Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Grace Van Pelt

Grace Van Pelt
Suspected in 303 theories

THE THEORIES

So this guy "truthliesinlogic" is biggest idiot i have ever encountered . He disses ever theory i write and all he has to say is that isnt logical to be right. Wow. Is this show logical people ? Is this show not based on misdirection and trickery? Come one ! Heres his response to me saying it looks like rigsby is plausable
Suspect becuase he was questioned by la roche about setting the cop on fire . I said who else would use fire as means of quieting a suspect his answer ...
----"Who else would use fire? Fire departments in practice sessions for trainees to learn how to properly fight fires. People cooking with gas ranges. People lighting pilots on hot water tanks, furnaces ect. People starting fires in fireplaces. Etc. etc. etc. All legal to do, and completely unrelated to arson."

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Even LaRoche said Todd Johnsons's killer had to have knowledge of the sophisticated CBI fire safety system, as well as how to disarm it. Rigsby admitted he had such capability. Rigsby was also highly knowledgeable about the accelerants used on Todd Johnson's person. Rigsby is a plausible suspect and if i hear one more person use the word LOGIC i will scream! This show is about twists, the illogical, and surprises ! Macalister is in the promo becuase he is NOT red john. No way they would
Spill the beans after this many years of secrecy on a silly promo! I mean the promo makes u think jane shoots rj in a church? He kills him in a park so yea

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Something is up with grace and rigsby. First of all rigsby is am arson specialist so the bomb looks like it coulda been him. Plus he was the suspect for the cop set on fire in cbi he would be the guy who knew how to do that! Who else would use fire? Plus last episode he seems to know alot anout bertram secrets that nobody knew. Vam pelt likes bad guys . It was weird cuz the camera was always showing graces expression and nobody else that means something . And guys its not macalister ! The promo makes u think its him therefore its not! Please stop with this LOGIC shit cuz this show is about twist and reede smith looked like rj in the last promo. I love fans that fall for the obvious and call it the logic explanation for macalister . Stop! The show wouldnt let u know the biggest secret ever in a promo ! Please be real

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok i am gonna start small. Do you find it plausible that there is something up with gvp? Or do you find it plausible that the show is showing that there is something up with her. Thought the dramatic scenes we always see her face on camera and nobody else . After the fbi dude said his bit it was all her . What are they trying to tell us? Gosh darn foreshadowing driving me crazy

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok i am gonna start small. Do you find it plausible that there is something up with gvp? Or do you find it plausible that the show is showing that there is something up with her. Thought the dramatic scenes we always see her face on camera and nobody else . After the fbi dude said his bit it was all her . What are they trying to tell us? Gosh darn foreshadowing driving me crazy

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

No way in hell they woulda showed sherriff macalister in the promo if he was red john so hes not him. Bertram is far from rj. Patrick did that to lure him in. The voice is nobody we could think of. Nobody talks like that! But its someones true voice that they have been hiding ...wonder who?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

No way in hell they woulda showed sherriff macalister in the promo if he was red john so hes not him. Bertram is far from rj. Patrick did that to lure him in. The voice is nobody we could think of. Nobody talks like that! But its someones true voice that they have been hiding ...wonder who?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on