million ways to connect the dots between William Blake and Red John and use this as some clue to his identity.

Perhaps it is not this at all. Perhaps when RJ recited the poem to Jane it was not to leave a calling card, but rather to give him a clue to the conspiracies going on within the law enforcement agencies. RJ may have nothing to do with this corruption, but he is aware of it and wants to alert Jane to this (cryptically, of course) as a warning to him to be careful who he trusts. RJ wants to keep Jane alive (obviously, saving his life here) and is absolutely in love with the game of cat and mouse. It is his raison d'etre for the last decade. So he must protect Jane so they can continue this brilliant mind battle. I don't even think RJ cares if Jane ultimately wins. I think he will take pride in being defeated, if he is. But he absolutely must continue this battle with Jane, and wants to preserve Jane's healthy existence.

So, perhaps the Tyger poem was a warning to Jane, and there is not in fact a relationship between the corruption and RJ. Why, for example, would they have a password which is from a Blake poem and is also something that RJ likes to recite? This just sounds odd. Foolish almost, like a bunch of kids in a treehouse thinking they are cool. It doesn't really fit the personality of RJ to my thinking.

So, I am starting to really think that RJ is outside this group, and his poem to Jane was a warning, not a ritual of his, or some game he was playing to see if Jane could figure out who he was.

So, who would this theory tend to support as being RJ? Somebody who could have knowledge of the corruption, but not be an insider to any great extent. That tells me Haffner or Stiles. Stiles seems to be the obvious choice for RJ if we never had the physical descriptions from Harker and Miller. But we must take this evidence into account, I suppose, and that leads to Haffner. The master surveillance man, with a wealthy business venture and enough ties to all the nefarious organizations to be able to have knowledge of this sort, and also be a manipulator of those within them.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I don't like this, RJ cannot be group of these clowns. Jane would found out about their Mickey Mouse club in a few days.
 RJ was presented like professor Moriarty.
Evil, manipulative genius with lot of connections and money.

Like I said before,he should be mix of Jane, Mashburn and Stiles.
I hope Heller will come up with some reasonable explanations for this funny club.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i am so disappointed by the last episode. it just makes no sense.
why did kirkland kill lennon without asking him who red john was? instead he goes around and kills people who might be red john. he could have asked lennon. what kind of bullshit is that? I am really disappointed and thought heller and his writer team would make the wrap up in a logic way. but sorry, the kirkland storyline is lame and just doesnt make sense at all.
I really hope heller and his team will come up with something smart and logic when reavealing the rj story, cause with what they came up now was a bit lame.
Tiger, tiger is a code for an organization. come on?!!! Lame, disappointing. After all those episodes and throwing around clues and fans analyzing like crazy, they didnt came up with something better then the revelation of last episode?!
I've been so mentalist addicted and now I am just disappointed, then more interesting than anything else,is not the question,who red john is, but the explanation of the whole rj story, making the puzzle fit.
unfortunately nothing of that in the episode "red listed." thumbs down reallly.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So now, after RJ, Jane will have to match wits and talents against this huge corrupt organisation and the show will go on (for the rest of this season and one more after that, tops).

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #6683 • By Kyle
Show this theory

Just a question....for fun...answer with like and unlike :) Will you continue watching The Mentalist if RJ really is an organization as we saw it in last episode? 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on