Who is Red John?

Share your own theory and rate other people’s

List of seven

Thomas McAllister
Thomas McAllister
Reede Smith
Reede Smith
Ray Haffner
Ray Haffner
Gale Bertram
Gale Bertram
Brett Partridge
Brett Partridge
Bret Stiles
Bret Stiles
Bob Kirkland
Bob Kirkland

LATEST THEORIES

Ok i need to change peoples perspectives because the list is working too well as a distraction.
1. Bertam. Yea he has pull but for god sake hes dumb . No way he has the smarts to be rj. Plus the show makes him look like hes the bad guy recently thus deff making him not the bad guy. Plus hes bad at poker , come on!
2. Reed smith. Do i even have to explain why hes not rj? Hes fat. Hes dumb. Hes in tiger tiger . I have a milliom other reason why buy its a waste of time
3. Sheriff macallister- one again rj is not a member of tiger tiger . Macalister is also not smart enougj. Hes not a heartthrob with many wives . He
4. Haffner- prob the most likely but deff not rj. Once again hes always outsmarted by jane . He seemed legititmitly hurt when lisbon said he could be rj. And o yea hes dead from the blast so
5. Kirkland. Dead. He thought his twin was rj so he asked the cop if "he recognized him" beciase if rjs follower knew his face then his bro could of been rj. Get it? But the cop said no so
6. Brett styles . He was my pick when i first saw the list. But hes not rj. Styles has his own stuff going on. He doesnt care about battling pj. He is dying . He cares about his church. He may know who rj is tho which is interesting .
7. Partridge. Everyones favorite pic for some reason but this isnt the show bones lol. He is creepy and killerlike but he's not smart like rj. He doesn't seem like a guy who has 12 wives too and can bang Lorelei. Plus HES DEAD!!!!!!!!!!!! Were gonna find out why he's dead soon cuz heller said it was important why he died .
So people i love the discussions but the list is just a trick to force rjs hand. In chess u make a move so that ur opponent thinks they have u and after ur enemy makes that move them you checkmate!!'n

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Make sure to watch this scene 100 times before you watch episode 8:


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKZvmwU1ufg


It will make you almost explode with excitement.

And btw RJ is indeed Ray Haffner.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I'm kinda new to this forum, didn't know it existed before my son showed
it to me, and since then I been a regular, and one thing thats striked
me , was that even tho a lot of us had diffrent theories about who RJ
is, it always was a good tone between the users, latly that has somehow
changed, I mean I can read a theory about let's say Reede Smith being RJ
and even tho I personally would be very dissapointed if it turned up to
be him, most of the theories I read make sense, because we are all
dedicated to make a great theory showing why we suspect the person we
suspect, I don't tell ppl to stop posting theories only because I don't
like who they think RJ is.

And to be frank I don't like it when
ppl call other ppl theories for crap or Bs, just because we have a
diffrent opinion, I think Partridge is RJ and I will post as many
theories I like about that, and I want change my mind before it's revealed who it is.

I
even click plausible on theories that have another suspect as RJ, just
because it's so many red herrings in this show , that alt of theories is
plausible, that's one of the many things that keep this show so great.

Here you can read my theory , but I warn you my suspect is BP

http://www.whoisredjohn.com/See-a-theory-Red-John/9976


Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

My reason for posting is to ask a question:  I don't understand the layout of Jane's house.  He enters through the front door, goes upstairs to look at the bedroom with the smiley face and then leaves through a back door, crosses a courtyard and then enters a second building.  The second building is also his because it has his safe.  

Lisbon pulls up in front of the first building, presumably sees the lights of the second building through the window and runs around to get there.  But all of the suspects appear to pull right in front of the second building, no questions asked.    

The second building explodes.  

So, firstly, what's the deal with Jane's house?  Is there like a pool house or something?
Secondly, how would the bomber know which building to bomb?  
Thirdly, how do the suspects know to go to the second building?  Jane's car is parked in front of the main house.  You would think that each person would do what Lisbon did (park in front and then walk around) rather than parking right in front of the second building. 

It does make me think that either a) Jane planted the bomb himself and didn't want to blow up his main home or b) one of the suspects brought it in with him, making him an RJ associate taking one for the team thereby suggesting that RJ is not one of the 5 -- or 7? -- but rather holds a grudge against this lot.

Still don't know how they would know to go to the "pool house".  

Ideas?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Bob Kirkland's twin brother is RJ. We have seen him killing a RJ follower just recovered from a coma. Bob Kirkland was killed just to confuse us!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think the IMDb list is unreliable. They change it all time!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Umm if the list was real rj wouldt of bombed himself. We gotta start thinking like jane and stop picking people just becuase we like them

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on