Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Theory #10572 • By Basics19_
Show this theory

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3196216/

He is still there? What happened "anyone" , why can't you change it haaa? maybe you are just making up ha? Mushburn is still there ????

If ı were red john I would certainly kill kind of people like you,best when making something up without giving any effort to understand facts.You do not deserve to breathe,oxygen you breath just a waste in your brains.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3196216/

All of you saying "Anyone can change IMDB cast list ,this doesn't mean anything",ok 

Can one of "anyone" inside you please remove Mushburn from there? 

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10560 • By Theoldgal again
Show this theory

None of these are the killers patrick jane did his own family in n could not accept it he blames a red john character for everything because he leaves in his own disturbed world in a hospital for the insane.
Red john is probably a dr somebody with red hair all these suspects are either patience in a hospital or the staff
Once his boss said , "I am many things to many people." Because he probably ran the hospital
Jane is disillusioned and cannot grip with the real world because f the crime he did.
My guess is blue skies will be a wake up episode odd what's really going on in the present reality. Green thumb will more than likely show him planing trees on the mediums of the highways when they send him to prison for life

This is called the mentalist jane is all about manipulating people minds
I think we have all been had

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10561 • By Theoldgal again
Show this theory

None of these are the killers patrick jane did his own family in n could not accept it he blames a red john character for everything because he leaves in his own disturbed world in a hospital for the insane.
Red john is probably a dr somebody with red hair all these suspects are either patience in a hospital or the staff
Once his boss said , "I am many things to many people." Because he probably ran the hospital
Jane is disillusioned and cannot grip with the real world because f the crime he did.
My guess is blue skies will be a wake up episode odd what's really going on in the present reality. Green thumb will more than likely show him planing trees on the mediums of the highways when they send him to prison for life

This is called the mentalist jane is all about manipulating people minds
I think we have all been had

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Theory #10559 • By Stoopkid
Show this theory

Has anyone noticed that something is definitely wrong with grace? She was just married and ever since this rj stuff happened she has been wearing a blank depressed look on her face...what could it be? I have posted many times accusing her as being rj but i havent even seem anyone question how she has been acting. Weird relationship she has with styles too. Any thoughts ?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I am Mystic Ryan. I travelled back in time to give you spoilers. Here goes:

1. Brett Partridge is Red John; leader of Tiger, Tiger

2. Ray Haffner, in Visualise is RJ's friend and killer associate. He was in the door opposite.

3. Michael Kirkland killed Jason Lennon.

4. Reede Smith killed Michael Kirkland.

5. Reede Smith, Gail Bertram and Sherriff Thomas McAllister turned out to be undercover agents in "Tiger, Tiger."

6. Bret Stiles is RJ's father.

7. "Brett Partridge" was just another alias.

8. Brett Partridge was related to Elise Vogelsong.

9. Patrick Jane is related to Brett Partridge.

10. Patrick kills Brett Partridge in "MacArthur Park."

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I like the popular Brett Partridge theory that has gathered many plausible hits. It's well noticed and actually seems very likely to be true. It's that kind of perception why I come to websites like this one. The fishing hat thing and Patrick only mentioning two murders was nicely picked up, kudos.

In case it isn't Partridge, how do you fellas comment on the behaviour of Gale Bertram in the tattoo scene? When you look at him as a character throughout the series, he does seem like a red herring the actor was talking about in the TV Guide article. He has a presence, powerful position, whistles well, and in that scene after PJ and Lisbon exit his office upon inviting him to Patrick's house, not only is Lisbon's face different, but Bertram suddenly uses this soft voice to speak to whomever was on the other side of the line. He looks more worried than the others after the meet and whistles prior to placing the call. Also, he isn't necessarily calling someone he's supposed to keep in the loop - he may be calling a minion who will help get to the bottom of things. He has the tattoo, as well, though I am not sure that signifies.

During the tattoo scene, Bertram is trying the hardest to calm PJ down and make him drop the whole thing, while after his should is revealed his stare is blank and empty and definitely looks creepy. I don't know if anyone noticed, but you can go back to the moment when the camera shows the tattoo on his shoulder. Incidentally, he's also the last one to reveal the tattoo.

Also from before, after Lorelei tells Patrick about the handshake, there's a scene where Jane bumps into Kirkland at the office, they quickly shake hands and go about their business while the camera stays put and shows a picture of Bertram on the office wall, literally moments after the handshake. I've never seen anybody mention this moment before, which I found odd.

Anyway, has it been confirmed that we get a double dose of the show on Sunday or is it just speculation? It would be mighty cool of CBS to give us a two-parter, to close the Red John saga in a marathon.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on