Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Grace Van Pelt

Grace Van Pelt
Suspected in 303 theories

THE THEORIES

So since jane, bertram, and smith didnt die in the blast or even get that hurt from it? Seems like the blast was a diversion and a way to fake deaths . I mean styles has the perfect motive. If the bomb went off in the house with jane and rest then they'd all be dead right ? Or a little more scathed right ? Weird.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok so i just concluded that the bomb in janes house had to go off after jane was unconscious. When he tries to recollect what happened it stops right before the gunshot. Jane bertram and smith all survived becuase they were in the house when it exploded . They were placed there . Styles haffner and macalister fakes their deaths. One of em is shot it dead from that shot . The bomb was a elaborate scheme to most likely fake styles death as he arranged with patrick earlier it seems . I think macalister is helping jane . Hes the only member of tiger tiger who seemed to like jane and want to help him . He doesn't seem to be merely helping jane because he is guilty from tt and wants to know what jane is on too. I get the feeling he legitimately wants to help jane find rj. Now rigsby and van pelt may be styles followers and set the fire to help
Styles. I dont think pj was in on it since he has no memory of how it went down. If van pelt and rigsby helped him does that make him rj? Idk but i doubt it . Styles has other motives . Being jesus for his church is top priority. Haffner also could of helped since he obvi follows styles . Either rj is styles or someone not in the house . Hmmm

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Partridge is dead . They deff checked his body but the mark on his arm is weird . Did he do it and was planning on leaving tiger tiger ? Did tt kill him and scratch off evidence or did rj scratch it off and why?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hit plausible if you think jane knows who red john is . Also if you believe the list was a ruse to force rjs hand . And when jane says hes "letting go" you take this to mean he is watching the dominoes fall and is waiting for rj to make his move
Or
Hit un plausible if you think jane has no clue. Was really set on his list and now doesnt know what to do and is "letting go" literally .

And for chuckles whats up with van pelt !!'

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok why post 3 pages about the same old theory about partridge, haffner , and Bertram and the kirkland brothers over and over . The longer your post is the more your wrong because your fishing and justifying in your head as your write. Lets expand our minds. Lets not fall into the promo trap. Lets delve into topics that are possible but also outside the box . Don't be afraid. This show should be called the mentaltwist. Its about stuff you didn't see coming . Its about saying "how did he do that" its about pjs luxurious hair from heaven. I think the show is foreshadowing a twist with rigsby and van pelt. Bonnie and clyde. Ive posted a million clues about van pelt . Rigsby has caught my eye recently . Think about how much he knew about bertram last episode. Or the weird scene when he asks everyone but looking at choe only "so were ok withe killing our boss" . He's an arson specialist . He was a big suspect of La roche when the cop was set aflame. He had a baby mamma out of nowhere. The episode started with him saying "red john used explosives to kill jane and the others. Lets talk about this. The outer limits . We beat all the other theories to death no pun intended . The people on the list were always a ruse . Lets go!

How did reed smith have van pelts direct line and ask for her specifically ?'!!!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

So it was weird that reede smith called van pelt by name on his burner phone right ? And why rigsby didnt think that was weird too?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I think a lot of people misunderstand the story. Why a lot of you thinking that Jane and Red John knows eachother from a long time, e.g. when they were kids? I think RJ started to kill not because of Jane, but Jane wanted to stop him/her and hurt the ego of RJ.
My theory is that something misterious happened in the house of Jane. Maybe somebody shoot the sheriff, e.g. Haffner or Stiles. Or Jane released them, and only focused on the 3 with tattoo's. Or faked this all, it was only for Red John, and he didn't want to hurt either of them, even if they are mad. I think that something is like that.
But my main suspect is Grace Van Pelt or Rigsby. A read that at least two people will prove to be smarter than we think. I think one of them will be Rigsby. I read a lot of theories, so my thoughts are in a whirl.
Let's see what happens!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on