Who is Red John?

All theories about

« See the other suspects

Patrick Jane

Patrick Jane
Suspected in 673 theories

THE THEORIES

If Red John is still alive...
He is not a he !
This guy has no ego whatsoever even though we are led to believe he is a ego maniac.
-jane eluded to this in "white lines"

Red John only works though Jane.
Timothy Carter took his place and Red John did not freak out, he waited until agent Darcy was bothering jane to show himself. It had nothing to do with letting the world know it was more about getting Darcy off Janes back. Hooking Jane up so to speak.

Then Red John let his legacy end with Bertram. Macalister was cool with letting the world know that Bertram was Red John and him and Jane killed each other in the church.
Ego maniacal? A serial killer would never let someone else take his place in the bloody hall of fame.

I gather from all this that Red John is a woman or is Patrick Jane himself.
Its weird that a serial killer cares about one guy so much. All Red John ever wanted was for Jane to join him. Join him in what? "Imagine the life we could lead"...

Lorelie- will she make a return? Her lifeless body had not one scratch where the gunshot wound was suppose to be. And i would say it was bad writing but she had the bloody bandage on her arm in the dvd. She may of been fbi, because she seemed more like a hired gun than a simple brainless Rj pawn.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Ok back to business. No rest for the wicked.
I am not trying to guess who Red John is and win a cookie or anything.
But i do have some ideas to throw out there because
A LOT of us know and feel that a big surprise
is on its way.

1: Marcus Pike- Lisbons new boy toy with darkness in his eyes.
He will obviously butt heads with Jane but there may be more to him.
Jane joined the FBI which was a past enemy of Cbi to get a closer look at them.
Rememebr the fishbowl line?
The fbi was always shady especially when they stole Lorelie. Shit Lorelie may of been FBI.
He is Mar cus pike. Maybe Rj found Renfrow so fast because he knew the hooker...
Maybe she was leaving a clue that we all wished would be explained. Maybe.
Also an amigo informed me that the actor is gay in real life.
Could be a great fit for a serial killer who has a crush on Jane.

2: Visualize- Creepy Cooper, Zombie Haffner or Styles- You never know with these weirdos.
Red Johns followers sound like Visualize memebers.

3. Kristins Freye- A Red John apologist. The only Red John supporter in the show who is not a follower.
"Imagine the life we could lead". Always wants Patrick to admit she has powers. Red john is always trying to recruit Jane. Which is another reason why Macalister was a pawn. Mac never said anything about Jane joining him
and RJ kept Jane alive all these years because he/she wanted him to join. Rj is in love with Jane. Roll tide.

4. Cbi Ron- Wheres Waldo? Why did the writers boost Ron's appearances
in episodes 1-8? Why was he at the hospital when his partner and the rest of the squad was at Cbi?
Why didn't he stop a man with a gun chasing Jane and GVP?
Did Ron answer Lisbons phone when Jane called?
Ronbon has a office crush on Lisbon maybe ? Haha Ronbon

Suspicious:
Agent Fischer- " i was hired to spy on you"-Fischer to Jane
"Me and my team were just about to search this whole island for you"-Abbot to Jane
Her demeanor says everything else as well as her magic wand.

Wylie- ehh why not right?

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Why would Haibach wait 2 years to seek his revenge!!!!!
His thumb gets cut off and he wait 2 years to do anything? NO.
Haibach started his revenge with Grace Van Pelt
He only started because he was made a suspect by the fbi.

Ardilles was murdered by someone else. Who would want him dead?
This is something to think about at least..

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

Hi guys...

in the fourth season red john had told lorelai to cut Patrick`s finger.
in the sixth season Bob kirkland had cut Haibach`s finger.
And in the last night episode Haibach wanted to cut off Patrick`s finger.
interesting....

in addition rigsby is shot and Patrick did not do anything.it is very unreasonable.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

I cant even leave my house today i am so embarrassed ;) Just playing, this shit is not about me you gosh darn trolls!!
Haha I am a writer believe it or not. I like to write and honestly don't care about being right. I was just trying to entertain you guys and I hope I succeeded in that.
But I liked the episode. It had my heart racing and I thought It was executed well. Could of been better yes, but i am not picky.

I know you guys don't want to hear this but Haibach was NOT behind the cbi hit-list. He simply reacted because he found out he was a suspect again and the last time he was a suspect bad things happened to him.
No way he stabbed Ardilles like that!
No way he had the technological wherewithal to tap all those phones.

We are still in for a huge surprise later in the season. The writers for episode 22 wrote every red john episode together.
Jane said "we need to break the pattern" and thats exactly what the show did. We all though red john was behind this and he wasn't but fear not because there is a much bigger darker force behind this whole big hit-list thing.
Seriously all those random names on the list Haibach has never even heard of those people let alone wanted to kill them all!
Keep the faith :)
My new list of suspicious suspects:

Cooper
Fischer
Wylie
Haffner
Freye

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

White as the driven snow = It was a waste of time.

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely

People have it twisted.
If red john is dead it really is not that big a deal.
People think i will wither away and die! Haha
Its a tv show people and this website is called
Whoisredjohn.com so i post about clues regarding red john.

There are so many hateful people on here . So filled with anger and dismay for me and the show.
Everybody calm down!
Formerman needs to be committed and have a talk with sophie miller .
If you dont like the show go away! Stop watching it and move on.
Instead you stay on here trolling telling me to move on!
Don't worry about me i will be fine, i love this show and am just happy its still on.
Get ready for some twist and turns because mentalist finales are usually wild!

Argue on this theory or rate it.
plausible
unlikely
Follow us on