Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Before I begin, I should state that I've watched every episode up to episode 6 (Fire and Brimstone). 

I know that lot of people are thinking that Brett Partridge is still alive and that he is Red John. I did have a thought though. In all the best horror movies, unless you actually see the dead body then they're not really dead. Even though Partridge is reported as being dead, we never actually see a dead body. Could he still be alive? Read on.

In a previous theory I wrote, I stated that Tiger Tiger group (TT) is a separate thing from Red John (RJ). What I mean by this is, RJ may be aware of TT and what they do, but is not actually a member. 

Given his number of contacts and influence, RJ could definitely have come into contact with TT members, even if he himself wasn't a member or even in law enforcement. However, I think that RJ must at least have been in law enforcement at one point in order to learn the best ways to leave no evidence at his crime scenes. During this time, maybe TT tapped him up to become a member. But instead, he could have easily persuaded them to help his cause as Red John. He charmed them (in the way a charismatic enigmatic person like RJ could) to help cover up evidence at his murder scenes and maybe even becoming one of his disciples.

I think that Brett Partridge was part of TT. TT has figured out that RJ is using some of it's members to cover up his crimes and is trying to find RJ to weed out those in the organisation who are helping him. They used Partridge as bait, but RJ being one step ahead, called in the anonymous tip that went to Lisbon. That screwed up TT's plans to catch RJ. However they faked Partridge's death and have him locked up in a dungeon somewhere possibly torturing him for info on RJ's identity.

This would explain why Partridge said Tiger Tiger to Lisbon. He felt betrayed and wanted to expose the organisation. Also, if TT have Partridge captive and tortured him for RJ's identity, it would explain the abundance of swat team members outside the house in the promo for the episode The Great Red Dragon, currently available on youtube. They want RJ as much as jane does and are determined not to let him get away.

In addition, Sophie Miller (Jane's ex-therapist) stated on her dictophone the following about Jay Roth (ie Red John):

Mr. Roth came in complaining of a recent issue with severe acrophobia. He’s middle-aged, in good health, with no stated prior history of psychiatric issues. He has no living family, but many friends on whom he relies for company and emotional support. He’s well-spoken, good posture, self-possessed. In the waiting room, he sat calmly in one place, needing no distraction.Though I note, he is an excellent whistler. His self-presentation is pleasant, but there are hints in his behavior of a damaged and narcissistic personality. He says he deals with conflict and adversity easily, though. I’m not convinced he’s being truthful about this. In fact, much of what he said, though spoken convincingly, did not match what I can only call my instinctive response to his presence, though I cannot point to identifiable clinical behaviors that indicate this. I sense something deceptive and dark in his emotional makeup. However, there is every indication that his phobia issues are real whether acrophobia or some other issue remains to be seen.

We have seen that Haffner definitely suffers from arachnophobia. There would be no reason to put in a scene like that to highlight a phobia without very good reason. Haffner is ex FBI and CBI agent, so would have definitely have come into contact with TT members, even if he didn't actually become a member.

Haffner is an ex-football player, probably college as seen by the trophy in his office. The trophy is a heisman trophy, as far as I can tell. "Heisman" - He is ma. Coincidence? Could the victim have been trying to write "heisman" but died before he finished it? Or if the message was supposed to be "he is many" (as a lot people suspect) could this be yet anotherreference to Tiger Tiger?

According to Rosalind Harker (who had a relationship with RJ for a few months) Red John is: 
Just under 6 feet tall. Not muscular but not soft, either. Short straight hair... a gentle voice. Rough, strong hands. This description sums up Haffner quite well (apart from the hands as we can't feel them).

Red John is extremely intelligent, a match for Jane, as seen from his ability to outwit him time and again.   He has twice hacked into the CBI computers without being detected. He sets up phony companies and bank accounts to keep his identity a secret. This would well be within Haffner's abilities; formerly, he was an FBI agent in the Organized Crime Division, and is an expert in wiretaps and creative surveillance techniques.


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I will tell you who isn't Red John. Brett Partridge. The poor chap is dead, get over it. The body didn't just disappear, there was an autopsy done, normal procedure. Patrick Jane isn't that stupid to wipe Partridge from his suspect list if his body just disappeared. Hopefully we can put a rest to these silly theories. 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

SPOILER!!!!!!!!

