Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

There is a strange idea in my head, I want to share it.

prolog

Currently we assume that Red John play with Jane his pervert games to have more fun by murding others. The classical reason for a high-level serial killer who wants a strong enemy.
There are a lot of movies or series like good vs. evil. (e.g. Homes vs. Moriaty) I don't think this series just use this old - in the past good working - pattern.

In my eyes, on this point we all were screwed. I think there is a big plot behind the scene. An organisation, which controls private companies and public institutions to rule behind the curtain, is the main bad guy at this show. This fits perfectly with symbolics and code words like "Tyger, Tyger". In our history there a lot of examples like that. (especially the use of christian methaphor)

I don't want to argue again the specific bible lines (apocalypse) or hints (like he is many), because in this board are a lot good explained theories. (please read them to accept that there is more than one bad guy)

main chapter 

Maybe I am totally wrong, but... What if this organisation identify Jane as potential risk for their "work"? He was a public man with a lot of intelligence. You can't kill someone like him easily. But an organisation of such a kind could keep him busy on another "focus". They make it personal to Jane and use Red John to murder his wife and daughter. (rage makes him blind and stubborn, at that point he got distracted)

You will doubt that Jane wouldn't be killed because he was public man. You are right. This is just on piece of the cake. In my opinion there must be a bond between at least on of the top guys with Jane. Currently, I don't know who could be this person. Maybe an unknown relative, an "old" pal of the past or an unreturned love. Red John knows a lot of Janes past. There must be a connection. (direct or indirect).

Why is he a risk? He had a public show at tv where he use his skills to manipulate people. He promise to solve the Red John case easily. Maybe the organisation worked already with Red John. Maybe solving the Red John case would lead to this organisation.

One last fact, that give me good feeling about my theory, is the following. The identity of Red John will be already revealed at the first part of the 6. season. Red John is just one guy (maybe just a tool) of the organisation. I don't think that all the future episodes after the revealing in the 6 season and the whole 7 season episodes will just tell us the story of Red John. I think Jane will hunt this organisation to bring them down.

epilogue
I know that my idea isn't waterproofed. But I don't think that my theory isn't too far of the truth.

Please, feel free to discuss this theory with me. :)

Before I forgot... imho... Ray Haffner fits perfectly Red John.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #7703 • By gugol
Show this theory

Micheal Kirkland is RJ
As so in the scene in the hospital who killed that guy was michael not Bob ,that is why he killed him without take the informotion of who was RJ and in the episode that kirkand menaces Lisbon about Volker was micheal not bob that talked with her and jane
and in the crime scene of Lorelains death was michael again not bob who talks with Jane

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Why Is Ray Haffner it's hard to say, but here comes my theory:
1)His age is perfect, not too old, not too young. He's member of the visualize, which gave him the possibility to draw the smiley at the Barn while he was a teen.
2)His high fits in. 
3)The lover of Rosalind Harker (blind woman) was called Roy (Roy=Ray?) Maybe it's just a coincidence. 
4)The name RJ gave to the psychiatrist was Jay Ross (JR :D) and again Jay= Ray? could be a coincidence again. The psychiatrist affirmed that he is middle-aged, good health, and he has a good posture.
4) Why did RJ left Teresa alive? We all know that Haffner has feeling for Teresa, that could be the reason.
5) Red John must be a person, who's not successful in his real life (not like Bred Stiles), and that's the reason why he need's to create a false identity. Haffner is not consider to be a great mastermind...
6) In S04E02 when Haffner became Jane's boss, he wanted to get information from Cho, and that could have been a good plan, but he didn't knew that they were such a good team, and they will never betray each other. However this shows us that Haffner always makes tactics, and he's sober-minded. Also when Cho said that Jane is smarter than Haffner, Ray has a(n ironic) smile :)
+1 Do you think the man who is working out in such a dark place alone (S06E02) is not a psycho?

Please share with me, your opinions! 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

This is not a theory!
Can anyone send me a link for the promo of season 6 episode 6? i can't find it. Maybe it's because im from Denmark?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Besides the major clue of the tattoo presented in this episode, another subtle clue was shown. Why would Red John need to bug the CBI if he could easily assess the HQ himself. This means that RJ does not have easy access to the CBI. This leaves two viable suspects McAllister and Stiles. McAllister is RJ

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

It would be rubbish if it turned out that
after 10 years of working on this Jane would just recklessly tell Teresa the
names on his list, knowing she'll probably tell Van Pelt - Rigsby - Cho. He is
presented as a brilliant character who isn't too social, at least not in a way
that's considered 'normal', and even when working on 'minor' cases he never
tells his plans to anyone, at least not 'till he solves the case. That's the
reason it'd be really disappointing to just blurt out something this important,
and I really do hope he has some master plan that only he knows about. Plus
I've noticed how they talk about it in the office, and considering half of the
cast of Mentalist is probably RJ’s associates (ok, not half but you get the
picture ;)) and even half of the 7 suspects work there or are connected to CBI
-it just seems stupid, anyone could have bugged the office - and for the moment
I thought maybe Jane wanted that actually, and it’s all a part of above
mentioned plan. As for the list of seven I've changed my mind a couple of
times...Wouldn't mind any of them being RJ if the story that goes with it is
good. The only one I can't swallow is that fat fuck Smith. Oh and yes, that
young man that's going to appear in e8 has similar facial features to both
Haffner and Mcallister (and even Partrigde) with that flat eyebrows and long
nose. I just hope Heller won’t fuck it up royally.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on