Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Come on guys, how can Bertram be Red John?? If someone is bald, he doesn't have short straight hair. And he doesn't have a soft voice, it's the opposite. If Bruno Heller chooses him, he has a lot of explaining to do because it all doesn't make sense at the moment.

In fact, the only person who has a gentle voice and short straight hair is Haffner. I know people here come up with complicated theories and clues, but sometimes we just have to look at simple facts.

But I'm starting to think like hundreds of others here, that Red John is not someone from the list.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Explanation of the events in Jane's house. Small warning, its quite complicated (nothing you mentalists can't handle though.)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Jacobs theory said Gabe Mancini had 666
"he is ma" is "he is Mancini
6x07 promo Jane says that Red John is one of the officers
Robin Tunney would be really surprised if it was him
Brought in on a Bruno Heller episode
Everybody looks at Reede Smith but they don't see the real man involved

Tagliaferro is Italian like Mancini

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Just some observations.  With all of the possible red herrings in this show, take these as no more than possibly being the same.

In 'If it Bleeds, it Leads' Kirkland asks Lisbawn (pronounciation probably doesn't matter, but hey, it was cute) to call him 'Bob'.  

On the list of 7 that Lorelei reads to Jane, all of the suspects names are said aloud in full--with exception of Robert Kirkland whose name is stated as Bob Kirkland.  I find it a bit strange that even the Sheriff's complete name is given.  Same with Raymond Haffner.  Those names could have easily been said/written using only say, 'Tom' or 'Ray'.   Does/did Red John know Bob personally?  Is Bob/Michael Red John?

In 'Red Sails In the Sunset' Bob is talking to someone named Tom before Lisbon comes in--Sheriff?  Tyger Tyger folk?

Furthermore, I'm a bit confused by the events of 'Behind the Red Curtain' where Kirkland (either Bob or possibly Michael) kills Lennon.  Bob/Michael says that if he were ever in Lennon's position--going to jail for murder--that he'd hope he had a friend to essentially kill him as he does with Lennon.  However, Bob doesn't seem too pleased about dying at the hands of Reede Smith despite his imprisonment and inevitable jail time...  Maybe because he couldn't pass on his info to Jane, or because it was Michael in the hospital and not Bob.  (As a side: the talk about Kirkland's tie changing colour is interesting, but it should be noted that at least a day passes until he's wearing a different tie, which to me, doesn't seem too strange.)


One more thing I'm curious about has to do with Partridge.  Why did he say that he had been working Red John's crime scenes since he (Red John) began near the end of Season 5?  In the very first episode he said that he was stoked to finally see one (Red John crime scene) in the flesh...  Maybe he was working in the lab during the first discovered killings?

I also find it strange that Rosalind found Roy's address on a business card as she is blind.  Maybe she had someone read it to her or it had lifted/stamped text she could feel.  I've always thought it was neat how Red John has the same tea cup as Rosalind at the end of Season 1...

I'd like to be surprised by the reveal.  I feel like Patrick has a plan in motion as some of his and the apparent Red John's actions just seem out of the norm--like the tattoo thing (would Red John really allow this info get to PJ by accident?)


Anyways, I think that there's more to the Kirkland thing.  Maybe Michael is Red John, or knows him.  Maybe Partridge will come back, but while I really like Partridge, I always saw Kirkland's character more fitting.  But hey, maybe that's the point.  Maybe Red John shouldn't be who we'd expect at all, he is Red John after all.
 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #9434 • By Jacob
Show this theory

Gale Bertam=666
Alex Jane=666
Gabe Mancini=666

The 666 theory seems to be popular especially with Bertram.
I have found another 2 that make 666.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Concerning this 666 and name-number theory.
http://www.openjs.com/scripts/666.php




Gale Bertram=666


Tom=666


Reede=666


vanPelt=666


Patrick=666


Stiles=666


Raymond=666


Sheriff=666


Robert=666
Red=666
Red John=666
...



Don't think, that this is a clue.

btw. the results, if 666 is in the name, are obviously correct, but the way, that is shown, is wrong. But it works when you sum every value up with 1.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on