Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Theory #10337 • By utkarsh
Show this theory

ok guys, to add to my previous reasons from the post just below.

1-  Minelli has been twice brought into the show after his resignation in season 2. now both of them were unnecessary you could say, or atleast the one in the santa episode.
2- dont you think heller would make sure the red john person is faded from the memory of people for some seasons so they get that ah moment. many would have even forgotten minelli.

3- in the 100 episode alexa shultz and bob kirkland are brought into the show in the end requesting red john things from minelli. just to divert attention maybe?
and kirkland is shown deliberately to be creepy imo. and then he is made to kill jason lennon under very suspicious circumstances.

4- ellis mars and todd johnson are brought into the picture soon thereafter to divert the attention.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10335 • By Brigmorewitches
Show this theory

 

After all that happened in the
last episode,i can't believe that some people still believe that one of the 7
on the "List" is Red John. I knew that the list would be fake and i'm
so glad that it is. The list was made to narrow down the members of that secret
organisation (Tyger),which revealed 4 of them were affiliated with RJ. Patrick
obviously killed 3 of them then blew up the building taking haffner and stiles
with him elsewhere. But the thing that puzzles me the most is why he kept
Lisbon out of it in the last second. Maybe he thinks she's frinds with RJ or he
did not want law enforcement involved (since he was gonna kill 3 cops for gods
sake).

 

Anyhow,i hope more episodes like
this one happen! it was very exciting.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

probably Rj has not the 3 dots tattoo. Maybe it was planned by Rj. But, you realized that both without the dots are from visualize? Only those who work for the police (tiger tiger) have it. My theory about making us think as a visualize thing may become true. Leaving us to Bret Stiles, with Ray reaveling him self át. The last moment.

Ray still with the clark kent face.

Like someone said. Bruno was honest with the list, he wont be with the tatto.

Would be interesting someone killing RJ or he dying for others causes. So it wouldn't be obvious.

Bruno said he'll be gone by the end of the season, but the audience could find out at the last moment it's Ray, and Keep PJ thinking it's Stiles, who would pretend to be RJ.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Theres something wrong. First Bruno started to kill the most popular suspects, then left enough connections for any one of the suspects, making us think if RJ was changed during the show.

1- come on, Why PJ would think Rj will accept his threat knowing he was a suspect and there were a plan there to get him? And PJ could do better, more technologies, tranqüilizer dart to get everyone to sleep, bullet proof vest, a place no one could escape, locking automatically all the doors, recording everything and sending through internet, in case Rj gets him first. Looked like western movies. It's a ten Years revenge on someone "impossible" to get. Threating everyone into a meeting?

2- i don't like the theory of the list Being fake. Would be cheating for me. anyway, Rj thinks it's real. Would you go to that meeting? I would kill PJ, if i accept trying not to be more suspicious, i knew i had friends there, which would pretend to be me. But i would prepare something (probably not only PJ made tricks there).

3- i like Sherrif as a characther, He's my second suspect, but he didnt appear enough. He's calm, instinctive, hunter, likes PJ, but was the most unexpected suspect of the list, it's like anyone could be Rj before this season, and there were not enough connections before to be a real puzzle.


4- i agree with someone who said that maybe only someone undead coming to be Rj, would bring something interesting to the end. I definitly did not like that meeting. Too common during the show and unplausible for the situation (only dangerous people who knew they were suspect).

5- Bruno followed a smart path, if he cant erase the clues that made people find out who Rj is, it's a good way to make more clues to the others suspects.
I don't know who he is, but Ray Haffner Keeps his clark Kent face and has not more clues (except the spider, subtle clue compared to the others)

Thanks for reading, let's want more from the next shows.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Wtf guys you say that only partrige and bertram are on imdb list i just viewed the cast list so either im blind or you are dumb but 

I CANT SEE neiter patrick jane, or lisbon or anyone else from the team on the list. so how can you even say that one of partrige and bertram is red john the description clearly says that Jane meets RJ face to face,  so Baker must be in the episode.

Or else i have a theory that might be possible the Jane RJ contact shown in episode 8 will be from their past, maybe when they met the first time as still teenagers or something like that, Jane will be dreaming or just thinking about the past and the whole episode will be shown like that. we will know who is rj at the end of 8 and jane will know who is rj by the and of 8 but the actual contact in the present time wont exist not yet in episode 8.

my theroy, sorry for bad english hope you understood it. byebye

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on