Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

So i'll write this theory based only on FACTS and assuming Heller is speaking the truth about Red John being one of the seven suspects on the list, think with me.

Brett Partridge: Dead (Confirmed by Heller and Plotnick as well;

Bob Kirkland: Dead (we all saw it happen, and dont say "Oh, but it could be Michael!" Michael is not on the list, Bob never said that Michael was an IDENTICAL twin, BOB was on the list, BOB, not Michael);

Ray Haffner: Doesn't have the three dots tattoo, is not RJ (First, the recent interview by Michael Logan on a magazine tells us that the secret organization "Tyger, Tyger" was led by Red John, also, the Great Red Dragon trailer tells us that there is left only THREE suspects, REAAALY doubt they would put someone that is not RJ at the trailer, cmon, lets be realistic);

Reede Smith: Really? Do i need to say anything? But i'll say just one thing, Simon Baker said recently that when Patrick finally kills Red John, it felt like he (Simon) was killing an old family member (speaking about the actor, someone who was in the series for a long time).

Brett Stiles: I guess he probably knows Red John's identity, but he does not have the tattoo or the health (recently) to be RJ;

Sheriff Thomas McAllister: Xander would be an AMAZING Red John, no doubt, i guess it could be him, sure, but backing at the GPS tracker scene with Lisbon, Sheriff was in transit, i doubt Red John would say to someone to drive his car with his cellphone just to misslead Lisbon, i dont know, he also looked very scary when Jane saw his tattoo. It could be him, sure.

Gale Bertram: Well, i guess that only leave us with Bertram, after all, he was the cloest on the GPS to where Brett Partridge was killed. When he gets at the crime scene take a look at his reaction when he heard Partridge was the victim. We cannot trust Rosalind Harker description, he was in love with him, she could have lied, she even said that she doesnt care about the problems out there, that she lives in a different world. Bertram is someone who is on the series for a long time, he was at the season finale 3, when Heller said we would see a glimpse of Red John, he is someone that Simon Baker could say it was like kill a familly member. The phonecall after Jane invited him to his house, he was also very calm and etc. I could go on but all of us already knows what points to him. 


::::::: QUESTIONS ABOUT RED JOHN TO BE ANSWERED :::::::

Red John's Voice (even the little girl at the cemetery told Jane he had a weird voice);
"He is Mar";
Brett Partridge's death;
Was he the one (shadow) escaping at Dummar's hut when the police arrives?;
Who killed Rebecca Anderson at the CBI? We can see that person had brown hair;
Who killed Kira Tinsley? That person also had hair (as we can see at the shadow);

Comments aprecciated. Sorry if i typed anything wrong, English its not my native language.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Actually Michael Kirkland, the 'evil brother'.

Makes sense that PJ wouldn't differentiate shaking Bob Kirklands hand from Michael Kirklands if they are twins...possibly identical.

He's the right age, fits all the criteria of the description of red john. He would know Styles from working at the visualise farm, where he committed his first murder and painted the face on the barn.

Also, profiling would suggest that he has been exposed to violence when he was growing up through an abusive father.


I think it's very plausible, and would be the type of story line that this tv show would take.

Thanks for reading,

Stu

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

He does look like the sheriff, doesn't he?
Looking at this picture and if this boy is really the young Red John, I think he can only be McAllister.




http://postimg.org/image/v7yat25cl/

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Its amazing how many people think "Brett Partridge is dead, so he can't be RJ." Its like they don't even watch the show. They think its "poor writing," when they make it quite obvious they aren't even capable of following clues...

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I would find it strange if Bertram is RJ. If Bertram is RJ why on earth would he hire a PI to bug the CBI? Why wouldn't do it himself? 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

i think that RJ is Ray Haffner. of course i'm not sure, but i have some reasons.
first of all, when partridge died, why RJ didn't kill lisbon? there could be different reasons but haffner said in different occasions that he liked lisbon...

moreover, RJ is a person who can act very well, and at Jane's house he was the least suspectable

in addition, Kyra said that RJ had a tatoo, so she had to see RJ's shoulder...but obviously RJ could be aware of this and could hid his tatoo in some way...

one more thing: we have to remember that RJ had a love story with Lorelei Martins...she was very beautiful, i can't see her with Smith, or Bertram or Sheriff McAllister o.O
i think a woman like Lorelei could be attracted only by Haffner or Kirkland...

last thing: Kirkland is dead..but is twin brother?he has never been found...

i apologise for my mistakes but i'm not english :)
i appreciate any comments :)

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Not a theory but I'll just like to point this out.. I'm so excited to see Jane get his revenge and finally know 100% who Red John is. 
Since the reveal of Red John is coming up soon I started re-watching all the old episodes again and when I got up to Season 2 Episode 8, when Red John got Bosco and his team killed, reminded me how much I despise this man. 

No matter who it is I'll be satisfied, just as long as it's not Reede!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on