Every time someone says Red John was McAllister,

We say "Bitch, please, stick to commenting on the weekly murder mystery."

Repost corrections:
Someone just corected me , thought i heard "beg" when PJ Said
"break", so i Will just correct it, but it still
makes a lot of sense..


I dont know If anybody already posted this,
but in s.6 e.7 PJ & Lisbon are talking
after Reede was Interviewed and PJ Said
"Red John would never break like that, not even
in an act"!!
I find that very contradictory.. In the "RJ reveal"
the sheriff is without a doubt VERY MUCH
BREAKING DOWN!! I a very stupid
non-believable Way..

Maybe its BAD story-writing
OR
very GOOD

My point is that All we have been shown is that
RJ has a lot of pride and dignity (in his own
Psyko-Way) that is after All, the Whole
reason for RJ to kill PJ's wife and daughter
Why a sudden change in Intelligence and
persona? Cause that was not the REAL RJ
who broke down, begging, in that Church..


Maybe it Was a little hint and hope
to those of us who still dont Believe
the real RJ is not yet revealed

So the question is still. WHO IS RED JOHN?

Sorry my bad english, I am Danish ;-)

I dont know If anybody already posted this,
but in s.6 e.7 PJ & Lisbon are talking
after Reede was Interviewed and PJ Said
"Red John would never beg like that, not even
in an act"!!
I find that very contradictory.. In the "RJ reveal"
the sheriff is without a doubt VERY MUCH
BEGGING for his life!! I a very stupid
non-believable Way..

Maybe its BAD story-writing
OR
very GOOD

Maybe it Was a little hint and hope
to those of us who still dont Believe
the real RJ is not yet revealed

Sorry my bad english, I am Danish ;-)

On the first day of the Christmas Bruno Heller gave to me! A Partridge as a Red John!

Hi everyone,

I was checking the 6x01, and I saw two interesting things....

1.- One second before Lisbon was going down to the floor, she looks to the bathroom and seems to saw something wrong... it's some king of yellow cloth... it can be a Forensic bag for dead bodies?? Still thinking in a body to fake Partidge's dead or Mcallister dead...

2.- I read here before a theory that explain that when RJ call PJ with Lisbon phone seems to be two people on the house... and if you check carefully, the first answer of RJ we're lloking PJ, but the second, it's at the same time, that he's had on one hand the weapon and with the other hand take blood from it... How can speak with cellphone at the same time???? (with a freehand system?? like Partidge on Pilot???) there are someone else on the room talking with cellphone, or holding??
It's clear for me that this is on propose... if not... why RJ make two things at the same time?? It's easier if he draw lisbon's face and then make the call looking his piece of "art"....

What you think???

The site has changed for the worse

There seems to be a trend of less theorizing and more hating. If you like hating, you've come to the right place. But if you want to make a red john theory you're no longer welcome here. It used to be the opposite.

We should get this website to 10.000 theories and then let it go :).