Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

NOT ACTUALLY BOB KIRKLAND...HIS TWIN BROTHER MICHAEL!

I believe that Red John is Michael Kirkland.

He is only believed to be dead. He was a 'wild child', Bob tried to help him out, but didn't succeed. He was the victim of an abusive father which would tend to suggest he was not mentally stable and was exposed to violence at a very young age. 

I believe he joined visualize where he would have worked on the visualize farm, taking Acid etc this is where he started his killings.

In one of the more recent episodes, Bob Kirkland asked "do you recognize me" to Haibach..which I think is a clue from the writers.

Finally, it makes sense that Patrick wouldn't recognize Michael as another person he shook hands with, because he would have thought it was Bob Kirkland.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #9290 • By Shakir
Show this theory

I think Bret Stiles is Red John

- He is taller than 6 Feet
- He has Short Straight Hair
- In the last Episode (6) you can see a wound on his left Eye (In the Church) because of the woman
- He didnt show is complete Arm so the Tatoo can be under his shirt (he holds his Arm with his Hand)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #9288 • By Mauricio Stankovic
Show this theory

question:

"Patrick Jane is looking for you": who sent this note to Stiles?
Haffner?

My guesses till now:

Tyger tyger: MacAllister, Smith, Bertram, Lisbon
Visualize: Bret Stiles, Haffner
Red John: Brett Partridge

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Before even starting, I am a huge Partridge fan, so maybe I won't be much objective. Either way, I think there is something in here that deserves a thought.

I think this whole investigation happening after 6x02 is all about the Tyger-Tyger corrupted group (TT). Jane is investigating this and making everyone believe he is chasing Red John, so he can continue his private hunting of RJ.

I believe Partridge said "TT" before he passed away to give a clue about this secret organization. Either because he was killed by TT, either because he faked his death, he is Red John and he is against TT -and he wanted Jane to focus in investigating TT-.

I think the role Red John has been playing in the show is now going to be played by TT: the enemy to be defeated. That is way the writers will introduce the new story at 6x07 (Red dragon -multiple headed dragon by Blake-) and end the previous one at 6x08 (so we will keep on watching the show).

Only Kirkland connected TT with Red John, but I do not think this is the case. Reede did not mention Red John when he told Kirkland about the organization. The 3 current main suspects were discussing something together when Jane walked into Bertram's office. Why if some if them was Red John were they going to be talking about Red John himself? Makes no sense to me.

Why I think Partidge is Red John? A lot have been said about that already: "Red John enters here" sounds too much like not just a coincidence on the pilot to me. The pidgeon flying away in 6x01. They never talked about Partidge's corpse (they talked about Kirkland's death instead).

If Jane is not chasing Red John at the moment, it is because he is sure who Red John is. If all the show at his house was about TT, none of the 5 suspects are Red John. Kirkland I believe is death after the multiple bullets! So only Partidge remains.

Please comment and rate!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Well i have this feeling from episode 7 promo that when PJ tells the cops not to move that when he take off their masks. He'll find someone who's supposed to be dead! Ye Partridge.


No matter what you say. I am not changing my mind about him.
Why would red john want him dead?! Or why would TT ?! I understand they killed Rob coz he was getting close to them & he kills. But why Partridge. And if red john on the list why he didn't appear too on the computer when Lisbon was kidnapped. Did he know and left his phone somewhere else?!!!!

And if RJ killed the PI i think he faked the tattoojust to reveal the TT group to Jane & z world.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I thought it was strange on the new episode how Bret Stiles said he was dying because on the season 4 finale when Jane was talking to Red John in the limo, Red John was talking like he was dying and he was saying when I die, I won't be punished like he was going to die soon. Well that's how I thought of it.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #9283 • By KobeBryant2481
Show this theory

I think there are something hidden in the tyger tyger poem if you compare together with the lamb poem:

"The Tyger" is the sister poem to "The Lamb" (from "Songs of Innocence"),
a reflection of similar ideas from a different perspective (Blake's
concept of "contraries"), with "The Lamb" focusing more goodness. "The
Tyger" presents a duality between aesthetic beauty and primal ferocity.
The speaker wonders whether the hand that created "The Lamb" also
created "The Tyger”

Seems that patrick jane is the lamb and red john is the tiger. So, we can relate red john with "primal ferocity", but with "aesthetic beauty"?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on