GALE BERTRAM IS RED JOHN  !!!!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Listen i respect all the work everyone is doing blaming all of the 7 suspects but the list is a ruse . Do you really think Patrick would blindly investigate all suspects while Red john knows he is doing so!?!? That seems crazy. Van pelt is red john or his daughter . Maybe her father died before patrick made his tv remarks fueling rj to kill his family. Van pelt started the same day as patrick and exhibited great hatred towards him at the dinner scene. Ever since i watched the pilot episode i knew it was her . This show is always showing her facial expressions at times you wonder why if shes just a simple cop on the team. Rj has always been one step ahead and sometimes it seems like magic but its Because Rj has been in cbi everyday! Van pelt is savvy with computers yet Rj always seems to hack only her computer. Jane knew lisbon would tell van pelt about the list and is thus playing Rj. The explains why rj didn't kill lisbon now or at any time in the show because van pelt likes lisbon! And think about this and ladies don't get mad at me. Rj seems like a women. Only women play games like this and hold grudges like rj. Rj has a feminine voice. Van pelt has no history she has dated two killers on the show. We know her dad coached football and the character who said he knew rj was a heisman football player ! I forget his name. Please send your comments because the list of 7 isnt legit . Rj wants the tiger tiger group dead and jane is helping rj do this. Loose ends. By making rj think he is focusing on the 7, the TIGRESS is going to reveal herself !!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #9846 • By a10001
Show this theory

To all that don't know mar means disfigured or to disfugre to spoil something or somebody.This is another thing that is the same with the killer form the movie Red Dragon with Hanibal Lector where the serial killer that they try to catch is dissfigured probably like RJ and another thing that is the same is the blind girlfriend Rosalind Harker is Rj girlfriend and in the movie the killer named Toothe Fairy also has a girlfriend that is blind.The last and most important thing is the William Blake connection the Tooth Fairy is transcending in to The Great Red Dragon which is a painting of William Blake and in the mentalist the next episode is called The Great Red Dragon and Tyger Tyger is also a poe of William Blake. 

mar  (mär)tr.v. marredmar·ringmars. To inflict damage, especially disfiguring damage, on.2. To impair the soundness, perfection, or integrity of; spoil.n.A disfiguring mark; a blemish.

Pls watch the movie Red Dragon it may contain clues to Red John's identity and plus its a great movie just like any movie that has Antony Hopkins in it!!!

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0289765/

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So I thought someone should collect all the Red John evidence from the six seasons and post it for everyone to see. Please comment below if you have further important evidence to add.

Rosalind Harker's description:  Under six feet.  Not thin but not muscular.  Straight hair.  Strong hands.  Soft voice.  Enjoyed Bach.  Smelled of pine and earth and nails.

Jared Renfrew:  He claimed Red John was a friend of a friend.  He had once won the Heisman Trophy.  When Renfrew was dying, he wrote on the bathroom wall He Is Mar...

Kristina Frye:  She was hypnotized by Red John into thinking she was dead.  Quite a mental feat.

Lorelei: She says PJ and RJ are just alike.  "I wonder why the two of you didn't become lifelong friends the moment you shook hands."

William Blake:  He quotes the poem to Patrick.  "Tiger, tiger, burning bright.  In the forests of the night.  What immortal hand or eye could frame thy fearful symmetry?"

Sophie Miller:  She describes RJ as a charming man, but with a dark cloud around him.  He was middle-aged, in good health, had no living family but many friends upon which he relied for comfort and support.  She believed he had a real phobia, not necessarily acraphobia, but something else perhaps.  He appeared calm and collective in the waiting room, though I note he is an excellent whistler.

The Red Barn:  Murders were committed at a Visualize farm by Red John in 1988.  His smiley face appears on the Barn outside. Most likely his first kills.

Kira Tinsley:  She was a P.I.  She claimed she was hired by Visualize to bug the CBI office and get close to Cho.  She is later killed and uses her last breath to tell Patrick her attacker has a tattoo, three dots on his left shoulder.  

Okay RJ hunters.  Use this information wisely!  

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #9842 • By F810
Show this theory

mar  (mär)tr.v. marredmar·ringmars. To inflict damage, especially disfiguring damage, on.2. To impair the soundness, perfection, or integrity of; spoil.n.A disfiguring mark; a blemish.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on